Re: [Jmap] draft-ietf-jmap-mdn-06

[Raphael OUAZANA <[e-mail]>]

Hello,

Le 6 mars 2020 20:35, de [e-mail]

On 3/5/20 7:40 PM, Ken Murchison wrote:
> A few questions as I implement this in Cyrus:
>
> - forEmailId is allowed to be null, presumably just for MDN/parse
> responses.  Should we mandate that it be non-null for MDN/send,
> because otherwise, what's the point?

Exactly. I'm adding a word about this.

> - subject and textBody are both allowed to be null.  Should we
> recommend default text for both?

I think it asks more questions than it solves an issue. How the server can choose the good language to send the notification?

> - The JMAP server may not be able to determine the Final-Recipient of
> the original message was Bcc'd or sent to an alias.  Should the MDN
> object include a 'from' property?

It should match the email of the account, no?

Or maybe we should ask for an identity when sending an MDN, so that the user can choose which email appears in this field?

Also, do we need a specific error type if the email corresponding to
fromEmailId does NOT have a Disposition-Notification-To header?  Or do
we use invalidProperties, forbidden, invalidEmail, noRecipients?

It seems I missed the notFound error, I'm adding it.

Regards,

Raphaël Ouazana.