XListReceivedDate: Tue, 15 Oct 2019 23:59:49 0000
==_mimepart_5da65d7320ec6_65293f9be08cd9607922c
ContentType: text/plain;
charset=UTF8
ContentTransferEncoding: 7bit
This confusion comes from when we changed Absolute Index to start from 0, and Base *Index* became just "Base". What is Base now anyways? Base is now a *Count*, and perhaps we should rename it to Base Count everywhere.
Because Base is a Count and not an Index, it shouldn't really point anywhere in the diagram. Maybe we should remove the arrow entirely, and just say, `Base = n  2`
If we really have to have an arrow, then where should it point when Base = Required Insert Count?
Required Insert Count = 2
Base = 2
```
Base

v
 1  0  # Absolute
 0  1  # Relative
```
or
```
Base

v
 1  0  # Absolute
 0  1  # Relative
```
Or when Base is 0 ?
Required Insert Count = 2
Base = 0
```
Base

v
 1  0  # Absolute
 0  1  # Relative
```
or
```
Base

v
 1  0  # Absolute
 0  1  # Relative
```

You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.
Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub:
https://github.com/quicwg/basedrafts/pull/2935#issuecomment542452651
==_mimepart_5da65d7320ec6_65293f9be08cd9607922c
ContentType: text/html;
charset=UTF8
ContentTransferEncoding: 7bit
This confusion comes from when we changed Absolute Index to start from 0, and Base Index became just "Base". What is Base now anyways? Base is now a Count, and perhaps we should rename it to Base Count everywhere.
Because Base is a Count and not an Index, it shouldn't really point anywhere in the diagram. Maybe we should remove the arrow entirely, and just say, Base = n  2
If we really have to have an arrow, then where should it point when Base = Required Insert Count?
Required Insert Count = 2
Base = 2
Base

v
 1  0  # Absolute
 0  1  # Relative
or
Base

v
 1  0  # Absolute
 0  1  # Relative
Or when Base is 0 ?
Required Insert Count = 2
Base = 0
Base

v
 1  0  # Absolute
 0  1  # Relative
or
Base

v
 1  0  # Absolute
 0  1  # Relative
—
You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe.
==_mimepart_5da65d7320ec6_65293f9be08cd9607922c