Return-Path: X-Original-To: rats@mail2.ietf.org Delivered-To: rats@mail2.ietf.org Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by mail2.ietf.org (Postfix) with ESMTP id 59392113E1030 for ; Thu, 9 Jul 2026 05:08:25 -0700 (PDT) DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/simple; d=ietf.org; s=ietf1; t=1783598905; bh=tD3c7kWmvMGkbWPVe0sUg50gdHfnWHOCA9MHGpMqmJY=; h=Date:To:From:Subject; b=SaJvWcPyKuRSXE2FkBvVPTVtateLFil0Df9Gy/CRa+VHTYnr0Tyu3ZmNJygMcJFzR ymjSECp/KQAqZMyGuu9kj+LdTTOZhc6r96nSk6OnjS/0xALJZaEg0tVf2GK5kIO1Dp xt28U5qQSzp1nCVAZNjshOX8uhj14eXcVSQV1Zgk= X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at ietf.org X-Spam-Flag: NO X-Spam-Score: -2.795 X-Spam-Level: X-Spam-Status: No, score=-2.795 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, DKIM_SIGNED=0.1, DKIM_VALID=-0.1, DKIM_VALID_AU=-0.1, DKIM_VALID_EF=-0.1, FREEMAIL_FROM=0.001, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_LOW=-0.7, RCVD_IN_MSPIKE_H3=0.001, RCVD_IN_MSPIKE_WL=0.001, RCVD_IN_VALIDITY_CERTIFIED_BLOCKED=0.001, RCVD_IN_VALIDITY_RPBL_BLOCKED=0.001, SPF_HELO_NONE=0.001, SPF_PASS=-0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no Authentication-Results: mail2.ietf.org (amavisd-new); dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=gmx.net Received: from mail2.ietf.org ([166.84.6.31]) by localhost (mail2.ietf.org [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id muSo8BwLym9B for ; Thu, 9 Jul 2026 05:08:24 -0700 (PDT) Received: from mout.gmx.net (mout.gmx.net [212.227.17.20]) (using TLSv1.3 with cipher TLS_AES_256_GCM_SHA384 (256/256 bits) key-exchange ECDHE (P-256) server-signature ECDSA (P-256) server-digest SHA256) (No client certificate requested) by mail2.ietf.org (Postfix) with ESMTPS id B09FF113E102B for ; Thu, 9 Jul 2026 05:08:24 -0700 (PDT) DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=gmx.net; s=s31663417; t=1783598897; x=1784203697; i=hannes.tschofenig@gmx.net; bh=tD3c7kWmvMGkbWPVe0sUg50gdHfnWHOCA9MHGpMqmJY=; h=X-UI-Sender-Class:Message-ID:Date:MIME-Version:To:From:Subject: Content-Type:Content-Transfer-Encoding:cc: content-transfer-encoding:content-type:date:from:message-id: mime-version:reply-to:subject:to; b=s1u7tlx/sGfGbPHNIFyIO3kdCcbSqCZ8efXgtPUtEUKbLJRYbnPW8s9w0f1N6L9u klOqjRcIsVb0TkTlfvRRUN/Ws0H7WvV29434NGyIbxU3SOsV1URFr/p6224HzS7yy C9pFXwDxyE2bHaRJwiNAe/r6t1znA3Q8KSu1nCB+UNVX/hS4k9yJWD1+jIKUQys66 8+/0Vure3o/Zh0xNawwru496t69t+bZLsYhLz4lTADAlT4ieKKyEK0DLWRyLhhAWY +qhAIUa3L8jSJy7srxm2UTObS4OmVlzxGnBI0R7O6feyRoMElYpw95JgU8rsYHF9i ZMQEZxlK5AAkGXZPuQ== X-UI-Sender-Class: 724b4f7f-cbec-4199-ad4e-598c01a50d3a Received: from client.hidden.invalid by mail.gmx.net (mrgmx104 [212.227.17.168]) with ESMTPSA (Nemesis) id 1MxDkm-1x1XOC3qbg-00uRgH for ; Thu, 09 Jul 2026 14:08:16 +0200 Message-ID: Date: Thu, 9 Jul 2026 14:08:16 +0200 MIME-Version: 1.0 User-Agent: Mozilla Thunderbird To: rats From: Hannes Tschofenig Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8; format=flowed Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable X-Provags-ID: V03:K1:rHTxe2apxn075UjzZfkmF68dGJQHD3SkcepR7Z6z55IdeLNBo1h Iy/GX7eObhmWF3mqUa5N9jxMsazV4zt/lPoMOd49yJPO7KLonk7iZWve21W0OWIPrxOgKqy bJP//P/M3Akz873P95GyLkr3TeTqUmFmimxiDbT3SCFlKekNaoEqMa8eSS4WVYsA67+cLHl Wt9pUtm08jFcd6ocAQCCg== UI-OutboundReport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:lt7Vxj1Pfr0=;2VDxRAFgz5o2UusnqymMCEhICIG 1iOkNS5vY4XXsawigJ6Jpg9jsijBZiIIKRZ+cBGj9W1cnkP8DfRk/77qCD+74R67EL1r4zyys 8wwXDXM4L6Ns4SZ6+xp86n6nSOR8ovJeipJ2x/O+msc6bsNZZJPDVsSwsFS/Ue7G1Bf0Jp/+m iXhUmmBolljArb4KkpsNCXYLKbI5v9Y+7iR0gYBy2FNT+qZqovx3E4U6aLDEKl+rU51FtM8ac RgeBMjCjNJ4zuDF1h6t9X+jcNYnBxMEw38HL2fTXceUXYD0pzJcvdAJRKybrf54OoyF08M3Go PifKM9PQIaYcxPFoSEfLsdPNsRhJwiiX5EbGwW9Lvosj0PI4M9Xc+7+Q4/TUGitXwJXK1DELf B6bTFR6k+NWtttJGCQIQbwrfogrVZ76MYOPh6dqfEc4TPnMlLwCt9wtvTav71253zpDMBn6DX CHfxsW4s9jkv4te7v/I6tNJ+zPBYJ3Elv6j1edFRABj/QhT9gy+xdKJidVmxGNDkPOoxgkXPD BKPaGdt+VZpxhkhUB4fkWSmf58fhZX0vSD4oU3gxDaTsKCY/0fLNTMM/mmkB3mbWviyYCDftI fVhwsuKoXnRdN0i4IhkhriLjh961OPoCBPazj3swb+AC4BCXjVd6CjL8TGF5Jx5tnwReIGIwB UGzVVtNIcmMWTo81gKV8438IqHwfBvAw7O3p7uYMOwnoIC3AxT40zq32CXnPN2gUd4JVkBm0N IbruvAIfYmXIQ6PwkHLdNYfIygJeQhKxMOsgeuO04iQWwyxLVWykdDOk4Al0QVi8L25uc/61R 9BXzHQ8rXczvSelj/6AarVtv/ycFS68jUjSVC60U//CP7Y+JAub7N3EOV9vBa792pgWbRmFyW Y87FiNB6zc6rhvkJvhj1iRaTfwt0pJXcJEs7uSwR9wnhqTNJK6WY2uZoF4ZRpZ88akVPxNerd RQzrzaAtg/uFmRDZtq5fc0lXA07IPbaqaCkgmskWR3EY2FF/bu9G3B2gBlfKniWIFNADkvMUT V+hQOKTBh6lUZZn9mBlIxFkmx9jBJTUeqMGf40YVoz0WtLrPVgqDuhRqbPRUfNvuKqDfypzL9 tHDLcMuLjTuIDpyMMhhfnSdPbcSNOAPLVl5Z8xrgeAo/wTMfBKVyvLQoAF6gEUdydMbcY+okD r2kreYozCwkM9j4y10128/TcEC1jX2woi6VkaUbhvkwxUTt+TIk3OJKn+MNhWUa4CZHRHI+UN ZGZB+F+UMNz/RCen4Z1Qcf40cc4DgyZHcl5pZ0FrRY7ivdO5iofrrI/WGUJPDAAEhIYbZ9bwo vs0J03kyzkcXz5FC6rv4Ebnhy5nwdZh2ZrOU6trSG/4wjOjM8ybelSprvn6vLq403lUX5mLnp JcM2O/wClXQY/aSU3x3w2bHIdvqEddouYgHlLbwj7LV4dr0bfAzOazKyWJfMmdScHm296uOVL A07nQIMYkl6WC9g1NpNTbSu+HGWtBYlXDBB14N2lvAZvyXKXdB+qLD+/5hLQZ+X9L22WP1v/g lBAWZ0k/tfkO6PzECzC5gcGpQ7Rlt1T4wskEwGKQN71KivgRqrHmVvh9Z1MNV8Dcbke5q9R0E 73NG6HMfc5iOBcyrF2L7pngWe3Ad0PtHCMsfWYhmC2Zbnqm9IDWh0r1Axg/IZDYzLoBsypQVf WNZ1IJbcd7WwFLUtcBFHBkKm9VXNQeNtialGtiE+aZT0Vuax1Bg1OHw2U0x/GOa1QBMGjUTae VLXSNX2aekqt7ABuQ9pKQ0fYd2yM9CLQLIyo/IRdV2eLc5BEX/qucQCOKcJNW3hPoxFvrWhn5 1yMo8wv6JLOYd8Exh2/ch2rQPgaDW8CpTq/LkZXXmEcO34feOgE29bpZ9SEsDzEahlHtF3HZd 9wXl82jv68PimoMa6trXifaRTaDJ7CSs/XjsfiKe64Gh6t41bv+LiB0sV8HEdjKrQeeexpXwX SrMRCXN3D/7RDNOLpGZ2OxXJHJhho3raQ6SkEiX3mT9ssbUBIn0rrpgxICvFNraMT9VUZ9kQJ SrrYlafGlaPSujrqB7lLS8AtoxeqvDpVFP6itgc543soApaUA+zerAKQeCQszyn2cG1h+xR/X R7M9NaD1nJrrtvKVLW4jh/38qgY6/w2eamu1shEEjPnoaZ7eCm56GxTVUgI17YbW2hGy27pWh tms5O/8Owpz+yCw9dExuTe1rZYenUq5atUsLZIiEU2FbKgpuKrbgX7YNqMyt3WP/Ti/UyVk7s xT3uxSScnUyPv4qTmYZe9fEVqQv9vfo7wKJhqOUsQTY/oWFj49GPukXeJTFM78laBtpizHPZ1 r4r85NS0E8zPegBA6BQevtGPJXwmpMF89ToJ1AfIONt5ZUGjDXD6EPTSusyAP6W6vKHNSsTM/ DRqo5wY6z57xBrXj80HfjNVVMBGCbDeaYjTrOHtg+KzqKaohL/GbxLE2bKrqBDKZAgWtqgsf/ hLB2HAjdiMzHOKxzD54EQ8QXB3C0yXLd3LsQpcu7PlyWh+ohlomSmdFTMgePZ0r+DhXshOlaY yAlA3bAqvAHpf9DL6HRjdLeCFldt87LNAmuMs9znC+PHSombmv6ZI/h/hjTNXSQ8hRs5SRPEo i6IQJ+1pGgk6T2eepsd7jbnB3lDDaB3XKMutQ5Gy1y1kSN9F/yUOSCM5fWH3yb4Z+Row31mHP jYdQXO74m4ky7sriWUpr+Bn8AM7jXLUfhRN62ofdhY84GWjsujc2egbgi1GxzxFe6zO13wIqB 7SmTxJ1Iv2Vm4fVkdL4MryOieZ+8PSQ6Vkh2YrFOae39XyrbQzp76o+H7D5RI06mZaHT/8hnz N+2mZGBQZrF/Y9LW0kh3IFODRCpqyNPNMFGyCk0AtnHlAYi7vI6PMbA2LxQ1EaSWa47+ixnaE XWElNeTwN3qgjRSxzMPfE81Cawo605BjwIc8zkquac42WkrR7kYx8xr9bNtaHrzbaINl/24tI xjU+xBvGF9lyaX568PBI9/iGXwmEZPPe23GeAwcb2mWvqqcHhLWsNXtYX13JfoXdDtSGsnbFR X2WmEDS2eMFLruP3dmbUS2AHL9YKsiJ6n1X7zpvnz8wjy5jffLERm7zyqYmrgQjRejgGMqhc7 gpRDCjUPD4Li/RzNLotysEQ5uzfIrNveAcqpYxRLoHsoe+xwSSLBLutg5IBvyZe7BD5CCO+8M mOwyAayRLl0tSYGvnhEwqe36LqghCEfngaKtU3GOjjb8rrZ4QvfzgdSca5R84rjXdgoAbrlI/ TPMtG58b9un3GjwWrVwAUJq6oWWyfqVznay8/Ey1xFV1umkbcMiBjypBICztxeUW7DGRU2d9Q Jy/eFdY+uzuGX58v/R0dnKk7UzLAnIAHIvpD4cpnDZrloL4ypjqugjOkh/HJ5ScZ+Ok6y285U FSkLcLafven1EDh5i9qig+eG5vQpH0ul5EPEvFe/bUYcIRTNkhE4J8EtFzf7kTAlsDbWVpcgA szYP997ag22+KXL+5nPwMVJnSH/LidMQxSV4YXenjVyfoirjyeW4wH230lf4GCI+u3cIlte/P QiXWkiTZZ99wgod05KMtR7pvcdlLwcoeB4esLEobqcyPapBNstgdfRV96/zZHbgQQzMrGcaG5 ep04owbUP4yNq+FUPiRy4f+pnEhqeD7FCsgQQXhCWEXD7AGBZnsXtPuUFA7VQSx8RSHkynGM2 5EPT1c078kVysVqUE5qmRBIsrqfKJL4M225C7kOMluD/ZusmThvySqQ5sFBqk+jk2egxE+6aU 50dCMBFTuYIxgKzInOnlyn+0SiSAY5tUAmwipYOkmpduS4UK6p3Dxh1icIOKLt5Mmx9vwcxJ/ FlRyvfDpVwCdfR7pmzNxzTQuIvXdRo6XX4WX9Oz30BxIFEFvmK+cisK8y1qSNoj9GNMJK4MLR KlS05gme81B/mtwh9mAK2YqFPQYdN2URNIl4noGoLuCnhzXaxTewFy37IL/Tr+daDlwgs86X+ ZcU8LkQvsruWM9HkHx+UqI7Azpz5TA9zeWP3fMnjtmFc+zuKrY7pJrHGLloSOqo5FxT2kQ2Rm X0TPPGPzbIwiEsC0sJko97F+HiniVKa8DkMeKG543CcT9WkwIlV+6DphrRloTwzvc0t3ztL1s guKxcvO/jK+lPbOh1jQqGFfzbrD5xqtCEziGWGem+Iff3ok39Pe8PGFYp3n4UrGzek361dvAn JMIIb9TxNZ1yUoFsvCexKZcJcQBDqOVhYIJrTLcySyAZuqdkSky6zLxgzNjVpprRQ+013bHJe iD/ZGSevSwneat9D+VD8EdlxHAppZH68tYy2kSZ7Ti5dapl3PWKRC9mfvTuxLEYZlh70j45OW MbfHd5BIbeVm3TBV1sNNSl2pkD+X1F4gteS3sOLCf5sTx30X6NJNhM5cF4f0Z0g5EdNH+eOMT hP/eSluC1mPLFou39+UWokTQg97NX2G78qoHpfJInsR7/O4yYxFjz8/zd0bHGkVyGiK+AN681 gdqaxBB8bhDTB7J//VX4rfztbfzDTAViVbub3FkerSrbUBnSDxGRc5ii4FD82Ehtg7EL4A7TS VG+vEuRxuRlEFOB4dwUrRdokQcSNdCZhKbYFgsxx5Gwblv9vlRl9ahsOJVqpv/lkzdZXAZdve BxitGhZe9UYQlUqEa95MaHdw3Trqu4OgW2yrSx+nm/efCLOlSSeyfNQ1Nr9gmrLA0IhHLDqQq XPDbtusETYFyrXzyGJhJtaLbWwoNwR24rSFLTJFZr+gHrHjNTAtKZdNcn0mVhOHu+IpgdaQLJ rUKy03ZGvbOBl90zx8rSUr3cZ7ELWmuw9dHDE7b+obddgHK8r8RGOkz3EEJP+Vm3hvWDf/Jkv Y13Ha+/8IFVdC5rx816baKIlXZ6pO86MazDcPMfi5M0qos1VPieTjPwcGmTncG6oeVlrGHelq XWAPaAYj1EdU9hw06UAwB9m1bCLL42VH5KuWv2CTSHwgFhDSfxYKiPy1An9etPixSATHOExHW RbeR5dJd9RPyXDrbiHTBE/cieceY5RMU2SSrLKrjMWKw4GnfNDM6e7Pp2ebMOxGdjTGnwebHD VdiHPTP9JuBlo1rQxGj7O6KggYHSKzVWhm73llRIrielETvgvJRn6o3ldLhrQkebrThO7o5wu qNOOVbIjeouGEKPUVsEjAvErayJu5WF1/1jfZe5ryEVt4vPjffBZV7MnMkQxHJ+S7a5rQivk8 CFIQDk5blVO+lfKqk2ouAqZJcX3kF0HAUbgfWFin4nmDAb6ioWv8i0o0c/wQFL1yCUYDGfiAY 26l3OM8/TyBBn/iBBTK4uIKwICTutRuWaf59z/+GPtPViAP4eXUrHaKByAiiDOhZRBRczq5cl hydn9g85NLSuf+fb+i/c5wNZ8NtdowFZEC+FbgnSAwPwM7GV4FoVgzxeLDj1QcY0y4q/fchVM 6n2iNRPjkegrD5JE1x1rDj/TZC0cEJk2v1siKcufTPzQuAsLTjpbYEOSMbEijCIaOHhda7tKi enLUE1adlQm5DgA== Message-ID-Hash: 3KGKBO62QIAHFY23ULPWNYXPQ3MDNXUM X-Message-ID-Hash: 3KGKBO62QIAHFY23ULPWNYXPQ3MDNXUM X-MailFrom: hannes.tschofenig@gmx.net X-Mailman-Rule-Misses: dmarc-mitigation; no-senders; approved; emergency; loop; banned-address; member-moderation; header-match-rats.ietf.org-0; nonmember-moderation; administrivia; implicit-dest; max-recipients; max-size; news-moderation; no-subject; digests; suspicious-header X-Mailman-Version: 3.3.9rc6 Precedence: list Subject: =?utf-8?q?=5BRats=5D_LAMPS_Attestation_Freshness?= List-Id: Remote ATtestation procedureS Archived-At: List-Archive: List-Help: List-Owner: List-Post: List-Subscribe: List-Unsubscribe: Hi all! The CSR attestation draft made good progress this year in the IETF LAMPS= =20 group and it is now in IESG review. This progress unblocked the work on the LAMPS freshness draft, which=20 offers a nonce exchange over a certifiate management protocol (such as EST= ). We have made a substantial update to=20 https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-lamps-attestation-freshness/= =20 and would like to hear your feedback. To make it easier to provide feedback, we have put slides together=20 (which will also be presented at the LAMPS meeting at IETF 126). You can= =20 find them here: https://github.com/lamps-wg/lamps-attestation-freshness/blob/main/slides/f= reshness-ietf126.pdf On behalf of the authors, thanks for your time and interest. Ciao Hannes