Re: [Int-area] [v6ops] Still need to know what has changed.... Re: IPv10 draft (was Re: FW: v6ops - New Meeting Session Request for IETF 109 - IPv10)

"Bless, Roland (TM)" <roland.bless@kit.edu> Fri, 25 September 2020 15:11 UTC

Return-Path: <roland.bless@kit.edu>
X-Original-To: int-area@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: int-area@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 791E23A0EFB; Fri, 25 Sep 2020 08:11:22 -0700 (PDT)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -1.9
X-Spam-Level:
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-1.9 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, NICE_REPLY_A=-0.001, SPF_HELO_NONE=0.001, SPF_PASS=-0.001, URIBL_BLOCKED=0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id PHIHQNRkll9K; Fri, 25 Sep 2020 08:11:21 -0700 (PDT)
Received: from iramx2.ira.uni-karlsruhe.de (iramx2.ira.uni-karlsruhe.de [IPv6:2a00:1398:2::10:81]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id ECAF53A0EED; Fri, 25 Sep 2020 08:11:13 -0700 (PDT)
Received: from [2a00:1398:2:4006:ba:5b19:4835:74a2] (helo=i72vorta.tm.kit.edu) by iramx2.ira.uni-karlsruhe.de with esmtpsa port 25 iface 2a00:1398:2::10:8 id 1kLpNP-0005N5-0m; Fri, 25 Sep 2020 17:11:11 +0200
Received: from [IPv6:::1] (ip6-localhost [IPv6:::1]) by i72vorta.tm.kit.edu (Postfix) with ESMTPS id A910A4211D6; Fri, 25 Sep 2020 17:11:10 +0200 (CEST)
To: Khaled Omar <eng.khaled.omar@outlook.com>, Mikael Abrahamsson <swmike@swm.pp.se>
Cc: IPv6 Operations <v6ops@ietf.org>, int-area <int-area@ietf.org>
References: <VI1P194MB0285F47132384AC7C0D8A8DCAE3C0@VI1P194MB0285.EURP194.PROD.OUTLOOK.COM> <F2516A37-06B1-44FC-850F-307114B7D6A5@gmail.com> <VI1P194MB0285B8AE9ACE88D1AF051ADAAE3A0@VI1P194MB0285.EURP194.PROD.OUTLOOK.COM> <601FB9F8-DB83-4654-B652-BE07C49F7918@gmail.com> <5ab64d0ebef1402d8bf912b937d7c489@huawei.com> <VI1P194MB02850EAA7D945B9163C84399AE360@VI1P194MB0285.EURP194.PROD.OUTLOOK.COM> <alpine.DEB.2.20.2009251436100.20021@uplift.swm.pp.se> <VI1P194MB028569F3A119BF2B2F59B8BBAE360@VI1P194MB0285.EURP194.PROD.OUTLOOK.COM> <d629ce71-e55b-19d4-aed3-b4867871d754@kit.edu> <VI1P194MB0285B456A9A54CC51AD30388AE360@VI1P194MB0285.EURP194.PROD.OUTLOOK.COM>
From: "Bless, Roland (TM)" <roland.bless@kit.edu>
Autocrypt: addr=roland.bless@kit.edu; prefer-encrypt=mutual; keydata= LS0tLS1CRUdJTiBQR1AgUFVCTElDIEtFWSBCTE9DSy0tLS0tCgptUUlOQkZpME94QUJFQUN5 MlZvaEo3VmhTdS94UEN0NC82cUNydzRQdzJuU2tsV1BmQVlFazFRZ3JiaXdndkxBClA5V0Vo QUlVdzQ1Y29qQmFEeHl0SUdnOGVhWWVJS1Ntc1hqSEdiVi9aVGZvOHIxMUxYOHlQWVIwV0hp TVdacGwKMFNIVWQvQ1pJa3YycENoTzg4dkYvMkZLTjk1SERjcDI0cHdPTkY0Vmh4Sm9TRms2 YzBtRE5mOEVtL0dsdDlCYwpXWDJBQXZpelRtcFFEc2hhUGplMThXSDM0KytLd1BaRGQvc0ov aEhTWGlQZzFHZGhzL09HL0MwQ0pndU9BbHFiCmdTVkFlM3FLT3IxTTRLNU0rd1Zwc2szNzNw WFJmeGQ3WkFtWjA1aUJUbitMZmdWY3orQWZhS0tjc1dyaTVDZFQKVCs3SkRMNlFOUXBveCti NUZYWkZTSG5FSVNUKy9xemZHN0cyTHFxWW1tbDZUWVk4WGJhTnlYWlAwUUtuY2ZTcApSeDh1 VFJXUmVIVWExWWJTdU94WFloNmJYcGN1Z0QyNW1sQy9MdTBnN3R6NGlqaUtpSXdxOStQMkgx S2ZBQWZZCnlZWmg2bk9vRTZFVDBUak9qVVNhK21BOGNxalBXWDk5a0VFZ2YxWG8rUDlmeDlR TENMV0lZN3pjbVNNK3ZqUUsKZ2RVRnBNU0NLY1lFS091d2xQdU96OGJWRUNhZnhhRXRKSkhq Q09LOHpvd2UyZUM5T00rRytibXRBTzNxWWNZWgpoUS9QVjNzenR0L1BqZ2R0bkZBWVBGTGM5 MTg5ckhSeEtzV1NPYjR4UGtSdy9ZUUFJOWwxNU9sVUVwc3lPZWh4Cm1BbVRzZXNudFNWaUN6 KytQQ2RlWHJRYzFCQ2dsOG5EeXRyeFcrbjV3MWFhRThhTDNobjhNMHRvblFBUkFRQUIKdENG U2IyeGhibVFnUW14bGMzTWdLRlJOS1NBOFlteGxjM05BYTJsMExtVmtkVDZKQWowRUV3RUlB Q2NGQWxpMQpmTHdDR3dNRkNSTE1Bd0FGQ3drSUJ3SUdGUWdKQ2dzQ0JCWUNBd0VDSGdFQ0Y0 QUFDZ2tRbzQzYTJXUTRsZTRsCkp3Ly9SNlgvSVY3Zmllem1ZRFZtNHpzM05Fb1hHdGdPdDBP bnk0MFNaS0xZVW9vc3pBSWFBZHNQU2lDenhTSHgKTmEwZnpGZWtYd0YxNWtjWC82cXdEUnJq d1Y0R2F2YWFSeUt3cUdOeTlvOU4ySHh6aXU1dUo1UWthaC9qS2prSwovTzlXclY2NnFuRmVX cWFzRVVSakNDMlR6WCtJSllFT0F4U0xmSnY5STFocHdrV2dZUzdWdVZjQkg2VDBPb2RkCmM3 YnovK1YzMmQ2VjdiNXFLRldJSzJaeXluMXJsRHlHSXh0bTZiTi9Ed2RtYzNCelRVN2hlNlV3 VW10NlAxTlcKc0V3K2RVK0F4TE1VcTJJTTV2eVB3NDJPMytmZkFkZ0xpNkhTV0NwV3NxNDlN bFZsSzZIUThOenI3eGtkek1lLwpwV0pLa2JMKzZZTWpZRjVESENTT3l4ZTNDZWNKODRDZFFR Y3o2TERySWhHSnI0VGR3eU54K2J6WUhJTUg1Zkp0Cmk5eDVWY0hHV1NaZnZDcXJVTDg5U3VG RHBEa0p3QlVkVm9ITUZlWXEwbGZtcUVYZ0tzdld1U3JHREIxYlhhTi8KZUdFTW9EbWd3NXpz b0ZJN1dERksvQ0doMnl1bUhmclBnTXVGNUwzNVhsZC83MFlIenRuR2lpS2pqSW40RHBjagpO WnhiZUlXcUJZVklIOEErRXFZVy91MmlrK1loT0U2d0JhQy92Z3krYkhkcVZCcE96VVp6THpu L1BRZ2xKUkpNCmRkRlV0SXRnWThESFRQbFVMKzQ4ckluZFRrek5zaEg1ZUdSWnJISDRMenFX aDdqY0p5U1Y3M3NyWG1nYzNZZVEKMnlzT3RFMVVIQ04vREF4aklpTFU0RUh2b0pkdE51dCsw SzA0R0tyc2liQ3FrdiswSGxKdmJHRnVaQ0JDYkdWegpjeUE4Y205c1lXNWtRR0pzWlhOekxt UmxQb2tDUFFRVEFRZ0FKd1VDV0xRN0VBSWJBd1VKRXN3REFBVUxDUWdICkFnWVZDQWtLQ3dJ RUZnSURBUUllQVFJWGdBQUtDUkNqamRyWlpEaVY3anY1RC93TlZnOFFKV3BkeXFPMThoZjcK TjVUSUFyZ1EzWWtCUXloVXZYKzh6Y1RsZjJ0UzM0TDV5dkN3eTU2YUV3a3lDbHU1bTBlZmhz bmh0Tkg4K3hNbgo0czlEMnZycS9XZzhQemNBdE5ld2dZeklrVENsdStHSjgrQkNlaEhVSHJ6 K1IvazRrSVo2QTR5WVhtWXVydGJJClRnQndOUVJKSFBzY2NqZnYzbkJoRDQ0UldsNkt4ZGF4 NUloaEwydS9IeitERHo1bzh2b3I0TU9ZNmFsS3RnSW0KTUJZc0p1aGc1bGg4c2FqRlBrM2pn NCsvUEVjdGtsNmJXTnV0R3lHWE1EZGJyQXlZNzgxMjk3V1ZKK0ZkekFkVAo5QzU3bHBYMk5t UUZURTQ1aWZFaUM3Tlh2aFB3SDJQeFh6TGJqeE1pSnJtT1pUcVllQzAyZXkyRE9SclFMTjlm ClNKSTRmNXRwVm5mK2cwTXB5K0xWQm5tcVoxSnNocmtRaUJkNlZxUi9YbVR0Q3o5NElBTGg5 YXFGakxabFM0QjkKR0JnT2dYNEVkcHFLVGU0cHVSaFFMU21pSVA0bHBsS3p4U1dod2piYjI0 V2xJcFRHQlhVUmFlMXh6UGJNN05HagpFZUhFVjF5UEkwU3NERkNGQXZ0UHNnRW5wT1VWQjNk b2pDeE80dStxZjR5bGFScXZ6dkFzbis2ZklPZkpVY3pnCjNqUGNRWWpvMnFFNzJvUnAzaS81 NWp6L2hlLzlsOFNpQmRRdk15NThuQW1WYjV1ZXBlZTRMaklvRXlwTWRmdmIKa203bENTdHJG WWdlcVFTYjZYZ2hnNEUwU1hMK2pCa2tWTk1WOU9lQVE4anJ5SEFjWTYwcndFcjFmaWhPaW9s WgpaWmM1eXdHcmVvK1g1cXUyL242VU1CYXFFclFvVW05c1lXNWtJRUpzWlhOeklDaFVUU2tn UEhKdmJHRnVaQzVpCmJHVnpjMEJyYVhRdVpXUjFQb2tDUUFRVEFRZ0FLZ0liQXdVSkVzd0RB QVVMQ1FnSEFnWVZDQWtLQ3dJRUZnSUQKQVFJZUFRSVhnQVVDV0xXSFJ3SVpBUUFLQ1JDampk clpaRGlWN3MxcEQvc0g0MUp3emMwWnVLOStHZ0RGbnFYRQpNNGs0S24rQ05YSzNDK2xRK09P K3V4NGNoYkkzQ2g5OVJPUnVZRXc4VzZiRE9LWnBJSVNuaTY2VDZOOUdDdDZtCit4UFlueUpL U1U3ekx0RXJVbEpuRjZ0TXo4aDJmaDhSM2pGcEtMSll4dDRQK0dIcEFxb0ZzS3dldGsrelRH S3QKQUUwSHRUQmdtVXdEOEVqeGdsR1U5NHFLdWRQTk5CVENQS0pKQmsxMHQ0ZGxQZHRucHU1 UEs3K3hOK1Bic25iOQpmV0JIRXU3U08vS1lJREhXcVFFcUQ5MEZnZE43Y3p5c0k2a0trbnI4 dXVMaWd4R3RGSUx3RE56MFd5Y1RtR1pWCjlYTjZ2d25Wc0tjSUZJZ0lUTFQxcjJyMWxrM01P aXBKT250SU1PS0JaUTBQb1dhS0M3K2E1V0VkM29IVmVBejIKZGJvQytkYnRNRUFrQnZhaWlE RjdKUUhaaW0wUTVCSEZoam90bTFnSFdNaUI0WVVCZVMwcm1tc1F0ajlyem1FUgo1eE9jcitT azFkMWU2WWhZRHhZeWcxdm9JZ2tYZTFSbjZIZWcyTm05c3M4SW5RakwzdFVMSnZQalJLeCts UG9UCktUQzNnaVF6THRUanIxMkd4WjA1S28zb09iQ29xVktFbllGN0NLT0pKZnFBSzJaYVNx Z3FKa2t6NFlvKzZ6TW4KcnY5WWpzR3pRbzdZcW9HK2VXUk94SkhmT0pxL2JHNnVDWnYrRUJw MVNOOUt1Rk5yM1JrbmpXMVk2SGRaNm8zOQoxRGN6OW1RdmgvY1k3QWhiaW1Hd2wrbU11RWty aEhMbTdYWm5RYXB0ZDZjYm11R2FqMGlOQTBFazlnaHd1NThTCjlRR2tSa1dHSWVjNk5yMFlO NHFaQkxrQ0RRUll0RHNRQVJBQXRnaVRhZFB5TDVMK0Nqb2w4WXJiREYyWGl2WHkKTkRWTmlW TmExdE9IVEN4ZXR5UmZBQllpZXFua2k5cGp4NkRJaS9ueHVZNWNjdE9kTVRIYVRDc1o0UTFY VE1jRAo3VEloc1d3Y243NjE3dGZQekFlNGZoTlF4MkZVWFJSVDJpOW80c1BnYjUrc0UwOTlU SXJodlZvZEZnSWFGdkkyClBDRjhTa0sxSiswRkRpckZvY3paYjFhVHFFb3pJbHVGbDVMRkFO QkVGVzVwYkpFdnpKeFRvQXEvS3Z4YXNBdk4KU2o4dmxTeHp3ZlN2d2V1YmtIYVdzTy9INHdJ RUZVS3FjUis0RkJkUkdLWFdWc3FJemZsZkI3U3ljZnZjbGdHWQowaFR1ZmR6aGQvNjlKd3h4 TW5Mam80WG53cTZxOUF3NEUyRkRiWVRuVkNqdGdzMCt6TGNIa2JRSDlKOXU4MjhLCkdMNUU3 NGlHMGZ0WlZkYnpaTVdsTFdlbnRhN1RzYjZKMFROVHQzWFJTTTBhZjBMbjdoM3ozdEdLb1JM S3dTQmwKdFdoUDZXVnZKSVRVSlFlcXJkdExKeS9YQlE2NXdldnZKQXh0M3Yvem95dFNBa0kv V1A4c3F5VldseW56MjNSNApTNmJJSWZFekF6NkIvbDEwSlF5Wll6QTlQdnY2TzNKRHQwbjJ2 R2JNb2RWbW04aWtBMkZ3NWc0SXZaUXFHa095CjM3aTFLYURMeVZmaEZxTkl4T0VWdjhBUmtH eXlhZWJyTXVZdEg0UVNyZzhMQ25TeHQ2amduK0hYcVNIRGJvMnUKbVptUjBVL3QwUlJZNzJm M1FJYXdscVVVOFdRRFpWcFMyYytvYlU2Q2JwUUdVQ1ErcFhLVmEreEZZQTEvOHVIRApjQ2hl L1hvRmx6d3p6cjBBRVFFQUFZa0NKUVFZQVFnQUR3VUNXTFE3RUFJYkRBVUpFc3dEQUFBS0NS Q2pqZHJaClpEaVY3cERLRC80elhvb0pZL0gzcHg5bG51MGlic2dhZlB1Uzk1L0hqY0g4R09R dVJ2bnJROUJPdjVaTGZ5WS8KVkhYVTJzOFhnZGVlSzFSVjBjNW5EZC9vUmdqbVlCZ01sZFRl M2ZNVE9uUWFrYlI1a1REN3VYMU1YMHFxelBhWgpxZ01Ob0pzd0h0SHM3VmIyalBzZWNlY1NB OWxtVG9qcXZIY2ZTamlxNldhSzNwSTdOeGhBTjFkY0pXZXpaTE1mCjZQQ21kT0lTM2luRWRh OU9zeEF5emY4Z1BoYy9DRDJ0Q3FxYm9heTlOZEcwQTRBSVh2YU9Vd05QM0RDYWNhUzYKaDRW OWdMUHVYRUFJU2d3N0ZpYnQ2QWMyVVpEZXg0ZngwNlZycTVrMEVVWjRpeGtub2k5TTNiWXBW MzZNTXNSbAp4K2tGb3R6R1dKcVRxdm5yYSs2T0JCaG01dG9wOGFWV3pQaldKbWliUGpBSXY4 K1c3RHY2d0FjSFRPY3JKdkljCkd3aHJmdGFCRERrY2pIRkpQN2tZM0pZRTJUTlRZUnFGNXRW Sit1L2tYb2J0T0l1d3dPbS9IWGRSL0FCWUdVanQKaCtDQ292dWNnQzNacVBuN1FpVXZOelgr bG91b1NaeWh2V2xrSXlpL3FwbWFnUkhMZnc5cmtTUmxnQkVWT2ZnOQpFY0RWZjR2WlVCUW1E WXh2VjAzc05BVDJHSndiUnhaYy9heVU2aG9RN3VMbTdwVXBHOFFDdDB5SlBGOHluVEwzCm45 N1ZmKzVpUXBuR2xXeWRtS0RWTFpIU2lZS0Rvb0NVekFWekVidUNHOHF0Ukl2bmZkSmNZYUl5 aXBYL2NvTHMKNmNaT1NtQlJsSXM2ZEhiYjNUYmwwUWJXSzhNOHBFdXJ3YzA1UzZoMmRLYnhv elgwMHI3cmpRPT0KPTVuZDYKLS0tLS1FTkQgUEdQIFBVQkxJQyBLRVkgQkxPQ0stLS0tLQo=
Organization: Institute of Telematics, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology
Message-ID: <94b9aa4e-301a-3b9f-3561-f2b404971a5d@kit.edu>
Date: Fri, 25 Sep 2020 17:11:10 +0200
User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64; rv:68.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/68.10.0
MIME-Version: 1.0
In-Reply-To: <VI1P194MB0285B456A9A54CC51AD30388AE360@VI1P194MB0285.EURP194.PROD.OUTLOOK.COM>
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="utf-8"
Content-Language: en-GB
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit
X-ATIS-AV: ClamAV (iramx2.ira.uni-karlsruhe.de)
X-ATIS-Checksum: v3zoCAcc32ckk
X-ATIS-Timestamp: iramx2.ira.uni-karlsruhe.de esmtpsa 1601046671.072992217
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/int-area/FMqw6ZFjdLrviAl1Yz4qwY9Hyzc>
Subject: Re: [Int-area] [v6ops] Still need to know what has changed.... Re: IPv10 draft (was Re: FW: v6ops - New Meeting Session Request for IETF 109 - IPv10)
X-BeenThere: int-area@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.29
Precedence: list
List-Id: IETF Internet Area Mailing List <int-area.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/int-area>, <mailto:int-area-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/int-area/>
List-Post: <mailto:int-area@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:int-area-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/int-area>, <mailto:int-area-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Fri, 25 Sep 2020 15:11:23 -0000

Hi Khaled,

Am 25.09.20 um 16:41 schrieb Khaled Omar:
> Roland, the sending host will encapsulate an extension header with two different IP versions, where is the contradiction here? I don't see it.

This is a bit sad, but probably one last try:
An IPv4-only host does only understand a single IP version, namely IPv4.
Inside an IPv4-only host there is NO understanding of a
different packet format (IPv10) or IP address format (neither IPv6 nor
IPv10) by definition. Consequently, it cannot encapsulate an IPv4 packet
into an IPv10 packet by lack of knowing the format and functionality.
Otherwise you have an IPv4/IPv10 _dual_ stack host, but that
is then not an IPv4-only host by definition.

Regards
 Roland

> Khaled Omar
> 
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Bless, Roland (TM) <roland.bless@kit.edu> 
> Sent: Friday, September 25, 2020 4:38 PM
> To: Khaled Omar <eng.khaled.omar@outlook.com>; Mikael Abrahamsson <swmike@swm.pp.se>
> Cc: IPv6 Operations <v6ops@ietf.org>; int-area <int-area@ietf.org>
> Subject: Re: [Int-area] [v6ops] Still need to know what has changed.... Re: IPv10 draft (was Re: FW: v6ops - New Meeting Session Request for IETF 109 - IPv10)
> 
> Hi Khaled,
> 
> Am 25.09.20 um 15:04 schrieb Khaled Omar:
>>>> You don't even have running code to be able to verify that your proposal actually works (it doesn't).
>>
>> Do you have a running code to state this?
> 
> How should one create running code out of a flawed specification?
> The following picture from your draft already shows that it definitely cannot work, thus no code needed:
> an IPv4-_only_ host by definition does NOT support IPv10 and thus CANNOT send any IPv10 tunnel packets. Same for an IPv6-_only_ host.
> 
> IPv10 Host                                         IPv10 Host
>     PC-1                                                PC-2
>    +----+                                              +----+
>    |    |                                              |    |
>    |    |                                              |    |
>    +----+                                              +----+
>   /    /   <--------------------------------------->  /    /
>  +----+              IPv10 Header (Tunnel)           +----+
>                               (3)
> IPv4-Only Host                                    IPv6-Only Host
> 
> Do you see the contradiction here?
> 
> Roland
> 
>> -----Original Message-----
>> From: Mikael Abrahamsson <swmike@swm.pp.se>
>> Sent: Friday, September 25, 2020 2:43 PM
>> To: Khaled Omar <eng.khaled.omar@outlook.com>
>> Cc: IPv6 Operations <v6ops@ietf.org>; int-area <int-area@ietf.org>
>> Subject: Re: [v6ops] [Int-area] Still need to know what has 
>> changed.... Re: IPv10 draft (was Re: FW: v6ops - New Meeting Session 
>> Request for IETF 109 - IPv10)
>>
>> On Fri, 25 Sep 2020, Khaled Omar wrote:
>>
>>> That’s why looking into the transitions solutions became a mandatory 
>>> or a peaceful solution such as IPv10 that will allow both version to 
>>> coexist and communicate until the full migration.
>>
>> No, any change now just resets the clock and postpones the transition by another 20 years.
>>
>> Meaningful support for IPv6 has been available in end-devices since 
>> the
>> 2006-2008 timeframe when Windows Vista was released and around the same timeframe other end-user operating systems gained support as well.
>>
>> We're now in 2020 in a situation where basically every end user device 
>> in use has IPv6 support, even laggards like Smart TVs have started to 
>> gain
>> IPv6 support. Printers have had IPv6 support for 10+ years.
>>
>> For your proposal, you have zero running code and thus zero devices supporting your proposal.
>>
>> You keep making these statements that upgrades are easy. They are not. 
>> Ecosystems take a long time to build. You don't even have running code to be able to verify that your proposal actually works (it doesn't).
>>
>