Re: [Insipid] Reviews for INSIPID Session-ID solution draft Version 11

["Paul E. Jones" <[e-mail]>]

Roland,

>>>Section 4.1 (and Section 5)
>>>
>>>Would it be worth to mention if the Session-id is case sensitive.
>>>Since when we will need to implement it we have to explicit state it 
>>>if
>>>it is case sensitive or not.
>>
>>Per RFC 3261, "field names are always case-insensitive". I don't think
>>that needs to be repeated here.
>
>[RJ] I looking here from Operator point of view. We have so many 
>discussions about the case (in-) sensivity of fields with vendors who 
>should know. I'm partly OK with your proposal. But nevertheless it will 
>led to wrong implementations seen from my experience with vendors. And 
>the point the following point will confuse a little. On one point we 
>say UUID lower case but RFC3261 points that header filds are case 
>insensitive. Thus I would at least prefer a note.

I'm open to adding anything that will add clarity.  At the end of the 
last paragraph in Section 5 seems to be the right place, since that is 
where we explain that the UUID is lower-case hexadecimal characters.   
However, what I'm not sure about is what else to say.  If you can 
suggest text that makes this clear, I would appreciate it.

Paul