Re: Last Call: RFC 6346 successful: moving to Proposed Standard

[Dave Cridland <[e-mail]>]

On 3 December 2014 at 17:15, Dave Crocker <[e-mail]> wrote:

> So, after 25 years of effort, we've achieved 5% penetration.  Wow.
>

Oh, I agree, it's pretty good, especially against a functioning incumbent.

Assuming you take the 1974 Cerf and Kahn paper as the startpoint for IPv4,
which may not be entirely reasonable, then how long was it before one out
of every twenty networked computers used it? 25 years would make that 1999.
Hard to say what the percentages were, but I suspect that OSI was still
significant, Netware had started the switchover from IPX/SPX only the year
before, and Windows tended to use NetBIOS Frames (certainly the installed
base did) - however overall, I seem to recall that IPv4 availability in
businesses was fairly common at that point, so I'd be willing to bet it was
higher than 5%.

However, I would guess it didn't pass 5% until toward the end of the '90's.
Prior to Windows 95, getting IPv4 support on a typical PC required
considerable technical ability, and prior to 1996 or so Win95 didn't
install IPv4 by default, so I doubt the numbers were significant at all in
percentage terms.

So if we pretend - probably incorrectly - that Win95 OSR2 caused an
immediate rise above 5%, then it's 22 years for IPv4.

In any case, it's essentially in the same ballpark.

Dave.