[DNSOP] Extended DNS Errors (implementation) feedback

[Ralph Dolmans <[e-mail]>]

Hi all,

I made an Extended DNS Errors implementation in Unbound during the
IETF104 hackathon. Implementing the code that handles the errors was
rather straightforward, the difficult part is (as Stéphane already
pointed out) finding the right locations in the code for the individual
errors. Some remarks regarding the draft:

Since it is possible to have multiple extended error options, is it
expected to return all errors that match the result, or only the most
specific one? For example: if a DNSSEC signatures is expired should both
the "DNSSEC bogus" (SERVFAIL/Extended error 1) and the "Signature
expired" (SERVFAIL/Extended error 2) be returned?

I am not sure whether linking the info code to the rcode is a good idea.
Some info codes can happen for different rcodes. It is in Unbound for
example possible to block a domain by sending a REFUSED rcode, while the
document list blocking only for the NXDOMAIN rcode. If the
rcode/info-code coupling will remain then I would like to have the same
info code for a specific error under different rcodes, for example
always use info-code 1 for blocking.

Since EDNS is hop-by-hop, only error information from the resolver you
are talking to is returned. There are cases when the interesting
information is not in the first resolver. For example: if a resolver
forwards queries to another one and the last one does DNSSEC validation
then the resolver you are talking to does not generate the interesting
information. Is it maybe an idea to add some text stating that extended
error-aware resolvers should forward the received EDNS option?

I think having the extra information provided by this document is useful
for debugging, and only for that. This extra information should not be
used to make any DNS resolving decision, which makes the retry flag a
bad idea. At the moment I don't have to trust all my secondaries as long
as my zone is DNSSEC signed. The worst thing they can do is not return
my data or tamper with it, in which case the validating resolver will
ignore it and try another nameserver. Giving a nameserver the power to
instruct a resolver to not try at another nameserver gives them the
power to make my zone unavailable. This completely changes the current
trust model. Please remove the retry flag from the document.

-- Ralph