Re: [Txauth] WG Name Voting!!!

[Dick Hardt <[e-mail]>]

In the poll, somehow I entered ZAuthZ instead of XAuthZ -- A dot for ZAuthZ
is really a dot for XAuthZ

Apologies. Editing the poll creates a new link which seems even more
confusing.



On Tue, May 12, 2020 at 1:44 PM Dick Hardt <[e-mail]> wrote:

> Well, so much for all the effort I did in sorting. The voting service
> randomizes the entries on each load ...
>
> Here is what is in the spreadsheet for your convenience ...
>
> abbrev pronunciation syllables WG Name
> PAuthZ paws 1 Protocol for Authorization
> AZARP a-zarp 2 AuthoriZed Access to Resources Protocol
> CTAP cee-tap 2 Comprehensive Token Access Protocol
> GNAP guh-nap 2 Grant Negotiation and Authorization Protocol
> GranPro gran-pro 2 GRAnt Negotiation Protocol
> NIRAD nir-ad 2 Negotiation of Intent Registration and Authority Delegation
> TIDEAuth tide-auth 2 Transference via Intent Driven Extension Auth
> TIDEAuth tide-auth 2 Trust via Intent Driven Extension Auth
> TIDYAuth tidy-auth 2 Transference via Intent Driven Yield Auth
> TIDYAuth tidy-auth 2 Trust via Intent Driven Yield Auth
> TIEAuth tie-auth 2 Transference via Intent Extension Auth
> TIEAuth tie-auth 2 Trust via Intent Extension Auth
> AAuthZ a-auth-zee 3 Alternative Authorization Protocol (AAuthZ)
> AZARAP az-a-rap 3 AuthoriZation And Resource Access Protocol
> CompAuthZ comp-auth-zee 3 Componentized Authorization Protocol
> DAZARAP daz-a-rap 3 Delegated AuthoriZation And Resource Access Protocol
> DisAuthZ dis-auth-zee 3 Dismembered Authorization Protocol
> ReAuthZ re-auth-z 3 Reimagined Authorization Protocol
> RefAuthZ ref-auth-z 3 Refactored Authorization Protocol
> TIARP t-i-arp 3 Tokenized Identity and Access Resource Protocol
> TINOA tin-o-a 3 This Is Not OAuth
> TXAuth t-x-auth 3 Testable eXtensible Authorization
> TxAuth t-x-auth 3 Transmission of Authority
> TXAuth t-x-auth 3 Truly eXtensible Authorization
> ZAuthZ x-auth-z 3 eXtensible authoriZation protocol
> BeBAuthZ be-be-auth-zee 4 Back-end Based Authorization Protocol
> CIOAuth cee-eye-o-auth 4 Client Intent Origin Auth
> BYOAuthZ be-y-o-auth-zee 5 Build-Your-Own Authorization Protocol
> CPAAP cee-pee-a-a-pee 5 Comprehensive Privileged Authentication
> Authorization Protocol
> DIYAuthZ dee-i-y-auth-zee 5 Do-It-Yourself Authorization Protocol
> IDPAuthZ i-dee-pee-auth-z 5 Intent Driven Protocol for Authorization
> TIAAP t-i-a-a-p 5 Tokenized Identity and Access Protocol
>
>
>
> On Tue, May 12, 2020 at 1:37 PM Dick Hardt <[e-mail]> wrote:
>
>> Hello Everyone
>>
>> We are now ready to do some dot voting
>> <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dot-voting>
>>
>> We have 32 suggestions in the list Nigel managed
>> <https://nigelhamilton.com/pages/txauth-name-game.html> that did not
>> conflict with something else and were googlable.
>> (if your name did not make the list, neither did my XAuth suggestion!)
>>
>> If you feel strongly a name not in the list to be voted on should be
>> there, email me privately.
>>
>> I sorted the list based on shortishness (see below)
>>
>> Reminder, the expansion is the name of the working group, that will be at
>> top of this page https://datatracker.ietf.org/wg/txauth/about/
>>
>> *Please goto this page to dot vote:*
>>
>> https://mindiply.com/products/decido/decisions/znxVEip81xOUjA
>>
>> *Please don't vote more than once!*
>>
>> If there is overwhelming support for one name, then we are done. If not,
>> then I'll cull the list and we will vote again.
>>
>> /Dick
>>
>> *Sorting Order*
>> I made my best guess on how I would pronounce the acronym/backronym, and
>> counted the syllables, as shortish was one of the selection criteria.
>>
>> The names are sorted by # syllables, alphabetical order of abbreviation,
>> then alphabetical order of WG name. The spreadsheet I used is here:
>>
>>
>> https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1N2vZY8xNjyAtvcY1PgVjY6ugxeUVSGoR98r2Nqu968c/edit?usp=sharing
>>
>