Re: [apps-discuss] Request for review: draft-arkko-ipv6-only-experience-04

[Jari Arkko <[e-mail]>]

Dave,

> On Thu Dec  1 15:21:34 2011, SM wrote:
>> Could you review draft-arkko-ipv6-only-experience-04 before December 15?  Please post your review to apps-discuss (see below), and DO NOT post it to apps-review.
>
> This is a great document. I will certainly read it again, and I may update my review as a result.
>
> I haven't particularly been looking for editorial issues; none stood out.

Thanks for your comments!

>
> I noticed that whilst some detail was provided well, other details were missing (which XMPP clients were used, for instance - I'm reasonably sure that while many support IPv6, some do not).

We should add this information.

>
> The choice of games seems odd as well - while Rome: Total War remains a popular RTS for a number of reasons, it's also very old. Crysis is comparitively old, too, as is Battelfield (now up to its second sequel).

I'll pass along your note to my kids :-)

> It'd be interesting to see whether more modern games actually support IPv6, in particular for LAN play, given that Win7 typically acquires LAN IPv6 addresses.  I'll see if I can find out a little more information here.

Yes, indeed, and WoW in particular we hear now has the support. But I have not tested it (my kids don't have it...) If someone else could report on that it would be great.

>
> Overall, though, this could be published as-is, and would be a valuable addition to the Informational corpus.
>
> Dave.

Thanks again.

Jari