Re: [Ianaplan] CWG draft and its impact on the IETF

[John Curran <[e-mail]>]

On May 21, 2015, at 9:47 AM, John C Klensin <[e-mail]> wrote:
> ...
>  Without either of those two kinds of
> information, I do have an opinion about impact and risks to the
> IETF, and have expressed it before, I think in my first note on
> the subject: this is too complex, it introduces new risks of
> non-transparent behavior that may be accountable to small groups
> but is not even as accountable to the broader community as
> ICANN's operation of IANA is today, and therefore should not be
> considered acceptable.  

John -

You do not consider IETF's MOU for IANA services sufficient to 
mitigate the risks associated with the CWG proposal? It would 
be very useful for this community to understand what risks you 
believe are not addressed by the present RFC 2860 MOU...

Thanks!
/John

Disclaimer: my views alone