Re: [Bimi] Guidance Document - Refactor input

[Zack Aab <[e-mail]>]

$0.02 worth:
The info is already there in various places, but since BIMI might require
some organizations to add brand new code, an explicit "example mail agent
workflows" section that is simply all of the BIMI-related actions (*what*
action, not *how*) taken by the MTA, MUA, etc., would probably be helpful.
I also think something along the lines of the "minimum implementations"
section in the DMARC RFC https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc7489#section-8
would be valuable.

*Zack Aab* (He/Him)
Senior Consultant, Trendline Interactive
*O* [phone] <[phone]> | *C* [phone] <[phone]>
| *W* trendlinei.com <https://www.trendlineinteractive.com/>


On Wed, Apr 7, 2021 at 4:56 PM Brotman, Alex <Alex_Brotman=
[e-mail]> wrote:

> Hello folks,
>
> We're looking to refactor the existing Receiver Guidance document to be
> more general purpose.  We thought we'd reach out to others on the list to
> see what areas they believe we should touch on.  We wanted the new
> iteration of the document to be something that can be referenced by all
> parties involved with BIMI such as Receivers, Senders, ESPs, Logo
> Designers, MUA authors, and so on.   We do intend to move over some of the
> existing content, so those have been included below.
>
> We started a rough outline of sections to cover, and we'd welcome
> feedback.  Thanks for any input you could provide.
>
>
> # Abstract
> # Introduction
> # Goals for BIMI
> # Should you implement BIMI?
> ## As a Receivers
> ## As a Brands
> # Terms
> # Sections covered below (definitions of each group)
> ## Receivers
> ### Site implementation
> ### Validation of a BIMI message
> #### Additional requirements
> ### Retrieval of image files
> #### TTL for cached images
> ### VMC Root of Trust
> ## Senders/ESPs
> ### DMARC for Customers
> ## Brands
> ### Obtaining a VMC
> ### Logo Hosting Considerations
> #### CDN Considerations
> ## MVAs
> ## Logo Designers
> ### Known Issues
> ### Adherence to SVG P/S
> ### Tools and Caveats
> ## MUA Creators
> ### Image Dispay
> # Privacy Concerns
> # FAQ
>
>
> --
> Alex Brotman
> Sr. Engineer, Anti-Abuse & Messaging Policy
> Comcast
>
> --
> bimi mailing list
> [e-mail]
> https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/bimi
>