[DNSOP] (no subject)

[Warren Kumari <[e-mail]>]

Hi there all,

At the moment this document says that the child SHOULD remove the
CDS/CDNSKEY record once the parent has consumed / acted on it (this
behavior was requested by someone -- unfortunately I cannot remember
whom).

I *think* that I'm hearing that folk would prefer that the child
SHOULD leave it in, or, less strongly MAY remove it.

This (IMO) makes the doc and the child's life simpler, but potentially
makes a bit more work for the parent -- currently most of the
time the parent will see no CDS, and so will go back to sleep. If the
child leaves them around, the parent will need to check them against
what is currently published and take action if they differ.

Can folk please let us know if they would prefer:
A: The child SHOULD remove the CDS/CDNSKEY RR from the zone once the
parent has published it (currently documented behavior) or

B: The child SHOULD NOT remove the CDS/CDNSKEY RR (will require a
small edit to the doc)

My personal preference is for B - it seems more elegant, but (as
always) we'll do whatever the WG wants.

W