[tram] A note from your (so far) friendly AD ...

[Spencer Dawkins <[e-mail]>]

Dear TRAMsters,

If I might offer a couple of suggestions to a new working group ...

The TSV area diverts QoS discussions to the TSVWG working group, because 
that's where the QoS DSCP expertise lives.

RTCWeb and TSVWG are having a robust and so-far productive discussion 
about QoS for RTCWeb now (by "robust", I mean "involving chairs and ADs 
for both working groups"). That discussion is more likely to be 
productive if RTCWeb QoS topics don't start popping up on other working 
group mailing lists, like this one.

I'll let your working group chairs actually run the working group, but I 
note as more than an interested observer that the TRAM agenda at 
https://datatracker.ietf.org/meeting/89/agenda/tram/ is really tight, 
and I would really be happier if the working group focuses on the 
currently chartered milestones and demonstrates that you can deliver 
what you're already signed up to deliver, before adding more milestones. 
The rest of the IESG would be happier as well.

Thanks, and see you in London.

Spencer, as your responsible AD

On 02/18/2014 03:33 PM, Simon Perreault wrote:
> Le 2014-02-18 16:12, Oleg Moskalenko a écrit :
>> How to handle the DS and ECN fields is a part of TURN server RFC (see
>> the section 12):
>>
>> http://tools.ietf.org/search/rfc5766#section-12
>>
>> And a good TURN server is supposed to implement that.
> Well, the RFC just says that the TURN server should copy the DSCP from
> one side to the other when doing en/de-capsulation. It doesn't say that
> the server should actually do QoS based on the DSCP. My point is that
> there's nothing preventing the server from actually doing it.
>
> Anyway, I was expecting responses along the lines of "DiffServ doesn't
> work on the Internet in general." To which I would have replied: "then
> couldn't we define a STUN attribute for transporting the DSCP in the
> payload?" Instead of inventing a new taxonomy (audio, video, slides,
> etc.), why not reuse DSCP?
>
> Simon