Re: [IPFIX] draft-ietf-ipfix-flow-selection-tech-07

Benoit, All,

If fsFlowRecordTotalCountis equivalent to field #3, isn't 
fsPacketTotalCount equivalent to #2 and fsOctetTotalCount equivalent to #1 ?

Also, there is an issue with section 7 of this draft: it doesn't 
describe the semantics for any of the new IEs.
The word "Total" in the names seems to describe their function and not 
the semantic.
It's especially important to know whether these are absolute or delta 
counts.

P.

On 28/07/11 07:01, Benoit Claise wrote:
> Dear all,
>
> Today, during the WG meeting, I had the action item to double-check 
> the IE id.
> Basically, no problem with Write-up on that front.
>
> From that list, the TBD1 should be assigned the value 3, as specified 
> in http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-yourtchenko-cisco-ies-01#section-3.1
>
>                    +------+---------------------------+
>                    | ID   | Name                      |
>                    +------+---------------------------+
>                    | TBD1 | fsFlowRecordTotalCount    |
>                    +------+---------------------------+
>                    | TBD2 | fsFlowRecordSelectedCount |
>                    +------+---------------------------+
>                    | TBD3 | fsPacketTotalCount        |
>                    +------+---------------------------+
>                    | TBD4 | fsPacketSelectedCount     |
>                    +------+---------------------------+
>                    | TBD5 | fsOctetTotalCount         |
>                    +------+---------------------------+
>                    | TBD6 | fsOctetSelectedCount      |
>                    +------+---------------------------+
>
> Not sure what the process is.
>     - directly replace TBD1 by 3 in the draft
>     - warn the IPFIX IANA expert, i.e. Nevil, that 3 should be assigned
>     - something else?
>
> Regards, Benoit.
> _______________________________________________
> IPFIX mailing list
> IPFIX@ietf.org
> https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ipfix