RE: How I deal with (false positive) IP-address blacklists...

> Second, the fact that 10 years ago you set up sendmail for 
> the computer club at your college doesn't make you an expert 
> on modern large scale email systemms administration. The 
> operational concerns for large-scale email setups today are 
> very different from thost that would have applied to small 
> scale setups a few years back.
> 
> I'm not going to get into the insight real operational 
> experience provides because I also lack the necessary 
> operational experience to have an informed opinion.

To make good standards you need a broad selection of
informed opinion from different viewpoints. Why should
it not be as simple to set up an IETF standard email
system for a small organization as it was 10 years ago?

Definitely there are issues of scale that have to be 
considered, but if the IETF really wanted to have large
scale email operators drive new Internet email standards
then we would hand the job over to MAAWG. 

You are right that the quality of the discussion about
DNSBLs has not been too good. But the underlying problem
seems to be that dissenting voices did not participate in
the drafting of the DNSBL document, and therefore the document
writers had not found the right level of compromise to get
the dissenters on board. Anyone can claim to be a great expert
and write a standards document, but the real hard work is in
getting a group of people with differing backgrounds and
experience to agree with that standards document.

--Michael Dillon
_______________________________________________
Ietf mailing list
Ietf@ietf.org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ietf