Re: [Idr] WGLC on draft-ietf-idr-as-private-reservation-00

[Randy Bush <[e-mail]>]

> the data center community has, for better or worse, decided that BGP
> is their protocol of choice.  Frankly, I find it mildly nauseating,
> but it's very clear that they are going to use BGP regardless of what
> you and I say.

agreed

but this is not what is in the ID or was not the discussion (that i
remember, with large caveats on my memory).  it has been about hiding
isp customers behind private asns, which we know how to do already.

while nauseating, this is a more compelling argument.  and i note that
it does not have the merger problem the isp model has.  or, more
precisely, when it has the merger problem, it falls only on the fools
who made it.

update the draft to make these arguments, i will support it, and i
suspect other dissidents will as well.

randy