Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RFC Errata for the IETF Stream"
John C Klensin <john-ietf@jck.com> Tue, 11 May 2021 23:39 UTC
Return-Path: <john-ietf@jck.com>
X-Original-To: ietf@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: ietf@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id AED4B3A2AF0; Tue, 11 May 2021 16:39:00 -0700 (PDT)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -1.896
X-Spam-Level:
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-1.896 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_BLOCKED=0.001, SPF_HELO_NONE=0.001, SPF_NONE=0.001, URIBL_BLOCKED=0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id W5IX2bMwpbYy; Tue, 11 May 2021 16:38:56 -0700 (PDT)
Received: from bsa2.jck.com (ns.jck.com [70.88.254.51]) (using TLSv1 with cipher DHE-RSA-AES256-SHA (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 016853A2AEE; Tue, 11 May 2021 16:38:55 -0700 (PDT)
Received: from [198.252.137.10] (helo=PSB) by bsa2.jck.com with esmtp (Exim 4.82 (FreeBSD)) (envelope-from <john-ietf@jck.com>) id 1lgbxm-000Cyi-2F; Tue, 11 May 2021 19:38:54 -0400
Date: Tue, 11 May 2021 19:38:48 -0400
From: John C Klensin <john-ietf@jck.com>
To: Stewart Bryant <stewart.bryant@gmail.com>
cc: Alvaro Retana <aretana.ietf@gmail.com>, Bob Hinden <bob.hinden@gmail.com>, IESG <iesg@ietf.org>, IETF <ietf@ietf.org>
Subject: Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RFC Errata for the IETF Stream"
Message-ID: <073453FA508B5B72BEDBA779@PSB>
In-Reply-To: <4FEB3D6F-E635-43FD-8DE4-FCE2B18F9775@gmail.com>
References: <A3EDA8207BC7C8BE22C9A00C@PSB> <4FEB3D6F-E635-43FD-8DE4-FCE2B18F9775@gmail.com>
X-Mailer: Mulberry/4.0.8 (Win32)
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="utf-8"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable
Content-Disposition: inline
X-SA-Exim-Connect-IP: 198.252.137.10
X-SA-Exim-Mail-From: john-ietf@jck.com
X-SA-Exim-Scanned: No (on bsa2.jck.com); SAEximRunCond expanded to false
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/ietf/QhuzPtRhPMr0BIm6q0PXx6yYabA>
X-BeenThere: ietf@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.29
Precedence: list
List-Id: IETF-Discussion <ietf.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/ietf>, <mailto:ietf-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/ietf/>
List-Post: <mailto:ietf@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:ietf-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ietf>, <mailto:ietf-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Tue, 11 May 2021 23:39:01 -0000
--On Tuesday, May 11, 2021 22:51 +0100 Stewart Bryant <stewart.bryant@gmail.com> wrote: >> On 11 May 2021, at 20:24, John C Klensin <john-ietf@jck.com> >> wrote: >> >> à´à¨ã¸ã¸âà´à¨ã¸ã¸ââ´â´ä¼æ¸âåçæçææç¤â°âä´æç¤âããâ°âããããâããã¨ããââ¬ããããâåçæçæççâäçç¤ææ¸çà´à¨ã¸ã¸âã°ççæçæççâ¸æçç¤ææ¸çäææ´ææ¤æ°â¸ææ¼æ´ã¸âççæ¼çæã¨à´à¨ã¸ã¸âà´à¨ã¸ã¸ã¸ââ¸â¸â¸à´à¨ã¸ã¸ã¸âåæ æâääâæææ¸âæææ¤çâçæ æâçæç çâææ¸æâççæ¼çæ¤ææâæâçæ¼æ°ççæ¤ æ¼æ¸âçæ æçâçæ¼çæ¬çâ¸à´à¨ã¸ã¸âà´à¨ã¸ã¸âäæ¸æâçæ æ¤ææ âæ æçâä¤äåäâææ¼æ¸çææ¸çççã¼ââà´à¨ã¸âà´à¨ã¸âä¤æ¸ââçæ æâæ´ææ¨æ¼çæ¤çç¤âæ¼æâææçæçâçæ æâçæçæ¼æ°ççæ¤æ¼æ¸âæ¼æâææ¸âæççæççæ´ââæ¤çâæà´à¨ã¸âçæ¤æ´çæ°æâæ¼æçæ¤æ¼ççâææ¤ç â¸âà´à¨à´à¨ä¤âææçææâæææ¼ççâçæ æâæ´ææ¨æ¼çæ¤çç¤âææ¸æâçæ¼çæ°æâææçææâæçææ¸âæ´æ¼çæâæ¤æâç¤æ¼çâæ ææâçææ¤æâçæ¼æ´æçæ æ¤æ¸æâçæ æçâçæ¼çæ°æâæ æçæâæ¤æ¸ææ°çæææâçæ æâççæ¼ææ°ææ´âæææ¤æ¸æâæ¼æçæ¤æ¼ççâæ¼æ¸ææâæ¤çâçæçâæ¤æææ¸çæ¤ææ¤ææâæç¤âçæ æâçæçæ¼ççææâæççæççæ´â¸âà´à¨à´à¨ ä æ¼çæçæçâ°âæçâçççææ°ââ ææ¸æâææçæçâçæ¼æ´æâææ¤æææ¤æçæ°çâæç çæçæ¤ææ¸ææçâ¤â°âä¤âæ´âææ¼æ¸ææçæ¸ææâæææ¼ççâçæ æâæ¼æ¸æçâçæ æçâæ¤æ¸çæ¼æ°çæâæ¸æ¼æ¸â´æ¼æçæ¤æ¼ççâççæ¼ææ°ææ´çâææ¸æâ¼æ¼çâæ¸æ¼æ¸â´æ¼æçæ¤æ¼ççâææ¤ç æçâ°âæççæææ¤ææ°æ°ç¤âçæ æâæ¼æ¸æçâ çæ æçâççææ´âæçæ¼æ´âææ¤çæ æçâæ¼çæççæ¤ææ ççâæ¤æ¸âçæ æâæçææçæ¤æ¸æâææ¸æâæçççæ¼çææ°âæ¼æâçæ æâæ¼çæ¤ææ¤æ¸ææ°âææ¼æçæ´ææ¸ççâæ¼çâææ¤çææçæææ´ææ¸ççâæææ¼ççâçæ æçâçæ æâçæ¼çæçâçæ æçâæçæâææ°çæææç¤âçæ æçæâæ´æææ¸â¸à´à¨à´à¨ä¤æâçæâæçæ âææ¼æ¸ææçæ¸ææâæ¼æ¸æ°ç¤âæææ¼ççâçæ æâæ´ææ¨æ¼çæ¤çç¤âæ¼æâææçæçâ°âä¤âæææ¸âççæ¼çæ¼çæâæâæ´çææ âæ´æ¼çæâçæ¤æ´çæ°æâææ¸æâæ°æççâçæ¤æ´æâ´ææ¼æ¸ççæ´æ¤æ¸æâççæ¼æææççæâçæ ææ¸âçæ æâæ¼æ¸æ°ç¤âææ¼çæçææâæ¤æ¸âçæ æâä¤äåäâççæçææ´ææ¸çâ°âææ¼æ¸çæ¤ççæ¤æ¸ æâæ¼æâææ¼ççâççæççã¨à´à¨à´à¨â ãâ¤âä¤æâçæ æâææ¼æçæ´ææ¸çâçæçâççæ¼æçæææâæç¤âæâççæ¤æ°æ°â´ææçæ¤çæâåäâ°âçæ æâåääâäææ¤çæ¼çâææ¼ççæçæçâçæ æâçæçæ¼ççâçæ¼âçæ ææ´âææ¸æâçæ æç¤âææææ¤ææâçæ æçâçæ¼âææ¼âæææ¼ççâæ¤çâ°âçæçæ æççâæçæ¬æ¤ æ¸æâçæ¼âæ´æ¼ææ¤æç¤âçæ ææ¤çâææ æççæçâææ¸æâççæçæ¤æ¸æâççâæâçæçæ¤çæ¤æ¼æ¸âæ¼çâ°âæ¼ççæ¤æ¼æ¸ææ°æ°ç¤â°âææææ¤ææ¤æ¸æâæ¤çâæ¤çâææ¸âæ¼æçæ¤æ¼ççâæææ¤çæ¼çæ¤ææ°âççæ¼ææ°ææ´âçæ æçâçæ æç¤âææ¼æ¸âçâæ¸æææâçæ¼âææ¼âææ¸ç¤çæ æ¤æ¸æâæææ¼ççâ°âææ¸æâçæçæ¤æç¤â çæ æâçæçæ¼ççâ¸ââä¼çâçæ æç¤âææ¼æ¸ææ°çææâçæ æçâçæ æâçæçæ¼ççâæ¤çâæ¤æ¸ææ¼ççææçâææ¸æâçææ¨ææçâæ¤çâ¸âä¼çâçæ æç¤âææ¼æ¸ææ°çææâçæ æçâçæ æç¤âæ¸æææâçæ¼âçæ¼çæ¬âæ¼æ¸âçæ æâææ¼æçæ´ææ¸çâ°âæ¤æ¸âçæ æ¤ææ âææçæâçæ æâçæçæ¼ççâæ¤çâæ´æçæ¬ææâ âæ æ¼æ°æâææ¼çâææ¼æçæ´ææ¸çâççææçæââ¸âââäæ¼æ¸æâæ¤æ¸âææ¸ç¤âææçæââ çæ¤çæ æ¼ççâçæ æâä¤äåäâæ¼çâ°âæ¼çæ æçâçæ ææ¸âææ¼ççæçææ¤æ¸æâçæ æâçæçæ¼ççâææ¸æâççææçæ¤æ¸æâææçæææçæçâ°âçæ æâåääâäææ¤çæ¼çâææççæ¤æ¸æâæ¤æ¸çæ¼æ°çææâ¤â¸à´à¨à´à¨â ãâ¤â åæ æâåääâäææ¤çæ¼çâ°âæ¤æ¸âææ¼æ¸ççæ°çæçæ¤æ¼æ¸âçæ¤çæ âçæ æâæççæ æ¼çâ çâ¤âæ´ææ¬æçâæâææçæçæ´æ¤æ¸æçæ¤æ¼æ¸âæçâçæ¼âçæ æçæ æçâæ¤çâæ¤çâææ¸âæææ¤çæ¼çæ¤ææ°âæ¤çççæâçæ¤çæ âææ¸âæ¼æçæ¤æ¼ççâææ¤ç â¸ââä¤æââç¤æçââ°âçæ æâçæçæ¼ççâæ¤çâçæçæ¤ææ¤ææâ æ¤çâçæ æâççæ¼ææççâææ¸æçâ¸ââä¼çæ æççæ¤çæâææ¼âçæ¼âççæçâãâ¸à´à¨à´à¨â ãâ¤âåæ æâææ¼æçæ´ææ¸çâæ¤çâææ¼ççæçæææâçæ¼âçæ æâä¤äåäâçæ æçæâæâææçæçæ´æ¤æ¸æçæ¤æ¼æ¸âæ¤çâæ´æææâæææ¼ççâçæ æ¤ææ âääâçæ æ¼çæ°æâææâçæççæ¼æ¸çæ¤ææ°æâææ¼çâæ¤çâ¸â ââä¤æâçæ æâääâ°âæ¤æ¸âææ¼æ¸æ¨çæ¸æçæ¤æ¼æ¸âçæ¤çæ âæççæ æ¼çâ çâ¤â°âççæçææ¸çâæ¼çâææ¼çæ´æçâåäâææ ææ¤ççâ°âææ¸æâææ¸ç¤æ¼æ¸æâææ°çæâçæ æç¤âææææ°âæ´æ¼çæ¤çæçææâçæ¼âææ¼æ¸ççæ°çâ°âææææ¤ææçâçæ æçâææ¼çæ âçæ æâççæ¼ææ°ææ´âææ¸æâçæ æâçæ¼æ°ççæ¤æ¼æ¸ âæçæâæ¼æçæ¤æ¼ççâæ¼çâçæ æçâçæ æâççæ¼ææ°ææ´âççæçææ´ææ¸çâæ¤çâæ¤æ¸ææ¼ççææçâ°âçæ æç¤âçæçæ¤æç¤âæ¼çâçææ¨ææçâçæ æâæççæççæ´âçæççææçæ¤çææ°ç¤â¸ââä¼çæ æççæ¤çæâ°âææ¼âçæ¼âåçæçâãâ¸à´à¨à´à¨â ãâ¤âä´æçæ¬âçæ æâçæçæ¼ççâæçââæ æ¼æ°æâææ¼çâ ææ¼æçæ´ææ¸çâçæçæ¤çæ¤æ¼æ¸ââ¸à´à¨à´à¨åæ æçâçææçææçâçæ¼çæ¬æ°æ¼ææâæ¼æ¸âçæ æâä¤äåäâæçæçâæ´æ¼çæâçæ ææ¸âçæ æâæçççææ¸çâççæçææ´ææ¸çâ¸âä¤ççâæ¤æ´çæ°æ¤ææçæ¤æ¼æ¸âæ¤çâçæ æçâ°âæ¤æâæâçæçæ¼ççâçæççæ¤çæçâææ¸ç¤âæææçâçæ æ¤æ¸æ¬æ¤æ¸æâæ¼çâçæææ° æ°ç¤âçæçæ¤æ¼ççâæç ææ´æ¤æ¸æçæ¤æ¼æ¸âæ¼çâææ¤çæçççæ¤æ¼æ¸âå¼æçâææ°æ°å¼âçæ æâæçççæ¼ççæ¤æçæâææ¤ççæ¼çæ¤çæ¤æ¼æ¸âæ¤çââçæçæ¼ççææâ°âæ æ¼æ°æâææ¼çâææ¼æçæ´ææ¸çâçæçæ¤çæ¤æ¼æ¸ââ¸à´à¨à´à¨ææççâ°à´à¨âââæ¨æ¼æ æ¸à´à¨à´à¨çâ¸çâ¸âä¸æ¼çæâçæ æçââ ãâ¤âæææ¸âææâæçç çæ æçâçççæææ´æ°æ¤æ¸ææâææ¼çâææ¼æçæ´ææ¸ççâææ¼çâçæ æ¤ææ âçæ æçæâæ¤çâæâççççæ¤çæ¤æ¸æâæ´ææ¤æ°æ¤æ¸æâæ°æ¤ççâæçæ¼æ´âçæ æâåäâæ¼çâçææ¬æ¤æ¸æâæ¼çæçâæ¤ççâææ¤çæçççæ¤æ¼æ¸çã¨ââåæçæ¼ççâææ¼æçâçæ¼âæ¼æ¸æâæ¼æâçæ æâääçâæ¤æ¸âçæ æâæ´æ¼ççâæ¸ææçæ °ç¤âçææ°æçææ¸çâäçææâ¸ââåæ æç¤âææ¤æççæâæ¼ççâæ æ¼çâæ¤çâæ¤çâçæ¼âææâæ ææ¸ææ°ææââ æ¼æçæ¤æ¼ççâæ¤æâæ¼æ¸æâæ¼æâçæ ææ´âçæçâçæççæ¼æ¸çæ¤ææ°æâææ¼çâæ¤çâ¤â¸ââåæ æçâääâ°âçæ¤çæ æ¼ççâææ¼æ¸ççæ°çæ¤æ¸æâææ¸ç¤æ¼æ¸æâ°âæ´ææ¬æçâæâææææ¤çæ¤æ¼æ¸âæææ¼çç âæ¼æçæ¤æ¼ççæ¸æççâ¸âââä¤æâæ¼æçæ¤æ¼ççâ°âæâæ¸æ¼çæâæ¤çâçææ¸çâçæ¼âçæ æâæ´ææ¤æ°æ¤æ¸æâæ°æ¤ççâæ¤æææ¸çæ¤æç¤æ¤æ¸æâçæ æâççæ¼çæ¼çææâçæ¼æ°ççæ¤æ¼æ¸âææ¸æâççæææ¤æç¤æ¤æ¸æâæâçæ¤æ´ææ¼ççâ¸ââåæ¤æ°ææ¸ææâæ¤æ¸ææ¤ææçæçâææ¼æ¸çææ¸çâçæ¼âææ¤çæ æçâçæçæ¤æç¤æ¤ æ¸æâæ¼çâçææ¨ææçæ¤æ¸æâçæ æâçæçæ¼ççâæçâçæ æâääâççæ¼çæ¼çæçâ¸ââäæ¸ç¤âçæçæ¤æ¼ççâçæ¤ææ¸çâæ¼æâææ¼æ¸ççæ¼çæççç¤âææ¸æâçæ æâææ¼æçæ´ææ¸çâææççâæ´æçæ¬ææââæ æ¼æ°æâ¸â¸â¸ââææ¸æâæçæçç¤æ¼æ¸æâæ´æ¼çæçâæ¼æ¸â¸à´à¨à´à¨çâ¸çâ¸çâ¸âåæ æçæâæçæâæ¼æçæ ¤æ¼ççâæ¼ççæ¼çççæ¸æ¤çæ¤æçâææ¼çâäæ¼åâæççæææ¬çâæ¼æ¸âææ¤çæ æçâçæ æâæææ¼çæâæçççæ¼æææ âæ¼çâçæ æâæ¼æ¸æâæ¤æ¸âçæ æâä¤äåäâççæçææ´ææ¸çâ°âæççâçæ æçâæ¤çâçæ ç¤âçæâæ æçæâççæ¼æææççæçâææ¼çâææææ°æ¤æ¸æâçæ¤çæ âçææ¼çæ°æâçæ æ¼âæçæâææ¤ çççççæ¤çæâ¸à´à¨à´à¨à´à¨
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Brian E Carpenter
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Eric Vyncke (evyncke)
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Michael Richardson
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Brian E Carpenter
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Bob Hinden
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Stewart Bryant
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Spencer Dawkins at IETF
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Spencer Dawkins at IETF
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Carsten Bormann
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… tom petch
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… John C Klensin
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Spencer Dawkins at IETF
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… otroan
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Carsten Bormann
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Lloyd W
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… John C Klensin
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Michael Richardson
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Alvaro Retana
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Brian E Carpenter
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Spencer Dawkins at IETF
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Lloyd W
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Spencer Dawkins at IETF
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… lloyd.wood@yahoo.co.uk
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Carsten Bormann
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Julian Reschke
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Stewart Bryant
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Bob Hinden
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… John C Klensin
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Stewart Bryant
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Carsten Bormann
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… John C Klensin
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Ole Jacobsen
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… John C Klensin
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… John C Klensin
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Spencer Dawkins at IETF
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… tom petch
- Re: Updated IESG Statement "IESG Processing of RF… Stewart Bryant