Re: fddi encapsulation woes
Dave Katz <katz@merit.edu> Thu, 31 May 1990 18:20 UTC
Received: from merit.edu by NRI.NRI.Reston.VA.US id aa10884; 31 May 90 14:20 EDT
Received: Thu, 31 May 90 13:19:25 EST by merit.edu (5.59/1.6)
Date: Thu, 31 May 1990 13:19:25 -0500
From: Dave Katz <katz@merit.edu>
Message-Id: <9005311819.AA04633@merit.edu>
To: fddi@merit.edu, jqj@rt-jqj.stanford.edu
Subject: Re: fddi encapsulation woes
Status: O
>Several vendors have proposed that IEEE 802.x traffic (e.g. OSI) on FDDI >be carried as: > > MAC header | length | 802.x packet ... I'd be interested to hear who is proposing this... The length field is present in 802.3 because, unlike all other 802 media (and FDDI), the information length is not self-encoding (due to the need to pad to a minimum frame size). There is no architectural reason why the information length should be explicitly carried - the hardware will tell you (after subtracting frame overhead). I would make the claim that standardization of such a field belongs to ANSI, as it is outside the 802 headers and protocols. Adding this field will be an utter disaster unless it is standardized by ANSI (and it seems like a bad idea to me). Allowing both framing conventions would be a *terrible* idea, assuming that it was possible to differentiate the two formats dynamically, which it's not, assuming that 802.2 is used for more than just Ethernet encapsulation and OSI. The trends regarding 802.3 vs. Ethernet on bridges to FDDI is that the SNAP format with OUI=0-0-0 means encapsulated Ethernet, and anything else is 802.3. Thus, anything running on an LSAP other than hex 'AA' ends up as 802.3. This works reversibly as long as the SNAP/0-0-0 format is not used on 802.3 (which, in general, it is not, although I've heard that Appletalk II is doing this). IP stations that use 802.3/RFC1042 framing need to be able to receive both types of framing in the face of bridges (I believe that this will be mandated when the 1042 revision is complete).
- fddi encapsulation woes jqj
- Re: fddi encapsulation woes Dave Katz