Re: [Pesci-discuss] PESCI team meeting on September 30

Spencer Dawkins wrote:
> Dear Pesci,
> 
> Thanks for getting this started. A couple of notes inline.
> 
> Spencer
> 
>> Discussed and agreed workplan to move forward with I-D.
>> - Use existing material as basis
> 
> 
> Do I know what "existing material" this is? What I'm really asking is, 
> is this material something besides, for instance, the review board draft?

It really means however much we can find time to review in the short
time available - current drafts are clearly part of it, recent mail
discussions, etc - I would certainly look at personal communications too,
but there is certainly no reservoir of private material.

> 
>> Looked at ways to open up discussions in Vancouver
>> - Agreed that a BOF will allow focus
> 
> 
> To quote Lurch, from the Addams Family show - "uuuuuugh..."
> 
> But I've said plenty about using BOFs/WGs for process evolution.

Well, we have to start somewhere with public discussion.

> 
>> - Deadline for BOF request is Monday 3rd: Harald will draft a
>>   request
> 
> 
> Just to ask the question, is there any need for an Open General Area 
> meeting, where PESCI might be one of the topics? ("are there any other 
> process items that we could combine, so we don't have multiple 
> general-area slots scheduled?" I note that techspec is also headed for a 
> BOF in Vancouver, and it would be nice to avoid spending two or three 
> slots on process).

Well, my preference is for focus and clearly separated slots
when that's possible. From the time estimates for PESCI and Techspec,
it would seem hard to fit them together in one slot.

> 
>> Brainstorming on the call about problems included:
>>
>> - Newtrk issues are in scope but we should allow Newtrk to work
>>   - maybe scope to provide input through principles 

Did you mean to comment on that? I think our feeling is that PESCI
is clearly separable from techspec and IPR but not from newtrk, so
we can't rule the core newtrk issues out of scope.

    Brian

_______________________________________________
Pesci-discuss mailing list
Pesci-discuss@ietf.org
https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/pesci-discuss