Return-Path: X-Original-To: idr@ietfa.amsl.com Delivered-To: idr@ietfa.amsl.com Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 147A012006D for ; Tue, 12 Nov 2019 13:41:10 -0800 (PST) X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com X-Spam-Flag: NO X-Spam-Score: -2.001 X-Spam-Level: X-Spam-Status: No, score=-2.001 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, DKIMWL_WL_HIGH=-0.001, DKIM_SIGNED=0.1, DKIM_VALID=-0.1, DKIM_VALID_AU=-0.1, HTML_MESSAGE=0.001, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_NONE=-0.0001, SPF_PASS=-0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no Authentication-Results: ietfa.amsl.com (amavisd-new); dkim=pass (1024-bit key) header.d=nist.gov Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id ssb8tGa1yogL for ; Tue, 12 Nov 2019 13:41:06 -0800 (PST) Received: from GCC02-BL0-obe.outbound.protection.outlook.com (mail-bl2gcc02on2099.outbound.protection.outlook.com [40.107.89.99]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 57CF012004E for ; Tue, 12 Nov 2019 13:41:06 -0800 (PST) ARC-Seal: i=1; a=rsa-sha256; s=arcselector9901; d=microsoft.com; cv=none; b=LP8BaX7Hbpm3WbNJlJx8T5QuuB7tC4wihWFfKy8ut82yywTEai8papiy61F3J9L+QjaOh2a22sXWdcUzbI2cBoE93HOBbQNE+D0iHgFs2Rpe8tTCSJrcRWgvT4WpmWeW/sWXN7fYehRBCkvGypBGvwb4T0eUc7DnwmhV+DLO9NcXKF1/XtIC4Onfty0v/p00erXZmIUg8pfaWidkXn/m4iia3rvi8y3g4Wf3OOyTt6OyqO+pFBA/yFh8vrOaoyvYBhNre0Lf6gYOIgI6DcMQZ6fEjYR6RXmyaOdALuVBj+QSqUiRV5W8c7MDLJuVGvpC0qT4QKrHsNov9tinHNJWYQ== ARC-Message-Signature: i=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=microsoft.com; s=arcselector9901; h=From:Date:Subject:Message-ID:Content-Type:MIME-Version:X-MS-Exchange-SenderADCheck; bh=ouLcw3kFncsvQ07e5pQ/mxA7pCq/k0QQsMKkevD442o=; b=Gge2cAlzYu5fzz5ixZEvXoWp/XPF43CBPZ+w6wFB5KXONYeHoRVyiV1Ibjg5KcbHqLxPzFgYiz2T1slYE64s5s3EwfX124qmSA0L9ttx5B/28KU8aoXWPOCCR1oo8rFqBqWNJD4G/hTAJBH4m8Jf5TIoIQwy4URkRWm180Q1QdVZG84UKUQvkSfvhOOaT+0tUSZ3uieYodRJ/I3EmEsauw/KsZ3tnStCd1SkQ1LQn7er4x42Edhg6im1K+bStKbr2s8Dm7e5cI3aNLoCbLdsBBRDtUfxkspbaW6pqYAroD5LXF6K+x6KZIwXLG5UPwuPR/u8GEc9cs+xBKTgepcHGw== ARC-Authentication-Results: i=1; mx.microsoft.com 1; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=nist.gov; dmarc=pass action=none header.from=nist.gov; dkim=pass header.d=nist.gov; arc=none DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=nist.gov; s=selector2; h=From:Date:Subject:Message-ID:Content-Type:MIME-Version:X-MS-Exchange-SenderADCheck; bh=ouLcw3kFncsvQ07e5pQ/mxA7pCq/k0QQsMKkevD442o=; b=cM0zbyRwhTLi5JDl0GoT+j+U1cmt5lIrv+VmE56KK9gzvrR5DH9ObqMICAmUgAhYWXTmNe77Bp4sAB1YrL/iDZtmWDfQ5xoh/hMPPl50ucVD2q3Zm4DVI4nVN7yJUz4saN0rjG+1lyhjq1PoN3ZOBu358+Honsx5t81ry5rwcUs= Received: from BN7PR09MB2643.namprd09.prod.outlook.com (52.135.245.21) by BN7PR09MB2866.namprd09.prod.outlook.com (52.135.253.25) with Microsoft SMTP Server (version=TLS1_2, cipher=TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_256_GCM_SHA384) id 15.20.2430.20; Tue, 12 Nov 2019 21:41:04 +0000 Received: from BN7PR09MB2643.namprd09.prod.outlook.com ([fe80::6c54:32d8:7967:1234]) by BN7PR09MB2643.namprd09.prod.outlook.com ([fe80::6c54:32d8:7967:1234%5]) with mapi id 15.20.2430.020; Tue, 12 Nov 2019 21:41:04 +0000 From: "Hannachi, Lilia (IntlAssoc)" To: Jeffrey Haas , "alejandroacostaalamo@gmail.com" CC: Sander Steffann , "idr@ietf.org" , Warren Kumari , "Sriram, Kotikalapudi (Fed)" Thread-Topic: [Idr] I-D Action: draft-ietf-idr-deprecate-as-set-confed-set-02.txt Thread-Index: AQHVl3hicb8HrA/7F0aisc+viPiSa6eFBzYAgABTfACAArK74IAABpyp Date: Tue, 12 Nov 2019 21:41:03 +0000 Message-ID: References: <4f6baac8-1466-e931-c123-5c29c2ec9ea1@gmail.com> <20191111040222.GE19227@pfrc.org>, In-Reply-To: Accept-Language: en-US Content-Language: en-US X-MS-Has-Attach: X-MS-TNEF-Correlator: authentication-results: spf=none (sender IP is ) smtp.mailfrom=lilia.hannachi@nist.gov; x-originating-ip: [129.6.248.164] x-ms-publictraffictype: Email x-ms-office365-filtering-ht: Tenant x-ms-office365-filtering-correlation-id: 2da17d60-527c-4d87-4d19-08d767b9049d x-ms-traffictypediagnostic: BN7PR09MB2866:|BN7PR09MB2866: x-ms-exchange-transport-forked: True x-microsoft-antispam-prvs: x-ms-oob-tlc-oobclassifiers: OLM:9508; x-forefront-prvs: 021975AE46 x-forefront-antispam-report: SFV:NSPM; SFS:(10019020)(39860400002)(346002)(366004)(396003)(376002)(136003)(189003)(199004)(54906003)(54896002)(186003)(9686003)(19627405001)(7736002)(105004)(316002)(110136005)(8676002)(6506007)(71190400001)(8936002)(71200400001)(74316002)(102836004)(4326008)(2501003)(6436002)(446003)(86362001)(26005)(30864003)(486006)(7696005)(76176011)(52536014)(5660300002)(6116002)(3846002)(476003)(91956017)(76116006)(256004)(478600001)(55016002)(81166006)(81156014)(11346002)(25786009)(107886003)(33656002)(14454004)(66446008)(66476007)(66556008)(64756008)(66066001)(229853002)(66946007)(2906002)(99286004)(6246003); DIR:OUT; SFP:1102; SCL:1; SRVR:BN7PR09MB2866; H:BN7PR09MB2643.namprd09.prod.outlook.com; FPR:; SPF:None; LANG:en; PTR:InfoNoRecords; MX:1; A:1; received-spf: None (protection.outlook.com: nist.gov does not designate permitted sender hosts) x-ms-exchange-senderadcheck: 1 x-microsoft-antispam: BCL:0; x-microsoft-antispam-message-info: LePePFfQHC8WeFBsuRrAIjrnokSOe1dJ5gHwJW8gQMj9Xy15O3Cn9ZDDDfDtxR1nRpIfjSaT+EgrEKhxXuMf7+cah1+eKklA8XDU9FtN4PX/pAurhTPhSVqSsCNa1RY4dBkj4hp1KOucptb/vzoFK4412jTwQI3o0Xbo02m9+VL8B1g4diWLgBccorsodifDTah/9Ps2+0fzupEJxAz8zrHaSsgMl9zBn5ZQwGScKrIsmcycq4zLRgGpG6UKGsKv5Tykay4NZsJ0GX0IpRtWdyR2T3tPDIMK445doUZxTTVVXtDky8V4R1qKyXbzEI1Gd9O8ih+/g/uj5yu/Tp2MH7gC172wqMaEEpK4q2bpqcbjCsSAReBZd7HG/qPR+QXn18sBbxInqcqiglgp6BMYTtUpUN9uyC3+lNQ3km8HB9FGfDhof8C2yTX2bCawkwXB Content-Type: multipart/alternative; boundary="_000_BN7PR09MB2643857C3ACEF18A37710B8DEF770BN7PR09MB2643namp_" MIME-Version: 1.0 X-OriginatorOrg: nist.gov X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-Network-Message-Id: 2da17d60-527c-4d87-4d19-08d767b9049d X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-originalarrivaltime: 12 Nov 2019 21:41:03.8853 (UTC) X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-fromentityheader: Hosted X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-id: 2ab5d82f-d8fa-4797-a93e-054655c61dec X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-mailboxtype: HOSTED X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-userprincipalname: VSAllW3V0x3lGSzCPu2Jo5OEYUlUKB56c78OxCl0qpb8giHwqWmFcVVdQ7FoHxez X-MS-Exchange-Transport-CrossTenantHeadersStamped: BN7PR09MB2866 Archived-At: Subject: Re: [Idr] I-D Action: draft-ietf-idr-deprecate-as-set-confed-set-02.txt X-BeenThere: idr@ietf.org X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.29 Precedence: list List-Id: Inter-Domain Routing List-Unsubscribe: , List-Archive: List-Post: List-Help: List-Subscribe: , X-List-Received-Date: Wed, 13 Nov 2019 15:07:49 -0000 --_000_BN7PR09MB2643857C3ACEF18A37710B8DEF770BN7PR09MB2643namp_ Content-Type: text/plain; charset="iso-8859-1" Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable Jeff, > > In IPv6, we shouldn't have any motivation to do aggregation in the > traditional sense. Have you done any analysis of the prefixes involved i= n > that IPv6 aggregation? > Earlier we (NIST) had shared the analysis for IPv4. Listed below is the AS_SET analysis for IPv6. Please let me know if you have any further questions. Lilia -------------- AS_SET ANALYSIS (OREGON6 2019-10-03:00) The Routeviews OREGON6 collector peers with (23) ASes ********************************************************************* Summary (for IPv6) ********************************************************************* Total # Updates : 155659 # Updates with AS_SET : 38 Percentage of routes with AS_SET : 0.024% # Total # ASes (globally) : 18027 # ASes that create updates with AS_SET : 27 Percentage of ASes that create updates with AS_SET : 0.15% # Routes with AS_SET (after eliminating AS path redundancy): 38 Explanation: These are routes with unique {prefix, AS_SET, 1st AS a= fter AS_SET, AGGREGATOR} combinations. Out of the 38 routes with AS_SETs: *** Routes with AS_SET that seem meaningless or malformed *** # Routes with only one AS in AS_SET : 26 # Routes with Reserved ASN in AS_SET : 0 # Routes with common AS in the AS_SEQUENCE and AS_SET : 4 # Routes with repeated ASes in the AS_SET : 0 # Routes that are /48 prefix (aggregate) announcements : 6 Total # Routes that seem meaningless or malformed : 27 Total # Routes that seem meaningful : 11 Distribution of # unique ASes in the AS_SET : 1:26,2:7,3:1,4:3,8:1 # Routes with AS_SET where AGGREGATOR does not match the right most= AS in AS_SEQUENCE : 1 # Routes with unique {prefix, AS_SET, AGGREGATOR} : 38 # Routes with unique {prefix, AS_SET} : 38 *** When there is AGGREGATOR without AS_SET *** # Unique prefixes (with or without AS_SET) : 78625 # Unique prefixes without AS_SET but with AGGREGATOR: 8651 % Unique prefixes without AS_SET but with AGGREGATOR: 11.003% # Unique prefixes with ATOMIC_AGGREGATE: 3823 # Unique prefixes with AGGREGATOR and ATOMIC_AGGREGATE: 3650 # Unique prefixes with AGGREGATOR and without ATOMIC_AGGREGATE: 503= 9 # Unique prefixes with AS_SET and ATOMIC_AGGREGATE: 2 ********************************************************************* List of ASes (AGGREGATOR) Ranked according to # Routes with AS_SET ********************************************************************* AS: 14080 # Routes with AS_SET: 4 Organization: Telmex Colomb= ia S.A., CO AS: 271 # Routes with AS_SET: 3 Organization: BCNET-AS - BCne= t, CA AS: 20940 # Routes with AS_SET: 3 Organization: AKAMAI-ASN1, = US AS: 9443 # Routes with AS_SET: 2 Organization: INTERNETPRIMUS= -AS-AP Primus Telecommunications, AU AS: 24158 # Routes with AS_SET: 2 Organization: TAIWANMOBILE-= AS Taiwan Mobile Co., Ltd., TW AS: 45147 # Routes with AS_SET: 2 Organization: NAPINFO-TRANS= IT-AS-AP PT. NAP Info Lintas Nusa, ID AS: 52320 # Routes with AS_SET: 2 Organization: GlobeNet Cabo= s Submarinos Colombia, S.A.S., CO AS: 22 # Routes with AS_SET: 1 Organization: DNIC-AS-00022 - = Navy Network Information Center (NNIC), US AS: 8376 # Routes with AS_SET: 1 Organization: Jordan Data Co= mmunications, JO AS: 8697 # Routes with AS_SET: 1 Organization: JTC-AS8697 Jor= dan Telecom Group ( JTG ), JO AS: 47377 # Routes with AS_SET: 1 Organization: ORANGE_BELGIU= M_SA KPN Belgium Business NV has been acquired by Mobistar, BE AS: 65401 # Routes with AS_SET: 1 Organization: -Private Use = AS-, ZZ AS: 7160 # Routes with AS_SET: 1 Organization: NETDYNAMICS - = Oracle Corporation, US AS: 6509 # Routes with AS_SET: 1 Organization: CANARIE-NTN - = Canarie Inc, CA AS: 32440 # Routes with AS_SET: 1 Organization: LONI - Louisi= ana Board of Regents/Louisiana Optical Network Initiative (LONI), US AS: 6364 # Routes with AS_SET: 1 Organization: ATLANTIC-NET-1= - Atlantic.net, Inc., US AS: 27919 # Routes with AS_SET: 1 Organization: IXP ECUADOR, = EC AS: 8664 # Routes with AS_SET: 1 Organization: ICM-PUB public= network services, PL AS: 41943 # Routes with AS_SET: 1 Organization: VMI-KISTA, SE AS: 41426 # Routes with AS_SET: 1 Organization: SAUDIDATASTC-= AS, SA AS: 203507 # Routes with AS_SET: 1 Organization: AVIRADE Kapl= aneiweg 1, DE AS: 44814 # Routes with AS_SET: 1 Organization: BTEL-BG-AS, B= G AS: 35548 # Routes with AS_SET: 1 Organization: SMARTTERRA-AS= , DE AS: 62917 # Routes with AS_SET: 1 Organization: GIGABITCO - G= igabit Communications, US AS: 34056 # Routes with AS_SET: 1 Organization: KIEVNET KievN= et ISP AS, UA AS: 9924 # Routes with AS_SET: 1 Organization: TFN-TW Taiwan = Fixed Network, Telco and Network Service Provider., TW AS: 26281 # Routes with AS_SET: 1 Organization: RIML-CORP-AS-= 1 - BlackBerry Limited, CA ********************************************************************* List of Routes with AS_SET that seem meaningless or malformed: ********************************************************************* 2607:ffc0:1000::/36 209 6939 18705 26281 {13340} 2607:f170:50::/44 57463 6939 2828 18672 6364 {6364} 2001:6a0::/32 7018 6939 8664 {8890} 2607:f8f0:210::/44 57866 1299 6939 271 271 271 271 {26415} 2800:484::/32 57463 6939 3257 14080 {10620} 2a01:4a40::/32 37100 44814 {60974} 2402:7500:600::/40 57463 6939 3491 9924 24158 {131614} 2800:480::/32 57463 6939 3257 14080 {10620} 2a03:f600::/32 57463 6939 1299 3301 25146 41943 {34236} 2a00:1688::/32 57866 9002 34056 {201948} 2600:1408:9800::/48 209 6461 20940 20940 {16625} 2a02:26f0:e00::/48 57463 6939 6762 20940 20940 {21342} 2403:4800:9000::/36 57463 6939 4826 9443 {16625} 2600:140b:f000::/48 7018 1299 4637 4637 4637 4637 20940 20940 {= 21342} 2606:b400:8814::/48 57463 6939 3356 7160 {7160} 2403:4800::/48 57463 6939 4826 9443 {38285} 2a00:18d8::/32 57463 6939 5511 8697 {328126} 2803:a8a0::/32 7660 2516 6762 27947 27919 {27919,266802} 2800:485::/32 57463 6939 3257 14080 {10620} 2402:4640::/33 22652 4788 38044 {23736} 2402:7500:800::/40 57463 6939 3491 9924 24158 {131614} 2a01:9700::/32 57463 6939 8697 8376 {8376} 2a06:e380::/29 57866 1299 203507 203507 {206970} 2a00:6480::/32 57463 6939 35548 {29018} 2001:480:10::/48 57866 2914 668 22 {7224} 2a02:2578::/32 3277 6939 1299 39386 41426 {51375} 2a01:cc00::/32 57463 6939 5511 47377 {12493} ********************************************************************* List of Routes with AS_SET that seem meaningful: ********************************************************************* 2404:c000::/32 1403 6939 7473 45147 {16625,17727,55818,64313} 2001:410::/32 3277 6939 6509 {271,7860,8111} 2800:b40::/32 57463 52320 {6939,18678,262220,262589} 2402:7500::/32 57463 6939 2914 9924 9924 9924 {24158,131614} 2404:c000::/33 7018 1299 45147 {16625,55818} 2607:f8f0::/32 57866 1299 577 271 271 271 271 {4476,16462,26415,39= 3249} 2604:82c0::/32 57463 6939 33132 62917 {32451,54426} 2800:482::/32 40191 3257 14080 {10620,64250} 2803:6700::/32 31019 43531 52320 {2,3257,6762,6939,18747,19429,262= 220,263210} 2607:f390::/32 57463 6939 3356 32440 {2055,17244} 2607:f8f0:600::/40 57866 1299 577 271 271 271 271 {4476,393249= } ********************************************************************* List of All Routes with AS_SET by AGGREGATOR ********************************************************************* *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 14080 *********************** 2800:482::/32 40191 3257 14080 {10620,64250} AGGREGATOR=3D14080 2800:484::/32 57463 6939 3257 14080 {10620} AGGREGATOR=3D14080 2800:480::/32 57463 6939 3257 14080 {10620} AGGREGATOR=3D14080 2800:485::/32 57463 6939 3257 14080 {10620} AGGREGATOR=3D14080 *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 271 *********************** 2607:f8f0:210::/44 57866 1299 6939 271 271 271 271 {26415} AGG= REGATOR=3D271 2607:f8f0:600::/40 57866 1299 577 271 271 271 271 {4476,393249= } AGGREGATOR=3D271 2607:f8f0::/32 57866 1299 577 271 271 271 271 {4476,16462,26415,39= 3249} AGGREGATOR=3D271 *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 20940 *********************** 2600:1408:9800::/48 209 6461 20940 20940 {16625} AGGREGATOR= =3D20940 2600:140b:f000::/48 7018 1299 4637 4637 4637 4637 20940 20940 {= 21342} AGGREGATOR=3D20940 2a02:26f0:e00::/48 57463 6939 6762 20940 20940 {21342} AGG= REGATOR=3D20940 *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 9443 *********************** 2403:4800::/48 57463 6939 4826 9443 {38285} AGGREGATOR=3D9443 2403:4800:9000::/36 57463 6939 4826 9443 {16625} AGGREGATOR= =3D9443 *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 24158 *********************** 2402:7500:600::/40 57463 6939 3491 9924 24158 {131614} AGG= REGATOR=3D24158 2402:7500:800::/40 57463 6939 3491 9924 24158 {131614} AGG= REGATOR=3D24158 *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 45147 *********************** 2404:c000::/33 7018 1299 45147 {16625,55818} AGGREGATOR=3D45147 2404:c000::/32 1403 6939 7473 45147 {16625,17727,55818,64313} AGG= REGATOR=3D45147 *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 52320 *********************** 2803:6700::/32 31019 43531 52320 {2,3257,6762,6939,18747,19429,262= 220,263210} AGGREGATOR=3D52320 2800:b40::/32 57463 52320 {6939,18678,262220,262589} AGGREGATOR= =3D52320 *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 22 *********************** 2001:480:10::/48 57866 2914 668 22 {7224} AGGREGATOR= =3D22 *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 8376 *********************** 2a01:9700::/32 57463 6939 8697 8376 {8376} AGGREGATOR=3D8376 *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 8697 *********************** 2a00:18d8::/32 57463 6939 5511 8697 {328126} AGGREGATOR=3D8697 *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 47377 *********************** 2a01:cc00::/32 57463 6939 5511 47377 {12493} AGGREGATOR=3D47377 *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 65401 *********************** 2402:4640::/33 22652 4788 38044 {23736} AGGREGATOR=3D65401 *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 7160 *********************** 2606:b400:8814::/48 57463 6939 3356 7160 {7160} AGGREGATOR= =3D7160 *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 6509 *********************** 2001:410::/32 3277 6939 6509 {271,7860,8111} AGGREGATOR=3D6509 *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 32440 *********************** 2607:f390::/32 57463 6939 3356 32440 {2055,17244} AGGREGATOR= =3D32440 *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 6364 *********************** 2607:f170:50::/44 57463 6939 2828 18672 6364 {6364} AGG= REGATOR=3D6364 *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 27919 *********************** 2803:a8a0::/32 7660 2516 6762 27947 27919 {27919,266802} AGG= REGATOR=3D27919 *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 8664 *********************** 2001:6a0::/32 7018 6939 8664 {8890} AGGREGATOR=3D8664 *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 41943 *********************** 2a03:f600::/32 57463 6939 1299 3301 25146 41943 {34236} AGG= REGATOR=3D41943 *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 41426 *********************** 2a02:2578::/32 3277 6939 1299 39386 41426 {51375} AGGREGATOR= =3D41426 *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 203507 *********************** 2a06:e380::/29 57866 1299 203507 203507 {206970} AGGREGATOR= =3D203507 *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 44814 *********************** 2a01:4a40::/32 37100 44814 {60974} AGGREGATOR=3D44814 *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 35548 *********************** 2a00:6480::/32 57463 6939 35548 {29018} AGGREGATOR=3D35548 *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 62917 *********************** 2604:82c0::/32 57463 6939 33132 62917 {32451,54426} AGGREGATOR= =3D62917 *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 34056 *********************** 2a00:1688::/32 57866 9002 34056 {201948} AGGREGATOR=3D34056 *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 9924 *********************** 2402:7500::/32 57463 6939 2914 9924 9924 9924 {24158,131614} AGG= REGATOR=3D9924 *********************** AGGREGATOR=3D 26281 *********************** 2607:ffc0:1000::/36 209 6939 18705 26281 {13340} AGGREGATOR= =3D26281 --_000_BN7PR09MB2643857C3ACEF18A37710B8DEF770BN7PR09MB2643namp_ Content-Type: text/html; charset="iso-8859-1" Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable
Jeff,

>
> In IPv6, we shouldn't have any motivation to do aggregation in the
> traditional sense.  Have you done any analysis of the prefixes in= volved in
> that IPv6 aggregation?
>

Earlier we (NIST) had shared the analysis for IPv4.
Listed below is the AS_SET analysis for IPv6.
Please let me know if you have any further questions.

Lilia
--------------

AS_SET ANALYSIS (OREGON6 2019-10-03:00)
The Routeviews OREGON6 collector peers with (23) ASes 

*********************************************************************
Summary (for IPv6)
*********************************************************************

        Total # Updates : 155659
        # Updates with AS_SET : 38
        Percentage of routes with AS_SET= : 0.024%
        # Total # ASes (globally) : 1802= 7
        # ASes that create updates with = AS_SET : 27
        Percentage of ASes that create u= pdates with AS_SET : 0.15%

        # Routes with AS_SET (after elim= inating AS path redundancy): 38
        Explanation: These are routes wi= th unique {prefix, AS_SET, 1st AS after AS_SET, AGGREGATOR} combinations.
Out of the 38 routes with AS_SETs:
        *** Routes with AS_SET that seem= meaningless or malformed ***
        # Routes with only one AS in AS_= SET : 26
        # Routes with Reserved ASN in AS= _SET : 0
        # Routes with common AS in the A= S_SEQUENCE and AS_SET : 4
        # Routes with repeated ASes in t= he AS_SET : 0
        # Routes that are /48 prefix (ag= gregate) announcements : 6
        Total # Routes that seem meaning= less or malformed : 27

      Total # Routes that seem meaningful : 11

        Distribution of # unique ASes in= the AS_SET : 1:26,2:7,3:1,4:3,8:1

        # Routes with AS_SET where AGGRE= GATOR does not match the right most AS in AS_SEQUENCE : 1

        # Routes with unique {prefix, AS= _SET, AGGREGATOR} : 38
        # Routes with unique {prefix, AS= _SET} : 38

*** When there is AGGREGATOR without AS_SET ***
        # Unique prefixes (with or witho= ut AS_SET) : 78625
        # Unique prefixes without AS_SET= but with AGGREGATOR: 8651
        % Unique prefixes without AS_SET= but with AGGREGATOR: 11.003%
        # Unique prefixes with ATOMIC_AG= GREGATE: 3823
        # Unique prefixes with AGGREGATO= R and ATOMIC_AGGREGATE: 3650
        # Unique prefixes with AGGREGATO= R and without ATOMIC_AGGREGATE: 5039
        # Unique prefixes with AS_SET an= d ATOMIC_AGGREGATE: 2


*********************************************************************
List of ASes (AGGREGATOR) Ranked according to # Routes with AS_SET
*********************************************************************

        AS: 14080    # Ro= utes with AS_SET: 4    Organization: Telmex Colombia S.A., C= O
        AS: 271    # Rout= es with AS_SET: 3    Organization: BCNET-AS - BCnet, CA
        AS: 20940    # Ro= utes with AS_SET: 3    Organization: AKAMAI-ASN1, US
        AS: 9443    # Rou= tes with AS_SET: 2    Organization: INTERNETPRIMUS-AS-AP Pri= mus Telecommunications, AU
        AS: 24158    # Ro= utes with AS_SET: 2    Organization: TAIWANMOBILE-AS Taiwan = Mobile Co., Ltd., TW
        AS: 45147    # Ro= utes with AS_SET: 2    Organization: NAPINFO-TRANSIT-AS-AP P= T. NAP Info Lintas Nusa, ID
        AS: 52320    # Ro= utes with AS_SET: 2    Organization: GlobeNet Cabos Submarin= os Colombia, S.A.S., CO
        AS: 22    # Route= s with AS_SET: 1    Organization: DNIC-AS-00022 - Navy Netwo= rk Information Center (NNIC), US
        AS: 8376    # Rou= tes with AS_SET: 1    Organization: Jordan Data Communicatio= ns, JO
        AS: 8697    # Rou= tes with AS_SET: 1    Organization: JTC-AS8697 Jordan Teleco= m Group ( JTG ), JO
        AS: 47377    # Ro= utes with AS_SET: 1    Organization: ORANGE_BELGIUM_SA KPN B= elgium Business NV has been acquired by Mobistar, BE
        AS: 65401    # Ro= utes with AS_SET: 1    Organization: -Private Use AS-, ZZ
        AS: 7160    # Rou= tes with AS_SET: 1    Organization: NETDYNAMICS - Oracle Cor= poration, US
        AS: 6509    # Rou= tes with AS_SET: 1    Organization: CANARIE-NTN - Canarie In= c, CA
        AS: 32440    # Ro= utes with AS_SET: 1    Organization: LONI - Louisiana Board = of Regents/Louisiana Optical Network Initiative (LONI), US
        AS: 6364    # Rou= tes with AS_SET: 1    Organization: ATLANTIC-NET-1 - Atlanti= c.net, Inc., US
        AS: 27919    # Ro= utes with AS_SET: 1    Organization: IXP ECUADOR, EC
        AS: 8664    # Rou= tes with AS_SET: 1    Organization: ICM-PUB public network s= ervices, PL
        AS: 41943    # Ro= utes with AS_SET: 1    Organization: VMI-KISTA, SE
        AS: 41426    # Ro= utes with AS_SET: 1    Organization: SAUDIDATASTC-AS, SA
        AS: 203507    # R= outes with AS_SET: 1    Organization: AVIRADE Kaplaneiweg 1,= DE
        AS: 44814    # Ro= utes with AS_SET: 1    Organization: BTEL-BG-AS, BG
        AS: 35548    # Ro= utes with AS_SET: 1    Organization: SMARTTERRA-AS, DE
        AS: 62917    # Ro= utes with AS_SET: 1    Organization: GIGABITCO - Gigabit Com= munications, US
        AS: 34056    # Ro= utes with AS_SET: 1    Organization: KIEVNET KievNet ISP AS,= UA
        AS: 9924    # Rou= tes with AS_SET: 1    Organization: TFN-TW Taiwan Fixed Netw= ork, Telco and Network Service Provider., TW
        AS: 26281    # Ro= utes with AS_SET: 1    Organization: RIML-CORP-AS-1 - BlackB= erry Limited, CA


*********************************************************************
List of Routes with AS_SET that seem meaningless or malformed:
*********************************************************************

        2607:ffc0:1000::/36  &= nbsp;  209 6939 18705 26281 {13340}
        2607:f170:50::/44  &nb= sp;    57463 6939 2828 18672 6364 {6364}
        2001:6a0::/32   7018 6= 939 8664 {8890}
        2607:f8f0:210::/44  &n= bsp;   57866 1299 6939 271 271 271 271 {26415}
        2800:484::/32   57463 = 6939 3257 14080 {10620}
        2a01:4a40::/32  37100 44814= {60974}
        2402:7500:600::/40  &n= bsp;   57463 6939 3491 9924 24158 {131614}
        2800:480::/32   57463 = 6939 3257 14080 {10620}
        2a03:f600::/32  57463 6939 = 1299 3301 25146 41943 {34236}
        2a00:1688::/32  57866 9002 = 34056 {201948}
        2600:1408:9800::/48  &= nbsp;  209 6461 20940 20940 {16625}
        2a02:26f0:e00::/48  &n= bsp;   57463 6939 6762 20940 20940 {21342}
        2403:4800:9000::/36  &= nbsp;  57463 6939 4826 9443 {16625}
        2600:140b:f000::/48  &= nbsp;  7018 1299 4637 4637 4637 4637 20940 20940 {21342}
        2606:b400:8814::/48  &= nbsp;  57463 6939 3356 7160 {7160}
        2403:4800::/48  57463 6939 = 4826 9443 {38285}
        2a00:18d8::/32  57463 6939 = 5511 8697 {328126}
        2803:a8a0::/32  7660 2516 6= 762 27947 27919 {27919,266802}
        2800:485::/32   57463 = 6939 3257 14080 {10620}
        2402:4640::/33  22652 4788 = 38044 {23736}
        2402:7500:800::/40  &n= bsp;   57463 6939 3491 9924 24158 {131614}
        2a01:9700::/32  57463 6939 = 8697 8376 {8376}
        2a06:e380::/29  57866 1299 = 203507 203507 {206970}
        2a00:6480::/32  57463 6939 = 35548 {29018}
        2001:480:10::/48  &nbs= p;     57866 2914 668 22 {7224}
        2a02:2578::/32  3277 6939 1= 299 39386 41426 {51375}
        2a01:cc00::/32  57463 6939 = 5511 47377 {12493}


*********************************************************************
List of Routes with AS_SET that seem meaningful:
*********************************************************************

        2404:c000::/32  1403 6939 7= 473 45147 {16625,17727,55818,64313}
        2001:410::/32   3277 6= 939 6509 {271,7860,8111}
        2800:b40::/32   57463 = 52320 {6939,18678,262220,262589}
        2402:7500::/32  57463 6939 = 2914 9924 9924 9924 {24158,131614}
        2404:c000::/33  7018 1299 4= 5147 {16625,55818}
        2607:f8f0::/32  57866 1299 = 577 271 271 271 271 {4476,16462,26415,393249}
        2604:82c0::/32  57463 6939 = 33132 62917 {32451,54426}
        2800:482::/32   40191 = 3257 14080 {10620,64250}
        2803:6700::/32  31019 43531= 52320 {2,3257,6762,6939,18747,19429,262220,263210}
        2607:f390::/32  57463 6939 = 3356 32440 {2055,17244}
        2607:f8f0:600::/40  &n= bsp;   57866 1299 577 271 271 271 271 {4476,393249}

*********************************************************************
List of All Routes with AS_SET by AGGREGATOR
*********************************************************************

***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 14080
***********************
        2800:482::/32   40191 = 3257 14080 {10620,64250}  AGGREGATOR=3D14080
        2800:484::/32   57463 = 6939 3257 14080 {10620}   AGGREGATOR=3D14080
        2800:480::/32   57463 = 6939 3257 14080 {10620}   AGGREGATOR=3D14080
        2800:485::/32   57463 = 6939 3257 14080 {10620}   AGGREGATOR=3D14080
***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 271
***********************
        2607:f8f0:210::/44  &n= bsp;   57866 1299 6939 271 271 271 271 {26415} AGGREGATOR=3D271         2607:f8f0:600::/40  &n= bsp;   57866 1299 577 271 271 271 271 {4476,393249}  &n= bsp; AGGREGATOR=3D271
        2607:f8f0::/32  57866 1299 = 577 271 271 271 271 {4476,16462,26415,393249}     =    AGGREGATOR=3D271
***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 20940
***********************
        2600:1408:9800::/48  &= nbsp;  209 6461 20940 20940 {16625}    AGGREGATOR=3D209= 40
        2600:140b:f000::/48  &= nbsp;  7018 1299 4637 4637 4637 4637 20940 20940 {21342}  &n= bsp;    AGGREGATOR=3D20940
        2a02:26f0:e00::/48  &n= bsp;   57463 6939 6762 20940 20940 {21342}    = ; AGGREGATOR=3D20940
***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 9443
***********************
        2403:4800::/48  57463 6939 = 4826 9443 {38285}    AGGREGATOR=3D9443
        2403:4800:9000::/36  &= nbsp;  57463 6939 4826 9443 {16625}    AGGREGATOR=3D944= 3
***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 24158
***********************
        2402:7500:600::/40  &n= bsp;   57463 6939 3491 9924 24158 {131614}    = ; AGGREGATOR=3D24158
        2402:7500:800::/40  &n= bsp;   57463 6939 3491 9924 24158 {131614}    = ; AGGREGATOR=3D24158
***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 45147
***********************
        2404:c000::/33  7018 1299 4= 5147 {16625,55818}   AGGREGATOR=3D45147
        2404:c000::/32  1403 6939 7= 473 45147 {16625,17727,55818,64313}  AGGREGATOR=3D45147
***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 52320
***********************
        2803:6700::/32  31019 43531= 52320 {2,3257,6762,6939,18747,19429,262220,263210}  AGGREGATOR=3D5232= 0
        2800:b40::/32   57463 = 52320 {6939,18678,262220,262589}  AGGREGATOR=3D52320
***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 22
***********************
        2001:480:10::/48  &nbs= p;     57866 2914 668 22 {7224}    =     AGGREGATOR=3D22
***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 8376
***********************
        2a01:9700::/32  57463 6939 = 8697 8376 {8376}     AGGREGATOR=3D8376
***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 8697
***********************
        2a00:18d8::/32  57463 6939 = 5511 8697 {328126}   AGGREGATOR=3D8697
***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 47377
***********************
        2a01:cc00::/32  57463 6939 = 5511 47377 {12493}   AGGREGATOR=3D47377
***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 65401
***********************
        2402:4640::/33  22652 4788 = 38044 {23736}        AGGREGATOR=3D65401<= br> ***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 7160
***********************
        2606:b400:8814::/48  &= nbsp;  57463 6939 3356 7160 {7160}     AGGREGATOR= =3D7160
***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 6509
***********************
        2001:410::/32   3277 6= 939 6509 {271,7860,8111}  AGGREGATOR=3D6509
***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 32440
***********************
        2607:f390::/32  57463 6939 = 3356 32440 {2055,17244}      AGGREGATOR=3D32440 ***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 6364
***********************
        2607:f170:50::/44  &nb= sp;    57463 6939 2828 18672 6364 {6364}   &n= bsp;   AGGREGATOR=3D6364
***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 27919
***********************
        2803:a8a0::/32  7660 2516 6= 762 27947 27919 {27919,266802}       AGGREGAT= OR=3D27919
***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 8664
***********************
        2001:6a0::/32   7018 6= 939 8664 {8890}   AGGREGATOR=3D8664
***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 41943
***********************
        2a03:f600::/32  57463 6939 = 1299 3301 25146 41943 {34236}        AGG= REGATOR=3D41943
***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 41426
***********************
        2a02:2578::/32  3277 6939 1= 299 39386 41426 {51375}      AGGREGATOR=3D41426 ***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 203507
***********************
        2a06:e380::/29  57866 1299 = 203507 203507 {206970}       AGGREGATOR=3D203= 507
***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 44814
***********************
        2a01:4a40::/32  37100 44814= {60974}     AGGREGATOR=3D44814
***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 35548
***********************
        2a00:6480::/32  57463 6939 = 35548 {29018}        AGGREGATOR=3D35548<= br> ***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 62917
***********************
        2604:82c0::/32  57463 6939 = 33132 62917 {32451,54426}    AGGREGATOR=3D62917
***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 34056
***********************
        2a00:1688::/32  57866 9002 = 34056 {201948}       AGGREGATOR=3D34056
***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 9924
***********************
        2402:7500::/32  57463 6939 = 2914 9924 9924 9924 {24158,131614}   AGGREGATOR=3D9924
***********************
AGGREGATOR=3D 26281
***********************
        2607:ffc0:1000::/36  &= nbsp;  209 6939 18705 26281 {13340}    AGGREGATOR=3D262= 81








--_000_BN7PR09MB2643857C3ACEF18A37710B8DEF770BN7PR09MB2643namp_--