Re: Last Hurdle

[[e-mail] (Dan Romascanu)]

> Last hurdle?????
> 
> Hold on here.  I don't yet feel confortable
> with the responses to the clarifying questions.
> 
> Also, havn't seen a high return rate to Jeff
> indicating that this MIB can be even implemented.
> 

My impression is that the high rate of messages on the list
(I would also say that they are competent and well articulated)
indicates that people are highly interested in this MIB.
I also think that we must not always look for the lowest denominator.
Even if some aspects cannot be implemented from the begining by
everybody, what we should get is a consensus thet this is the right
way of describing the objects we want to manage, that the solution is
needed and that it is technically implementable at at reasonable price.
 
> For me to feel confortable, with this MIB, the
> following items need to be done:
>   1) Diagrams and text that explain the
>      chassis models that the MIB is providing
>      information about.
>   2) An updated MIB document (with dates and
>      versions on it) posted in internet-drafts.
>   3) Results from a poll indicating which sections
>      of the MIB can be implemented.
> WHere are we with these?

I do fully agree. We should have first #2) formally done, (can you do it,
Dave A., taking into account the contributions on the list?). Then, for
the IETF meeting we should prepare material and discuss #1), despite
the fact that I think most of us have the same models in mind. The last
point #3) will result from discussions, or we can have a poll on each
section.  
  
> 
> /dave perkins, synoptics, 408-764-1516
> 
> 

[e-mail]

Dan Romascanu
Systems Group Manager

LANNET Data Communications Ltd.
Tel Aviv, ISRAEL

Voice: 972-3-6458414
Fax:   [phone]