Re: [Roll] [ROLL] Projected DAO and Extended MOP

["Pascal Thubert (pthubert)" <[e-mail]>]

This is all very convincing Rabi.

Let’s discuss in Singapore. Will you be present ?

I plan to publish an update today or Monday.
The update will have proposals for a number of items that were in the table, advertising siblings, requesting a route, compressing the VIO based on RFC 8138 and building Tracks.

This is a lot of stuff and I expect we’ll need more time than I initially expected at the WG meetings.

Regards,

Pascal

Le 1 nov. 2019 à 01:24, rabi narayan sahoo <[e-mail]> a écrit :


Hello All

If my understanding is not wrong ID draft-ietf-roll-mopex-cap-00 is introduced to support Projected DAO. I think Extended MOP is not required for projected DAO.
Objective of P-DAO is to enable a path computing element (PCE) with global topological view of the network, knowledge of device capabilities and various network parameters to compute and install optimized (TE) routes to meet certain application requirements (Application scenarios requiring P2P path between devices).
Why Projected DAO is more of a Capability Compare to the Mode of Operation?

1-     The core mesh network will always operate either in Storing or Non-Storing mode. Projected DAO will use the underlying topology to compute more efficient p-routes and install them either in storing or non-storing mode. A new LR, irrespective of it supports projected DAO or not it has to join the network. This joining decision is completely based on which mode global network is operating and the new LR supports it or not.


2-     P-DAO is more like a capability. This capability mostly includes if the LR has enough memory to store the P-Routes and support to do SRH based packet forwarding.
Let’s consider the below scenarios
1—Global Network is Storing

     *   P-Route to be installed in Storing mode

For this to work all the LR need to have P-Route table

  *     P-Route to be installed is non-storing

Just the Ingress node must store the route entry in the P-Route table and all other intermediate LRs in the P-Route process the SRH header and forward the packet.
2—Global Network is Non-Storing
               Same requirement as above mentioned in storing mode case.
So P-DAO is independent of global mode of operation of the LLN.

What do you all think?

Thanks
Rabi

_______________________________________________
Roll mailing list
[e-mail]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/roll