Re: [DNSOP] raising the bar: requiring implementations

[bert hubert <[e-mail]>]

On Wed, Mar 28, 2018 at 08:49:39PM +0530, Mukund Sivaraman wrote:
> I'd raise the bar even higher, to see complete implementation in a major
> open source DNS implementation when it applies. Sometimes implementation
> problems are very revealing (client-subnet should have gone through
> this).

Well to allow the one remaining closed source DNS implementation some room,
I think we could live with a 'demo' from them if they'd want to. This would
lead to an implementation report, much like is customary in the BGP WGs.

But otherwise, +100. 

This might go for MIXFR which we are discussing now btw.  It looks nice in
theory, but I wonder about the practice, and if the people who want this
(TLD operators I guess) would be willing to test it in simulated production
to see if it fits their needs.

	Bert