Re: [Icar] independence of reviews; variability

[Mark Allman <[e-mail]>]

 
> If we don't think anyone except area directors reads documents any
> more, discussion about "reviewers inside/outside the management
> structure" might make sense. I had hoped that we would not be starting
> down that road.

I believe the spirit of the ICAR charter is that we should think more
along the lines of *early* review -- which my mind thinks of as "way
before the IESG sees a document".  I was unclear about whether Dave's
comments were about early review or late review or just plain review.
But, I am pretty sure the above is about later review.  Am I off on the
spirit of ICAR?  And, if we're scoped on early review does that help the
independence issue?

allman
(w/o co-chair hat)


--
Mark Allman -- ICIR -- http://www.icir.org/mallman/