Re: [Detnet] 1st stage of WG adoption poll: draft-dt-detnet-dp-sol

[Stewart Bryant <[e-mail]>]

I will do a detailed review a bit later, but I think we need to mark the 
IPv6 encapsulation as undecided, and I think that we need to have a 
serious discussion in the WG about the proposal to perform an 
intermediate triage of duplicate packets. Doing the triage at S-PEs adds 
a lot of complexity and posiibly a lot of silicon expense whereas a 
simpler approach that would be to do standard 1+1 or even 1+n and 
de-duplicate at the edge of the network. So I think we need to donsider 
that as undecided at this stage.

I am not sure what the scaling constraints that are proposed are, but 
S-PE can have huge numbers of PWs flowing through them.

- Stewart



On 20/07/2017 12:51, Loa Andersson wrote:
> Lou,
>
> One thing I feel that we need to do is to look at how GACh works with
> replication and elimination.
>
> The document does not specify OAM functions, but I think that the data
> channels for OAM should be within scope of the document.
>
> /Loa
>
> On 2017-07-20 12:00, Lou Berger wrote:
>> All,
>>
>> In this morning sessions we discussed a two stage adoption call for the
>> proposed data plane solution:
>>
>> - in the first stage we collect issues with the -01 individual draft
>> that WG members would like to see addressed as part of the normal WG
>> processing of the document.  These issues will then be captured in -02
>> rev of the individual draft.
>>
>> - The second stage will be the normal WG adoption process
>>
>> This message initiates the first stage of adoption.  In this stage we'd
>> like to collect technical issues to be captured in the -01 draft.
>> Specifically, if you have an issue with the draft please:
>>
>> (a) if an issue with a particular section or sections, please identify
>> the section(s) and summarize the issue to be captured in the -02 rev of
>> the draft (your text may be copied verbatim or 
>> paraphrased/summarized), or
>>
>> (b) if not section specific, identify the general issue you'd like to
>> see captured in an "open issues" section.  Again, your text may be
>> copied verbatim, paraphrased or summarized.
>>
>> Please send comments in the next 3 weeks, no later than Thursday, 
>> August 10.
>>
>> Thank you,
>>
>> Pat and Lou
>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> detnet mailing list
>> [e-mail]
>> https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/detnet
>>
>