replay field size
Derrell Piper <piper@tgv.com> Sun, 09 February 1997 00:52 UTC
Received: from cnri by ietf.org id aa03366; 8 Feb 97 19:52 EST
Received: from portal.ex.tis.com by CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa17786; 8 Feb 97 19:52 EST
Received: (from majordom@localhost) by portal.ex.tis.com (8.8.2/8.8.2) id TAA28943 for ipsec-outgoing; Sat, 8 Feb 1997 19:40:41 -0500 (EST)
Message-Id: <199702090044.QAA04984@fluffy.cisco.com>
To: ipsec@tis.com
Subject: replay field size
Date: Sat, 08 Feb 1997 16:44:44 -0800
From: Derrell Piper <piper@tgv.com>
Sender: owner-ipsec@ex.tis.com
Precedence: bulk
There was clear consensus at the ANX IPSEC bakeoff last week to make the size of the replay field 32-bits for both AH and ESP. If we _must_ have alignment for IPv4 IPSEC then the additional bits should be specified as alignment. No one wants to do 64-bit math for replay computation. It's silly. In my opinion, IPv4 is misaligned for 64-bit hardware anyway and I don't see the point of aligning the fields just to keep the protocol consistent with IPv6. I don't think this issue needs the Security AD to resolve. I think we already have consensus. Let's hear now from anyone who absolutely must have 64 bits or else move to revise AH and ESP to reflect consensus. We have much more interesting things to argue about. Derrell
- RE: replay field size Roy Shamir
- RE: replay field size Michael J. Oehler
- Re: replay field size Niels Ferguson
- replay field size Derrell Piper
- Re: replay field size Matt Thomas
- RE: replay field size Roy Pereira
- RE: replay field size Ran Atkinson
- RE: replay field size Roy Pereira
- Re: replay field size Tim Bass (IETF)
- RE: replay field size Rob Adams
- Re: replay field size Dan McDonald
- RE: replay field size Ran Atkinson
- Re: replay field size Robert Glenn
- RE: replay field size Roy Pereira
- RE: replay field size Dan McDonald
- Re: replay field size Germano Caronni
- Re: replay field size John Keating
- Re: replay field size Derrell Piper
- Re: replay field size Ran Atkinson
- Re: replay field size wei
- RE: replay field size Stephen Kent
- Re: replay field size Matt Thomas
- RE: replay field size Phil Karn
- Re: replay field size Theodore Y. Ts'o
- Re: replay field size Perry E. Metzger
- Re: replay field size Niels Ferguson
- Re: replay field size Bill Sommerfeld
- Re: replay field size Theodore Y. Ts'o
- Re: replay field size Uri Blumenthal
- RE: replay field size Bob Monsour
- RE: replay field size Stephen Kent
- RE: replay field size Stephen Kent
- Re: replay field size Stephen Kent
- Re: replay field size Stephen Kent
- Re: replay field size Ran Atkinson
- Re: replay field size Steven Bellovin
- Re: replay field size Ran Atkinson
- Re: replay field size Jim Thompson
- Re: replay field size Bart Preneel