Re: [dmarc-ietf] Fwd: I-D Action: draft-ietf-dmarc-psd-01.txt

["John Levine" <[e-mail]>]

In article <6596039.Rh8MxG5e5K@kitterma-e6430> you write:
>The current PSL is over 12K lines long.  What we're talking about here is 
>probably .1% to 1% that size.

Indeed, but since everyone has the PSL anyway to find organizational
domains, who cares about the size?  The point of asking the PSL people
to do it is to find a credible third party to evaluate "all your
domains belong to us" assertions.

>  Leaving aside for a moment the mechanism, would 
>people review the latest draft and see if they think the privacy issues are 
>adequately described and if they require some kind of mitigation?

I think it's fine.  At the end where you talk about failure reports,
you might note that since they contain actual messages, any domain
where the admistrator does not normally read its users' mail already
has the same issues.

R's,
John