Re[2]: Multiple signatures over a document

"Nickolay L." <ni4@ukr.net> Fri, 13 October 2006 09:16 UTC

Received: from [10.91.34.44] (helo=ietf-mx.ietf.org) by megatron.ietf.org with esmtp (Exim 4.43) id 1GYJ9v-0008In-To for openpgp-archive@lists.ietf.org; Fri, 13 Oct 2006 05:16:51 -0400
Received: from balder-227.proper.com ([192.245.12.227]) by ietf-mx.ietf.org with esmtp (Exim 4.43) id 1GYJ9q-0004fq-6G for openpgp-archive@lists.ietf.org; Fri, 13 Oct 2006 05:16:51 -0400
Received: from balder-227.proper.com (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by balder-227.proper.com (8.13.5/8.13.5) with ESMTP id k9D8rE2E098415; Fri, 13 Oct 2006 01:53:14 -0700 (MST) (envelope-from owner-ietf-openpgp@mail.imc.org)
Received: (from majordom@localhost) by balder-227.proper.com (8.13.5/8.13.5/Submit) id k9D8rEFi098414; Fri, 13 Oct 2006 01:53:14 -0700 (MST) (envelope-from owner-ietf-openpgp@mail.imc.org)
X-Authentication-Warning: balder-227.proper.com: majordom set sender to owner-ietf-openpgp@mail.imc.org using -f
Received: from cielago.ip.net.ua (cielago.ip.net.ua [82.193.96.15]) by balder-227.proper.com (8.13.5/8.13.5) with ESMTP id k9D8rBGp098402 for <ietf-openpgp@imc.org>; Fri, 13 Oct 2006 01:53:12 -0700 (MST) (envelope-from ni4@ukr.net)
Received: from infernal.org.ua (82.193.103.213.ipnet.kiev.ua [82.193.103.213]) by cielago.ip.net.ua (8.13.6/8.13.6) with ESMTP id k9D8qWiM065292; Fri, 13 Oct 2006 11:52:32 +0300 (EEST) (envelope-from ni4@ukr.net)
Date: Fri, 13 Oct 2006 11:51:23 +0300
From: "Nickolay L." <ni4@ukr.net>
X-Mailer: The Bat! (v3.80.03) Professional
Reply-To: "Nickolay L." <ni4@ukr.net>
X-Priority: 3 (Normal)
Message-ID: <1388499092.20061013115123@ukr.net>
To: Jon Callas <jon@callas.org>, ietf-openpgp@imc.org
Subject: Re[2]: Multiple signatures over a document
In-Reply-To: <BB4E694E-A8AF-4D18-A092-399F47E20420@callas.org>
References: <166808470.20061011132150@ukr.net> <BB4E694E-A8AF-4D18-A092-399F47E20420@callas.org>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
X-Virus-Scanned: by amavisd-new
Sender: owner-ietf-openpgp@mail.imc.org
Precedence: bulk
List-Archive: <http://www.imc.org/ietf-openpgp/mail-archive/>
List-Unsubscribe: <mailto:ietf-openpgp-request@imc.org?body=unsubscribe>
List-ID: <ietf-openpgp.imc.org>
X-Spam-Score: 0.1 (/)
X-Scan-Signature: e472ca43d56132790a46d9eefd95f0a5

Hello Jon,

JC> Could you provide a sample document to show the issue?
Hm, i've sent files as soon as you sent first request.
Maybe, there were some problems with mail server.
Here is second attempt :

1) two example keypairs (password for both is 'password').
2) encrypted and signed file without one-pass entities
3) encrypted and signed file with one-pass entities

-----BEGIN PGP PRIVATE KEY BLOCK-----
Version: PGP 8.1 - not licensed for commercial use: www.pgp.com
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=oQP9
-----END PGP PRIVATE KEY BLOCK-----
-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
Version: PGP 8.1 - not licensed for commercial use: www.pgp.com
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=nyli
-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----

-----BEGIN PGP PRIVATE KEY BLOCK-----
Version: PGP 8.1 - not licensed for commercial use: www.pgp.com
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=+GSA
-----END PGP PRIVATE KEY BLOCK-----
-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
Version: PGP 8.1 - not licensed for commercial use: www.pgp.com
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=i+vp
-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----

-----BEGIN PGP MESSAGE-----
Version: EldoS PGPBlackbox

wcBMA2EOYp9nZ4O1AQf/U090w5aCiUItJwjEDG7Xlzj65ZNpkPkH8ASfG4BCqIFN
OOQ7y2DivVgJgYOxVy1tivoJu3pecxw8sBHNi40TtfO3LKfQEmzUpDS+BWJtfFYz
IfOfzh+dS1ykYvDpg9KquXBLFTCQooD0d5gbJwrH4vAwXsd0srR80lz1DOGoypn6
/xV0TvwFisiXgrb2bHWCEG/Ds/qFpvq+hreJeMUSHICAEfOOxImxWFfKySPp92Yr
+Ou6dJdXiMmFy9X9jlZ4A271Q/MtTcYzYg4bshiRDfMBitcMdzVBRsB7DMqoUKOV
3eUenFa3mIdLhbYrIGhU9GjGsdBlC2ntm1iJAQVZ0MnA0cxqub+Vj/tqy4KsbxwK
LM99r63MYB/l2GtklCd9r5WTOe6f9mOlQOcuUsQgOh9LSiv3gw7Xu2X2Fasu/O9e
xswyYrUIp8uYS9GPtOC+olmh0A6FjkNexX/GNDMy8ES8/CwK7WQcB0bFDfMuOwLK
EwMVCmIA9CovNccYCUfFZqTNP9mDNlEDCeppscBs+Q3OY4DfFjS5SAcdYdS/bfuQ
DCGlxji/3weqyIBHblEmPxwYjKKC5+O4pf93ACulw3GI+VWAHA8FsLKgL2LdwKYG
YR60JYEe55J4j1Wu1QL9KHzgfw+UVm7I7Q8jLA7ZTCr4kjHYUbhz1kfRLZZBLuEX
5J9PMRWigxPJ37HWtnPtIS9vhV5Vi4VOJjX0GPWebmpmfHTykhhMyk6JavXN+MEW
1CboilXFEcwlpQFL254VWbEgNu3uCWv48qE2U3oRG+sp1mB2+wXX6Wb/nCnORq6P
8rzWWw010ShRcE17h18DIp3idgG6ufpbZ0AP6XjylvsvLUP4AkT0Hx8vhehcc8aR
HTLQ
=gsjO
-----END PGP MESSAGE-----

-----BEGIN PGP MESSAGE-----
Version: EldoS PGPBlackbox
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=7bNN
-----END PGP MESSAGE-----


--
  Best regards,Nickolay mailto:<ni4@ukr.net>