Re: [Gen-art] Gen-ART Last Call review for draft-ietf-netlmm-pmip6-ipv4-support-12

[Ryuji Wakikawa <[e-mail]>]

Hi Spencer,

Thanks, We will update the document according to your other comments.

thanks
ryuji

On 2009/05/18, at 12:38, Spencer Dawkins wrote:

> Hi, Ryuji,
>
> Thanks for explaining - SHOULD NOTs will be fine (with me).
>
> Spencer
>
>
>> Hi Spencer,
>> Thanks for the detailed comment.
>> On 2009/05/18, at 12:02, Spencer Dawkins wrote:
>>> Hi, Sri,
>>>
>>> (Thanks to everyone for the quick responses - I can still  
>>> remember  the review without having to re-read it ;-)
>>>
>>>> If the request is rejected with a specific reason, there is not  
>>>> point
>>>> for the requester to continue to send the messages for the exact  
>>>> same
>>>> service. Its ok to resend the message when some thing changes.  
>>>> Ex: An
>>>> administrative action allowing the user for that service.
>>>> So, the "SHOULD NOT" is with the goal to avoid unnecessary  
>>>> messaging.
>>>> Otherwise, the requester will recv the same error code.
>>>
>>> I'm sorry, I'm not asking the question clearly - I'm asking why   
>>> these SHOULD NOTs aren't MUST NOTs. Is there a reason why the   
>>> requestor would resend the messages for the same service, without   
>>> changing anything?
>>>
>>> If there's a reason, SHOULD NOT would be appropriate. If there's  
>>> not  a reason, perhaps MUST NOTs would be more appropriate.
>> The "MUST NOT" is too strict in this case.
>> As Sri mentioned, it is just for optimization by skipping  
>> unnecessary  messaging.
>> After operational action is taken by LMA and error is fixed, MAG   
>> should be able to retry the registration of the home address which
>> was previously rejected with  NOT_AUTHORIZED_FOR_IPV4_HOME_ADDRESS.
>> The retry timing depends on operation and administrative matter.  
>> It  might be the next registration or 1 hour later..
>> That's why we just put SHOULD NOT here.
>> We will work on the other comments.
>> regards,
>> ryuji
>>>
>>>
>>> Thanks,
>>>
>>> Spencer
>>>
>>
>