Re: [Ice] active / frozen check lists

[Christer Holmberg <[e-mail]>]

Hi,

>>> Apparently it was decided at IETF 99 to remove the terms "active 
>>> check list" and "frozen check list" from the core spec. These terms 
>>> are used in the trickle spec. For example:
 
###
 
>>> A Trickle ICE agent initially considers all check lists to be frozen. 
>>> It then inspects the first check list and attempts to unfreeze all 
>>> candidate pairs it has received so far that belong to  the first 
>>> component on the first media stream (i.e., the first media stream 
>>> that was reported to the ICE implementation from the using 
>>> application). If that first component of the first media stream does 
>>> not contain candidates for one or more of the currently known pair 
>>> foundations, and if candidate pairs already exist for that foundation 
>>> in one of the following components or media streams, then the agent 
>>> unfreezes the first of those candidate pairs.
>> 
>> How would this change if we removed "frozen check list"?
>
> We'd probably need to create a circumlocation such as "considers all candidate pairs in all check lists to be frozen".

5245bis already says that all pairs are initially set to frozen. I don't think you need to re-define it in trickle.

(We'll deal with the rest, if needed, once you've had time to look at it)

Regards,

Christer