Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-korhonen-mext-mip6-altsec

<Basavaraj.Patil@nokia.com> Mon, 24 January 2011 22:00 UTC

From: Basavaraj.Patil@nokia.com
To: arno@natisbad.org, jan@go6.si
Thread-Topic: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-korhonen-mext-mip6-altsec
Thread-Index: AQHLvBKLTg4gV2FeYUKwegM9zkfBrQ==
Date: Mon, 24 Jan 2011 22:03:33 +0000
Message-ID: <C963527A.D013%basavaraj.patil@nokia.com>
In-Reply-To: <878vyarmku.fsf@natisbad.org>
Accept-Language: en-US
Content-Language: en-US
user-agent: Microsoft-MacOutlook/14.2.0.101115
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"
Content-ID: <a0e04f7a-e4b8-4f3b-a673-35d82f358f83>
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable
MIME-Version: 1.0
Cc: julien.laganier.ietf@googlemail.com, mext@ietf.org
Subject: Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-korhonen-mext-mip6-altsec
Precedence: list

Inline:

On 1/24/11 3:58 PM, "ext Arnaud Ebalard" <arno@natisbad.org> wrote:

>
>To me, what the draft describes is a patchwork based on MIPv6, ESP and
>TLS. Instead of building on top of those protocols (read modularity and
>interoperability), it reuses (hijacks) various blocks of associated
>standards in a non-modular way. For instance, one has to reimplement ESP
>in userspace to support the protocol.

We are specifying an encapsulation method in the I-D. To say that one has
to reimplement ESP in userspace is incorrect.
We are reusing TLS which is widely implemented today. I do not see a
problem with reuse.

>
>Additionally, it does not support RO.

We are adding RO support to the spec. It is not a big deal to support RO
between MIP6 nodes. Securing the RO signaling messages between the MN-HA
uses the same method used for the BU/BAck messages.

-Raj

>
>Cheers,
>
>a+
>
>[1]: http://permalink.gmane.org/gmane.ietf.mip6/10368
>_______________________________________________
>MEXT mailing list
>MEXT@ietf.org
>https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mext

Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-kor… Hidetoshi Yokota
Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-kor… Laganier, Julien
[MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-korhone… marcelo bagnulo braun
Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-kor… Jan Zorz @ go6.si
Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-kor… Arnaud Ebalard
Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-kor… Basavaraj.Patil
Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-kor… Behcet Sarikaya
Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-kor… Jan Zorz @ go6.si
Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-kor… Arnaud Ebalard
Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-kor… jouni korhonen
Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-kor… Domagoj Premec
[MEXT] IRON - a new approach to mobility manageme… Templin, Fred L
Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-kor… Laganier, Julien
Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-kor… Suresh Krishnan
Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-kor… Ahmad Muhanna
Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption ofI-D: draft-korh… Templin, Fred L
Re: [MEXT] IRON - a new approach to mobility mana… Templin, Fred L
Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-kor… Jouni
Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-kor… Laganier, Julien
Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-kor… Laganier, Julien
Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-kor… Jouni
Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-kor… Laganier, Julien
Re: [MEXT] IRON - a new approach to mobility mana… Templin, Fred L
Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-kor… liu dapeng
Re: [MEXT] IRON - a new approach to mobility mana… Templin, Fred L
Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-kor… Julien Laganier
Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-kor… jouni korhonen
Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-kor… Julien Laganier
Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-kor… Jouni
Re: [MEXT] Call for WG adoption of I-D: draft-kor… Julien Laganier