Re: [Uri-review] The registration request for “cstr” URI scheme

Dear Wangshu,

I've been following your discussion of this proposal.  Thank you for responding 
constructively to the various comments and issues that Ted Hardie has raised.

The next step for registration of a provisional scheme is very easy (you've done 
the hard part!).  Simply send a request for provisional registration with copy 
of your registration template to iana@iana.org [1].  The process for provisional 
registrations is very straightforward, and should complete quite quickly.

[1] https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc7595.html#section-7.2

Graham Klyne
(IANA Designated Reviewer, URI schemes)

On 11/05/2022 09:41, wangshu@cnic.cn wrote:
> Dear Ted Hardie,
> 
> Thank you for all your help, please let me know if you need any more information 
> about CSTR.
> 
> I want to know how long it will take to complete the registration and what else 
> we need to do:)
> 
> Looking forward to your reply.
> 
> Best wishes.
> 
> Shu
> 
> 
> --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
> wangshu@cnic.cn
> 
>     *发件人：* Ted Hardie <mailto:ted.ietf@gmail.com>
>     *发送时间：* 2022-05-10 16:56
>     *收件人：* wangshu@cnic.cn <mailto:wangshu@cnic.cn>
>     *抄送：* uri-review <mailto:uri-review@ietf.org>; liujia <mailto:liujia@cnic.cn>
>     *主题：* Re: Re: [Uri-review] The registration request for “cstr” URI scheme
>     Dear Wangshu,
> 
>     Thank you for this additional detail in the specification.  I believe this
>     registration is ready to proceed.
> 
>     best regards,
> 
>     Ted Hardie
> 
>     On Tue, May 10, 2022 at 9:13 AM wangshu@cnic.cn <mailto:wangshu@cnic.cn>
>     <wangshu@cnic.cn <mailto:wangshu@cnic.cn>> wrote:
> 
>         Dear Ted Hardie,
> 
>         Thank you for your comments. The internal identifier is defined by the
>         user, including digit, alphabet and ASCII character "-"(octet 0x2D),
>         "."(octet 0x2E), "_" (octet 0x5F), "~"(octet 0x7E). We have already
>         updated the CSTR specification. _https://cstr.cn/doc/specification/_
>         <https://cstr.cn/doc/specification/>
> 
> 
>         Please let me know if you have any questionsabout cstr.
> 
>         Looking forward to your reply.____
> 
>         Best wishes.____
> 
>         Shu
> 
>         --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
>         wangshu@cnic.cn <mailto:wangshu@cnic.cn>
> 
>             *发件人：* Ted Hardie <mailto:ted.ietf@gmail.com>
>             *发送时间：* 2022-05-08 17:46
>             *收件人：* wangshu@cnic.cn <mailto:wangshu@cnic.cn>
>             *抄送：* uri-review <mailto:uri-review@ietf.org>; liujia
>             <mailto:liujia@cnic.cn>
>             *主题：* Re: Re: [Uri-review] The registration request for “cstr”
>             URI scheme
>             Dear Wang Shu,
> 
>             Thank you for the updates to the registration.  The only remaining
>             issue is clarifying the set of characters which may be used in
>             constructing an internal identifier.  One way to do that would be to
>             specify that they are constructed from the RFC 3986 unreserved set:
> 
>               unreserved  = ALPHA / DIGIT / "-" / "." / "_" / "~"
> 
> 
>             If that is the case.  If it is not, or there are restrictions you
>             wish to note, that would be appropriate to specify here.
> 
>             Best regards,
> 
>             Ted Hardie
> 
>             On Sat, May 7, 2022 at 9:05 AM wangshu@cnic.cn
>             <mailto:wangshu@cnic.cn> <wangshu@cnic.cn <mailto:wangshu@cnic.cn>>
>             wrote:
> 
>                 Dear Ted Hardieand others,
> 
>                 Thank you for all your comments, the application of cstr is in
>                 the initial stage, so we are not sure all the security
>                 considerations at the time of registration.
> 
>                 We have already updated the CSTR specification. CSTR and the
>                 registration agency code are separated by the ASCII character
>                 ":" (octet 0x3A), and the rest of the parts are separated by the
>                 ASCII character "." (octet 0x2E). ____
> 
>                 The "cstr" scheme is specified as follows:____
> 
>                 __ __
> 
>                 __ __
> 
>                 Scheme name: cstr____
> 
>                 __ __
> 
>                 Status: Provisional____
> 
>                 __ __
> 
>                 Applications/protocols that use this scheme name:____
> 
>                 A "cstr" URI is used to express an identifier that isfor common
>                 science and technology resources.____
> 
>                 Applications that use this scheme nameprovide services for the
>                 persistent identification, inluding citation, statistics and
>                 traceability of scienceand technology resources.____
> 
>                 __ __
> 
>                 Security considerations:____
> 
>                 The general security considerations from Section 7 of RFC 3986
>                 apply, but no other security considerations have been identified
>                 at the
>                 time of registration.____
> 
>                 __ __
> 
>                 Contact: Wang Shu(wangshu@cnic.cn <mailto:wangshu@cnic.cn>)____
> 
>                 __ __
> 
>                 Change controllers:____
> 
>                 - Wang Shu(wangshu@cnic.cn <mailto:wangshu@cnic.cn>)____
> 
>                 - Computer Network Information Center,Chinese Academy of
>                 Sciences____
> 
>                 __ __
> 
>                 References:____
> 
>                 [1] _https://www.cstr.cn/en/_ <https://www.cstr.cn/en/>____
> 
>                 [2] _https://cstr.cn/doc/specification/_
>                 <https://cstr.cn/doc/specification/>____
> 
>                 __ __
> 
>                 Please let me know if you have any questionsabout cstr.
> 
>                 Looking forward to your reply.____
> 
>                 Best wishes.____
> 
>                 Shu____
> 
> 
>                 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
>                 wangshu@cnic.cn <mailto:wangshu@cnic.cn>
> 
> 
> _______________________________________________
> Uri-review mailing list
> Uri-review@ietf.org
> https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/uri-review

-- 
Graham Klyne
mailto:gk@ninebynine.org
http://www.ninebynine.org
Skype/Twitter: @gklyne