Re: [Tools-discuss] Deletion of unused and broken trac instances

[Jay Daley <[e-mail]>]

> On 15/03/2021, at 11:22 AM, John Levine <[e-mail]> wrote:
> 
> It appears that Jay Daley  <[e-mail]> said:
>> To support Robert as The Tools Team PM, I am working on an RFP to move all the wiki pages in existing trac instances to a new wiki
>> product and all the issues to GitHb repositories.  In preparation for this work, I propose to have all broken and unused Trac
>> instances deleted so that we do not waste resources having those migrated.  
> 
> Do we plan to keep backups of the broken instances in case someone in
> the future thinks there was something of interest in them? I don't
> propose offering a recovery service, just "here's a copy of the files,
> good luck and let us know if you find anything."

Yes we do.

Jay

> 
> R's,
> John
> 
> 
> 
>> 
>> - Broken instances are ones that cannot be started by the Trac software.  They may well contain data but as no support calls have
>> been raised since they broke some years ago, I am assuming they are no longer needed. 
>> 
>> - Unused instances are those with no edits made and no issues raised.
>> 
>> The following lists have been circulated to the IESG and WG Chairs and one instance moved from one list to another.  Please note:
>> there are multiple examples where a specific WG/Team uses a set of wiki pages underneath inside another wiki, not actual wiki set
>> aside for that purpose, which remains unused.  e.g. genart pages are under the gen wiki not the specific genart wiki, which is
>> unused.
>> 
>> This is just a final check to make sure there are no concerns with this deletion.  Please let us know in the next few days if you do
>> have a concern.
>> 
>> PS There will be a follow up this week about what Wiki product I propose we switch to.
>> 
>> thanks
>> Jay
>> 
>> 
>> 1.  List of the broken instances along with an estimated date for when they broke.  24 in total.
>> 
>> Jun 10  2019	ITU-T-CITS
>> Oct 22  2014	aaadoctors
>> Jun 11  2019	add
>> Jul 10  2015	appsdir
>> Oct 22  2014	genart
>> Jun 26  2019	iepg
>> Oct 22  2014	intdir
>> Oct 22  2014	iotdir
>> Jun 11  2019	lake
>> Jun 11  2019	loops
>> Jun 26  2019	mentor
>> Oct 22  2014	mibdoctors
>> Jun 11  2019	mops
>> Oct 22  2014	opsdir
>> Oct 22  2014	perfmetrdir
>> Oct 22  2014	raiart
>> Oct 22  2014	rsvpdir
>> Oct 22  2014	rtgdir
>> Oct 22  2014	sdpdir
>> Oct 22  2014	secdir
>> Oct 22  2014	smartpower
>> Jun 27  2019	tdd
>> Oct 22  2014	tsvdir
>> Oct 22  2014	yangdoctors
>> 
>> 
>> 2.  List of unused Trac instances.  159 in total
>> 
>> 16ng
>> 6renum
>> acme
>> ancp
>> apparea
>> aqm
>> arcmedia
>> armd
>> artarea
>> artart
>> atoca
>> autoconf
>> avtext
>> babel
>> banana
>> bcause
>> bfcpbis
>> bimi
>> bmwg
>> cacao
>> calext
>> capport
>> capwap
>> cbor
>> cdni
>> cellar
>> cfrg
>> coinrg
>> coms
>> cose
>> csi
>> curdle
>> cuss
>> dart
>> dcrouting
>> dcrup
>> detnet
>> doh
>> drip
>> driu
>> emodir
>> enum
>> eppext
>> extra
>> fecframe
>> genarea
>> gendispatch
>> geojson
>> ghost
>> git
>> grow
>> hackathon
>> hotrfc
>> hrpc
>> i18ndir
>> i18nrp
>> ianaplan
>> iasa2
>> iasa20
>> iccrg
>> ice
>> icnrg
>> ideas
>> ietf
>> ila
>> imapapnd
>> insipid
>> ipfix
>> ipwave
>> irtfopen
>> isis
>> jmap
>> jsonbis
>> justfont
>> karp
>> keyprov
>> kitten
>> ksk
>> l2sm
>> l2tpext
>> l2vpn
>> lamps
>> ledbat
>> lmap
>> lsr
>> lsvr
>> maprg
>> marf
>> masque
>> mboned
>> mip6
>> mipshop
>> mls
>> modern
>> monami6
>> morg
>> netrqmts
>> netslicing
>> netvc
>> nfsv4
>> nfvrg
>> nwcrg
>> openpgp
>> opsarea
>> opsawg
>> opsec
>> p2psip
>> pals
>> panrg
>> paw
>> paws
>> pcn
>> pearg
>> perc
>> privacypass
>> qirg
>> qresync
>> quic
>> raiarea
>> rats
>> rfcplusplus
>> ript
>> rsoc
>> rtgarea
>> rtgyangcoord
>> rum
>> saag
>> sasl
>> savi
>> sdnrg
>> secevent
>> sidrops
>> sip
>> sipbrandy
>> splices
>> storm
>> straw
>> supa
>> t2trg
>> taps
>> tcpinc
>> teep
>> tmrid
>> tokbind
>> tools-arch
>> trill
>> tsvarea
>> tsvart
>> txauth
>> v6ops
>> vcarddav
>> vipr
>> vnrg
>> webpush
>> webtrans
>> wgtlgo
>> wpack
>> wugh
>> xrblock
>> 
>> -- 
>> Jay Daley
>> IETF Executive Director
>> [e-mail]
>> 
> 
> 

-- 
Jay Daley
IETF Executive Director
[e-mail]