Re: [TLS] I-D Action: draft-ietf-tls-oob-pubkey-08.txt

[Hauke Mehrtens <[e-mail]>]

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

On 07/30/2013 03:50 PM, Hannes Tschofenig wrote:
> Hi Hauke,
> 
> 
> I addressed your earlier comments with the most recent draft
> update. There is this issue left:
> 
>>>> Could you add some list definition where the numbers assigned
>>>> by the IANA should be added later. I like how it is done in 
>>>> draft-mcgrew-tls-aes-ccm-ecc-06 for the CipherSuites [0].
>>> 
>>> The above-mentioned draft uses a different registry but I guess
>>> you are asking for a snapshot of the current registry. For
>>> example, something like this:
>>> 
>>> - ------------------------------------------------------ Value 
>>> Description 	          Reference 0	           X.509 [RFC6091] 1
>>> OpenPGP	          [RFC6091] 3             Raw Public Key
>>> [This RFC] 3-223	 Unassigned 224-255	 Reserved for [RFC6091]
>>> Private Use - 
>>> ------------------------------------------------------
>>> 
>>> Is this correct?
> 
>> Isn't the final number in the end of the standardization process
>> added to the draft? I was just thinking about adding a
>> placeholder for that number in the draft. For the Certificate
>> Type there is already the excepted number added in the draft, but
>> for the server_certificate_type and client_certificate_type there
>> is a placeholder missing.
> 
> I have not added the current snapshot of the registry to the draft
> at the moment. I am not convinced I should do it since the (more
> accurate) data will in the end be in the IANA repository.
> 

Hi Hannes,

yes, I also think you should not add a number into the draft till it
is assigned by the IANA.

Now I get the meaning of this block:
   Value: 2
   Description: Raw Public Key
   Reference: [[THIS RFC]]

I was a little bit confused, but this is nice. ;-)


Could you also add such a block for the TLS extensions?

   Value: TBD
   Extension name: client_certificate_type
   Reference: [[THIS RFC]]

   Value: TBD
   Extension name: server_certificate_type
   Reference: [[THIS RFC]]

Hauke
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.11 (GNU/Linux)
Comment: Using GnuPG with undefined - http://www.enigmail.net/
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=e0hU
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----