Re: [proto-team] Re: PROTO - proceeding on adding PROTO shepherds to the tracker

On May 14, 2006, at 7:49 AM, Henrik Levkowetz wrote:
>
> 3.2. Notifications	
>
>    Under the assumption that the tracker already has the ability to  
> send	
>    email notifications when certain state transitions occur, the  
> tracker	
>    should be able to send out notification to one or more email	
>    addresses when one of the followings states or sub-states are	
>    entered(R-012):	
>
>    * Awaiting MIB Doctor Review	
>
>    * Awaiting Cross-Area Review
>

It seems that there are other kinds of expert review besides MIB  
doctor.  You could consider the security review to be an expert  
review although naturally that can also be cross-area review.  The  
MIME Types list does some kind of expert review which could be  
handled the same way as MIB doctors. And it's interesting to consider  
expert review for i18n issues.  Should this be simply "Awaiting  
outside review" or, if we want to preserve the difference, "Awaiting  
expert review" and "Awaiting cross-area review"?  If we preserve the  
difference, what if both kinds of review happen simultaneously?

I do have an action item from the retreat to work more on the early- 
review problem, so my questions here are somewhat influenced by  
thinking how that might work.    (And by the way Allison, Aaron,  
Henrik and proto-team, I welcome input from all quarters on that.)

thx,
Lisa

_______________________________________________
proto-team mailing list
proto-team@ietf.org
https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/proto-team