[rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode
nico at cryptonector.com (Nico Williams) Fri, 23 January 2015 23:04 UTC
From: "nico at cryptonector.com"
Date: Fri, 23 Jan 2015 17:04:47 -0600
Subject: [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode
In-Reply-To: <E378C876-5217-4274-86B6-1DBFB653DE24@vpnc.org>
References: <54C20F92.4090400@seantek.com> <54C232FC.1000604@gmx.de> <54C275BC.1040905@alum.mit.edu> <20150123175511.GI2350@localhost> <54C28E3F.4040901@alum.mit.edu> <E378C876-5217-4274-86B6-1DBFB653DE24@vpnc.org>
Message-ID: <20150123230443.GO2350@localhost>
On Fri, Jan 23, 2015 at 10:39:26AM -0800, Paul Hoffman wrote: > By "work", I think of "is the solution understandable to a typical > Internet Draft author", and here things fall apart. It is possible to > mark artwork as a fragment; it may not be possible to sanely say what > it is a fragment of. Many RFCs have multiple ABNF modules or ASN.1 > modules, so there would have to be some way to say "this is a fragment > of that module" *and* say "and the whole goes in this particular > order". I'd be happy with a mechanism that collates multiple figures into a synthetic appendix and which can extract the same. I'd prefer the reverse for authoring, but beggars can't be choosers. A mechanism that collates artwork wouldn't be difficult to implement in XSLT... Just provide an attribute for naming the file/module/appendix/ whatever, and an optional attribute for specifying collation order; the XSLT to collate that almost writes itself. Nico --
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Sean Leonard
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Julian Reschke
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Paul Kyzivat
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Nico Williams
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Paul Kyzivat
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Nico Williams
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Paul Kyzivat
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Paul Hoffman
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Paul Kyzivat
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Nico Williams
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Sean Leonard
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Nico Williams
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Ted Lemon
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Paul Kyzivat
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Paul Kyzivat
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Ted Lemon
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Nico Williams
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Nico Williams
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Paul Kyzivat
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Paul Kyzivat
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Nico Williams
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Nico Williams
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Sean Leonard
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Julian Reschke
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Julian Reschke
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Paul Kyzivat
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Sean Leonard
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Ted Lemon
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Sean Leonard
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Julian Reschke
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Julian Reschke
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Paul Kyzivat
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Sean Leonard
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Paul Kyzivat
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Sean Leonard
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Nico Williams
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Nico Williams
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Sean Leonard
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Nico Williams
- [rfc-i] [Json] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourc… Nico Williams
- [rfc-i] [Json] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourc… Bjoern Hoehrmann
- [rfc-i] [Json] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourc… Sean Leonard
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Sean Leonard
- [rfc-i] ABNF Core Rule extensions Paul Kyzivat
- [rfc-i] ABNF Core Rule extensions Dave Crocker
- [rfc-i] ABNF Core Rule extensions Nico Williams
- [rfc-i] ABNF Core Rule extensions Dave Crocker
- [rfc-i] [Json] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourc… Bjoern Hoehrmann
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Bjoern Hoehrmann
- [rfc-i] ABNF Core Rule extensions Julian Reschke
- [rfc-i] ABNF Core Rule extensions Bjoern Hoehrmann
- [rfc-i] ABNF Core Rule extensions Julian Reschke
- [rfc-i] ABNF Core Rule extensions Bjoern Hoehrmann
- [rfc-i] ABNF Core Rule extensions Julian Reschke
- [rfc-i] [Json] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourc… Sean Leonard
- [rfc-i] ABNF Core Rule extensions Dave Crocker
- [rfc-i] ABNF Core Rule extensions Paul Kyzivat
- [rfc-i] ABNF Core Rule extensions Sean Leonard
- [rfc-i] ABNF Core Rule extensions Julian Reschke
- [rfc-i] ABNF Core Rule extensions Dave Crocker
- [rfc-i] ABNF Core Rule extensions Paul Kyzivat
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Paul Kyzivat
- [rfc-i] ABNF Core Rule extensions Dave Crocker
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Bjoern Hoehrmann
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Paul Kyzivat
- [rfc-i] ABNF Core Rule extensions Paul Kyzivat
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Bjoern Hoehrmann
- [rfc-i] ABNF Core Rule extensions Dave Crocker
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Riccardo Bernardini
- [rfc-i] ABNF Core Rule extensions Sean Leonard
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Paul Kyzivat
- [rfc-i] v3imp #8 Fragment tagging on sourcecode Paul Kyzivat