Re: request for registration of the "scte" URN namespace

[Darshak Thakore <[e-mail]>]

Hi Ted,

Thanks a lot for the quick turn around on the feedback. Comments inline

On 4/12/16, 12:41 PM, "Ted Hardie" <[e-mail]<mailto:[e-mail]>> wrote:

Hi Darshak,

Thanks for the submission; the IETF week has just ended, so it's possible that folks will bring this back to the fore.

I note that the document has a "TBD" for the mailing address of the designated contact.  That will need an update.  Second, you use the syntax:


urn:scte:{SCTEresource}:{ResourceSpecificString}


to describe the structure.  You don't appear to include ABNF for each of the substructures, though; did you intend to describe them?

DT>> I’ll update the designated contact address shortly. The ABNF for {SCTEresource}:{ResourceSpecificString} will be in the SCTE specs. Do I need to provide it here or is it ok if I simply state that the specific tokens will be defined in relevant SCTE specs ?



You also cite the "SANN" as the intended numbering authority, but the citation is simply a repetition of the acronym expansion.  What's the actual status of this body?

DT>> I’m in the process of procuring the URL to the document and update it shortly.

Regards,
Darshak



regards,

Ted HArdie

On Tue, Apr 5, 2016 at 11:34 AM, Darshak Thakore <[e-mail]<mailto:[e-mail]>> wrote:
Hi all,

The Society of Cable Telecommunications Enginners (SCTE) would like to register the “scte” URN namespace in the IANA registry located here:

http://www.iana.org/assignments/urn-namespaces/urn-namespaces.xhtml

Pursuant to the instructions provided in RFC 3406, Section 4.3, I am sending the request to the above address. An I-D using the template in Appendix A of RFC 3406 has been submitted to the IETF. The I-D requesting the URN registration and providing the relevant information is available here:

https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-dthakore-scte-urn-00

We would like the group to review the draft and provide any necessary comments/feedback.

Regards,
Darshak Thakore
Lead Software Architect
CableLabs