[OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signed JWT Credentials to Resource Servers with DPoP
Ashwin Ambekar <ambekar@gmail.com> Wed, 30 September 2026 16:33 UTC
Received: from mail-ej2-x0f.google.com (mail-ej2-x0f.google.com [IPv6:2a00:1450:4864:34::f]) (using TLSv1.3 with cipher TLS_AES_256_GCM_SHA384 (256/256 bits) key-exchange x25519 server-signature ECDSA (prime256v1) server-digest SHA256) (No client certificate requested) by mx.ietf.org (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 8940C50 for <oauth@ietf.org>; Wed, 30 Sep 2026 16:33:38 +0000 (UTC)
Authentication-Results: mx.ietf.org; dkim=pass header.d=gmail.com header.s=20251104 header.b=G72xwAbo; dmarc=pass (policy=none) header.from=gmail.com; arc=pass ("google.com:s=arc-20260327:i=1"); spf=pass (mx.ietf.org: domain of ambekar@gmail.com designates 2a00:1450:4864:34::f as permitted sender) smtp.mailfrom=ambekar@gmail.com
Received: by mail-ej2-x0f.google.com with SMTP id a640c23a62f3a-c2e23be09baso98720566b.1 for <oauth@ietf.org>; Wed, 30 Sep 2026 09:33:38 -0700 (PDT)
ARC-Seal: i=1; a=rsa-sha256; t=1790786017; cv=none; d=google.com; s=arc-20260327; b=OoFRhn14J38BhoyZjXyXup+7yUxDdet29izV4H81IG9q8pK9N0Q5Sbb/3VBYw3NVyz dUqyyVYkRAwsE8MQiTXmCBlMndtCN8rQcYTMnVGmT+g4Dfh0qMH7wENh+gV+csRmmkAx gRlRpO6qZL+aCTXM754QtZQTqycKiKOvHoPSYJrjzzS/edrQyeT3qa1qx5F4fDWn2naE L6IAP5QwmRiE8SVeUlKDTsdoSz69/n6PFrFiJHQYGEn5Bt/w+AY0Z4Ak6GVVfHQPhZQr Y1Bw1jX6kL1zyiw2RLqGrJ7UAeCJbv+utIak9Yt6kW72ax9BgNhw7927ktuaqGe6lgYT aneA==
ARC-Message-Signature: i=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=google.com; s=arc-20260327; h=cc:to:subject:message-id:date:from:in-reply-to:references :mime-version:dkim-signature; bh=RJils7Yu67l5N0obeE6lhbCtwBmXFRb/mS3yMW1khes=; fh=USTaSqzMNAubURggB+/CtD0kJbPSLlIxFb/m5klvZzA=; b=BSbVICdngSQ1YYp8iqIPR7rGIrGtWW7LbZS1ECYdXVSm4q60rdmmR+9ts3OvmhFbGr SZsgjmlmF3wsedICL7SbOBz2QVB/dqaBSclt8qn8z6zUY9yt9Ljx7lxJho/RMcDPTLLo BoFp1qlZQ6YR6+DpPxfXLvUQ70zaygWQFd87yPObsDOmaXKJyMV6ZNEpNWENc03QHd0j 2hulcvn+dR3qgurw1DY+gv8qcyNknRlG3Ua9HXLaUcV3gqJLLaTGHBJXTiD4WS/elOpt SxYXllBEpVsyhLPBKOzYkpgHt4Wt8KuS4XENNMKVs5aw2Y0XKxl9IU1ISKy+C3ZgF7rF 8ZBw==; darn=ietf.org
ARC-Authentication-Results: i=1; mx.google.com; arc=none
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=gmail.com; s=20251104; t=1790786017; x=1791390817; darn=ietf.org; h=content-type:cc:to:subject:message-id:date:from:in-reply-to :references:mime-version:from:to:cc:subject:date:message-id:reply-to :content-type; bh=RJils7Yu67l5N0obeE6lhbCtwBmXFRb/mS3yMW1khes=; b=G72xwAbo2AwnOzELw9jnsWbsopdAg0UDgXnys8Z7blHQZLTrth+PVfthiCwcYpkWKx IrZTE3Cgd9m+gOIC17j7Jo8v2Y3UkI85xIFlUkrHA9l60HlNaxZP4fg9EAJYBRLH84Ik mFGL8BWUXjB14MUG6N4yB1PSDh7rmOAzle4WTWch9VqUf54LU82WUG28ZIUTzU8lIGIl Atvrbns+Si/ZrqJzCKINP3sjesq8upmTWsHeOvnCKtANFloaYAiORuAskWPtDYl1gxLi moyafUofpYV0lCF5XBeC+mwyKFea9zn6TtVcE6bxG3DP+x1mbi2sXZmshookBNJDJehU 36Yg==
X-Google-DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=1e100.net; s=20260707; t=1790786017; x=1791390817; h=content-type:cc:to:subject:message-id:date:from:in-reply-to :references:mime-version:x-gm-gg:x-gm-message-state:from:to:cc :subject:date:message-id:reply-to:content-type; bh=RJils7Yu67l5N0obeE6lhbCtwBmXFRb/mS3yMW1khes=; b=21EvOiMMMJ3R81dk00VW1BpZayy7aXPl7BKe9PRi6VbG+ZfKx9X2cPQSaSo35nkagz SNYoprsRs3iN8Wx/d8F9mDX6truN3tSfhY71EW1MVMDKpqatkc2jgia3/8bLkkBaXrDQ KpoYn3TJF6dbYhETONpPwohQnUVfcL0DTKYs3uQDXdhAKT8L+IqGXUBynYJl1k5NBMHO pF5CYVx6R2jhKYk8N3321gsI8JVBzd6CwllJ1l7Wwm9Ww+LBJEHu4auCn0tJtMOScL3m t1p6e0sPjk50nnNa1W0pSl4S6bKX2ZJs1E50Z/zS14e5rtpJ93WHEgbnhezSaczErTxI yeSQ==
X-Forwarded-Encrypted: i=1; AKwUvByndVbyt8RBQTYIJ+4QlS/6TJI1rdluOOQwld+F7jIsX1WMZuDJIxQ2JdYx7Ii78bnuQYuwaA==@ietf.org
X-Gm-Message-State: AFuF++kyOoQA1+zbfM3UAWIPZ+V7+HUOLQJzE5Kn0YVCgZO/CKx64X1a mU4mfJmmAaw7PvAC9JJ/T/aD9ETRuiZYUBpk7qSxCgL/lK64wHJaQeWqfIwtQkIVDDWMrPUo7cY BNzkWEMx+p0pCQ3fPS+Ml4KiW0Vmy6wI=
X-Gm-Gg: AYBFou2+idnbkGM94j0x3qvAM7fAZdrhby0VQbb301yN0qquBf9XB9YuwyfuG30azfR MUs1o5UYFlt+FmnpxkNLXbNUWz0SgobqTw69oLoTrBH+4xCEuWgpdkQ0aWQoKEsS8iExh1Xo1Jf n6AtQvuze7vWWpFs87nryNOfEKroAWC5VbEu9FXYRFx2nxnfz3YGB8gfgZav5MBLY7oY4FShvgN oXKOOIBLlgHH6jctQuulDDSDOtFIXTrWWB15NNOuI6GwHoFyoAPb3Lav+IROD6RgPFnyHu1mIPB mal7Gjg0ShlmIzOZ+qLd/tLvjNgRMc9Ua8rzjG8CFNhFcOMcL8rmMClD
X-Received: by 2002:a17:907:3ea8:b0:c29:286e:2e3e with SMTP id a640c23a62f3a-c2e23da1451mr154801666b.38.1790786016724; Wed, 30 Sep 2026 09:33:36 -0700 (PDT)
MIME-Version: 1.0
References: <53ece5a3f251e1567c11ca1c286199@cweb002.nm> <CAJot-L3-eEwxLmqnTih9Vg2gi3HkScnzJS5BOnunbHV1bF3=Cw@mail.gmail.com> <9e55639d793453ab210336617e5d976@cweb001.nm> <CAJot-L3N9urv3jo1-SQA_ceURg=XLFVGqKaaYSKeTz1P+A=3Fg@mail.gmail.com> <ad2820d8df8695b62c12a168f53314d@cweb005.nm> <MMZPR04MB481271B16F172C25F4B1A2EDD8938C2@MMZPR04MB481271.eurprd04.prod.outlook.com> <68f91419062c2f3bf752a1ce2a85c1@cweb007.nm> <CAJot-L0GNMJ-txT9m+w-+-ntphSO6nLyHi4mv9ZnyVEcCf8LNg@mail.gmail.com> <dbfc3ab9595679387de2a8c089795ee7@cweb010.nm> <CAJot-L2wrNYPTR4mxeSvsAS3-z_Kwu8hYbQgH6T6nYzh+fu1eQ@mail.gmail.com> <189c87d4aa2fc97e63fb25e236816ec@cweb001.nm> <CAJot-L0gGYnFryN4UuOkuyZn41jftR_LbYc2fs8nY9Yj0a0p=Q@mail.gmail.com> <f0552aa8c3567869efb77e41583a793@cweb014.nm> <CAJot-L2Y=YmKwsX_pCJVS24tx-ntYG2wLavL6vSqKBgwmiM6+A@mail.gmail.com> <2df8e97914895bb94b9012ba65def6a@cweb002.nm>
In-Reply-To: <2df8e97914895bb94b9012ba65def6a@cweb002.nm>
From: Ashwin Ambekar <ambekar@gmail.com>
Date: Wed, 30 Sep 2026 09:33:23 -0700
X-Gm-Features: AclHuK9xVZ7FbXtqRNSXUAMjVWPyCm3rup-strGhe82C39Bartp_f4vNiTGGlHU
Message-ID: <CAHcgzDK8-JvZF1AfsVMQUY70PMvxE5no_DAJgUeMwQ69ZrYc5w@mail.gmail.com>
To: Su-hyeon Forten Lee <nine01223@naver.com>
Content-Type: multipart/alternative; boundary="000000000000654bb9065cb5dc6e"
X-Spamd-Bar: -
Message-ID-Hash: B3TTHI77GCI32CFXEZKCO7ZOYYIEGASO
X-Message-ID-Hash: B3TTHI77GCI32CFXEZKCO7ZOYYIEGASO
X-MailFrom: ambekar@gmail.com
X-Mailman-Rule-Misses: dmarc-mitigation; no-senders; approved; loop; banned-address; header-match-oauth.ietf.org-0; emergency; member-moderation; nonmember-moderation; administrivia; implicit-dest; max-recipients; max-size; news-moderation; no-subject; digests; suspicious-header
CC: Yaron ZEHAVI <yaron.zehavi@rbinternational.com>, oauth <oauth@ietf.org>
X-Mailman-Version: 3.3.10
Precedence: list
Subject: [OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signed JWT Credentials to Resource Servers with DPoP
List-Id: OAUTH WG <oauth.ietf.org>
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/oauth/D4AwX2hYyNd0U_y7_2Ttf8A-oK8>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/oauth>
List-Help: <mailto:oauth-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Owner: <mailto:oauth-owner@ietf.org>
List-Post: <mailto:oauth@ietf.org>
List-Subscribe: <mailto:oauth-join@ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <mailto:oauth-leave@ietf.org>
Hi Su-hyeon, Have you looked at EPOP draft? Please let me know if this is closer to what you are looking for : https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ambekar-oauth-epop/ Regards, Ashwin On Wed, Sep 30, 2026 at 8:04 AM Su-hyeon Forten Lee <nine01223@naver.com> wrote: > Warren, > > Thank you for laying this out in detail. > > Yes, the idea was to use the credential like an access token to make > authenticated calls to the RS, and as you point out, it was really closer > to a way for a client acting on behalf of a user to authenticate itself. > > To be honest, my long-term hope is to have something that is an access > token and a credential at the same time, in a structure where the AS is > also the issuer and the RS is also the verifier. For convenience, please > allow me to use a JOSE-secured W3C VC as the example. The first thing that > collides is typ. RFC 9068 requires the RS to check for at+jwt, while > VC-JOSE-COSE only recommends (SHOULD) vc+jwt and allows cty: vc to identify > the content. So with a VC carrying typ: at+jwt and cty: vc, I wonder > whether an entity that is both RS and verifier could accept it as an > ordinary at+jwt, while on the VC side it could be accepted through > negotiation, for example by defining it as a credential format in > OpenID4VP. That said, this discussion has shown me that this path is much > harder than I thought. > > I agree that credentials fit better for authenticating to the AS as the > holder than for use at the RS. The case I had in mind is one where both the > holder and the AS are under my control, so your approach of treating the AS > as the verifier and having it complete the flow started by the RS applies > directly. I also understand that this is already supported from an OAuth > standpoint, and thank you for saying it is a part you could get behind. > > I will rethink the draft with this perspective in mind. Thank you again > for taking the time, several times over. > > Best regards, > Su-hyeon > > -----Original Message----- > *From:* "Warren Parad"<wparad=40rhosys.ch@dmarc.ietf.org> > *To:* "Su-hyeon Forten Lee"<nine01223@naver.com>; > *Cc:* "Yaron ZEHAVI"<yaron.zehavi=40rbinternational.com@dmarc.ietf.org>; > "oauth"<oauth@ietf.org>; > *Sent:* 2026-09-30 (수) 01:14:37 (GMT+09:00) > *Subject:* [OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signed JWT > Credentials to Resource Servers with DPoP > > Why are trying to send unsolicited credentials to an API / RS. > > Is that the part where you are trying to use the credentials as an access > token? > > How would you even know which credentials should be sent? Is the idea that > a verifier wouldn't care, they just want any mechanism for a client > operating on behalf of a user to authenticate themselves? > > So said differently... There is an RS that accepts credentials and DPoP, > and "you" want to make authenticated calls to that RS with the credentials > without exchanging the exchanges for an access token. > > At first glance, it feels like the credentials are the wrong form for > this. But, credentials are great for autheticating to the AS as the holder. > The AS requests user identity verification as part of generating the OAuth > access token. > > What systems do you control here? Clearly the holder, if it also includes > the AS then the implementation I would use is to treat the AS as the > verifier and have it complete the OAuth exchange flow still started by the > RS. > > And since the AS user verification is out of scope, this is definitely > something already supported from an OAuth standpoint. But I think at least > personally, that is the one part of this I could definitely get behind. > > On Tue, Sep 29, 2026, 17:39 Su-hyeon Forten Lee <nine01223@naver.com> > wrote: > > Hi Warren, > > Thank you for raising that. I agree it is the key question. Using the > KB-JWT is certainly a valid option. However, RFC 9901 leaves both how the > KB-JWT nonce is obtained and how the aud value is represented to the > protocol in use, and as far as I know nothing defines them for an > unsolicited HTTP call where the verifier has not sent a request first. So > even with the KB-JWT, one would still need to define how the resource > server delivers a nonce and what goes into aud. DPoP, on the other hand, > already has a way to deliver a nonce through DPoP-Nonce, and binds the > proof to the request through htu and htm. > > In addition, for a client that already uses DPoP for its access tokens, > using the same mechanism for credentials means both the resource server and > the client deal with a single binding mechanism. > > This is why I believe that reusing DPoP could bring the two worlds, > credentials and access tokens, together at the verification level as well. > > Thank you again. > > Best regards, > Su-hyeon > > -----Original Message----- > *From:* "Warren Parad"<wparad@rhosys.ch> > *To:* "Su-hyeon Forten Lee"<nine01223@naver.com>; > *Cc:* "Yaron ZEHAVI"<yaron.zehavi=40rbinternational.com@dmarc.ietf.org>; > "oauth"<oauth@ietf.org>; > *Sent:* 2026-09-30 (수) 00:19:15 (GMT+09:00) > *Subject:* Re: [OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signed JWT > Credentials to Resource Servers with DPoP > > Agreed on all accounts. Which means we should ask why. As in if you intend > to use key bindings why not just use the SD-JWT defined mechanism? > > On Tue, Sep 29, 2026, 17:10 Su-hyeon Forten Lee <nine01223@naver.com> > wrote: > > Hi Warren, > > Thank you for narrowing it down that way, it is very helpful. As you say, > the AS side is not the issue. An AS can mint an SD-JWT VC today, and > generation and verification of both the SD-JWT and the DPoP proof are > already specified. Creating a DPoP proof for an SD-JWT on the client side > is not difficult either. The gap is at the next step, on the verifier side. > > First, the format. An SD-JWT presentation always ends with a "~", even > without any disclosures, so it is not a plain JWT. It fits the HTTP header > syntax, but an existing DPoP resource server that parses the token as a JWT > will not accept it as is. In this respect, a JOSE-secured W3C VC, being a > plain JWT, is cleaner. Introspection would avoid the format issue, but then > the resource server would contact the issuer on every presentation, which > is the kind of structure credentials are meant to avoid. > > Second, key binding. In RFC 9901, whether to require Key Binding is up to > the verifier's policy, and the only mechanism it defines is the KB-JWT. So > a resource server can choose not to require SD-JWT Key Binding and check > DPoP instead, but nothing currently says that the DPoP proof provides > equivalent binding. Interestingly, an ath computed over the presented > SD-JWT covers exactly the same bytes as sd_hash, so I believe it already > provides nearly the same guarantee in practice. > > In short, the first is closer to an implementation matter, while the > second is what is actually missing at the specification level. It is not a > missing property in the SD-JWT spec, but the lack of a rule stating that, > for an SD-JWT presented to a resource server, the DPoP proof can serve as > the key binding. > > This is also why I have been considering setting selective disclosure > aside and starting from a plain JWT format such as a JOSE-secured W3C VC, > although I realize that in that case there would be very little left for a > specification to define. > > Thank you again. > > Best regards, > Su-hyeon > > -----Original Message----- > *From:* "Warren Parad"<wparad@rhosys.ch> > *To:* "Su-hyeon Forten Lee"<nine01223@naver.com>; > *Cc:* "Yaron ZEHAVI"<yaron.zehavi=40rbinternational.com@dmarc.ietf.org>; < > oauth@ietf.org>; > *Sent:* 2026-09-29 (화) 23:26:04 (GMT+09:00) > *Subject:* Re: [OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signed JWT > Credentials to Resource Servers with DPoP > > no problem, but I like this path you've now laid out. If you are > interested in AS minting and distributing a VC, what stops your AS from > doing that today via the SD-JWT? Do you control the AS? If so, you can make > that change, but which step of the process would be a problem specifically? > Is it attempting to add a DPoP signature on top of a sent SD-JWT? from the > client, is that the problem. That's the only step which seems like it could > be a problem, because of course the generation and verification of the > SD-JWT exists, as well as the RFC for generation and verification of DPoP, > so the problem you must be alluding to is a challenge creating an DPoP > signature for the SD-JWT, which step is explicitly the issue, is it a > missing property in the SD-JWT spec? > > On Tue, Sep 29, 2026 at 4:20 PM Su-hyeon Forten Lee <nine01223@naver.com> > wrote: > > Hi Warren, > > Thank you for the question, and for taking the time to lay out the > possibilities so clearly. The first one you describe, using OAuth to > generate an access token that works as a credential, captures what I meant > very precisely. > > I think this WG's SD-JWT VC is the most suitable format, but to be candid, > one of the things I ultimately have in mind is a JOSE-secured W3C VC. From > an engineering point of view, I am looking for a single artifact that works > unchanged in both worlds: issued by an AS, accepted as a token by a DPoP > resource server, and accepted as a credential by a VC verifier outside > OAuth. Along the same lines, I am exploring whether the DPoP proof can take > the place of the verifiable presentation that the VC side normally uses for > holder binding. Verification with the AS's JWKs and the DPoP proof are the > means to that end, and my interest is mainly in reusing what OAuth already > provides. > > There are several challenges and pieces of work involved, but a > representative one is defining a set of fields that work the same way for > both a credential and an access token, such as iss, sub, exp and cnf, along > with typ to tell the two kinds of token apart and status information. As > you know, the biggest hurdle was aud, and thanks to the comments in this > thread I feel I am finding a way through it. > > Whether this turns out to be work for the OAuth WG or for somewhere else, > I have already gained a great deal of insight from this discussion. Thank > you again. > > Best regards, > Su-hyeon > > -----Original Message----- > *From:* "Warren Parad"<wparad@rhosys.ch> > *To:* "Su-hyeon Forten Lee"<nine01223@naver.com>; > *Cc:* "Yaron ZEHAVI"<yaron.zehavi=40rbinternational.com@dmarc.ietf.org>; < > oauth@ietf.org>; > *Sent:* 2026-09-29 (화) 22:48:29 (GMT+09:00) > *Subject:* Re: [OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signed JWT > Credentials to Resource Servers with DPoP > > What do you mean by "flow over existing OAuth infrastructure" exactly? > When you say that, it sounds more like you are interested in the generation > and distribution of credentials by an AS. Using OAuth to generate an access > token that works as credentials. > > Or are you talking about how to verify the credentials using a JWK > supplied by an AS? Or maybe you are just interested in being able to > generate DPoP header values for your credentials. DPoP is limited to OAuth, > but nothing would stop you from creating an OpenID4VP version (if that was > your preference), but that would be likely out of scope for the OAuth > working group. > > On Tue, Sep 29, 2026 at 2:29 PM Su-hyeon Forten Lee <nine01223@naver.com> > wrote: > > Hi Yaron, > > Thank you very much for taking the time to write such a thoughtful and > detailed review. I really appreciate it, and I learned a great deal from it. > > I agree with the concerns you raise, and reading them carefully, I came to > think that the key question is how the use case is defined. The > request-response flow with its nonce, issuer recognition, selective > disclosure and privacy, wallets acting on behalf of people, and governance > limiting which credential types a wallet can obtain all apply to > credentials held in wallets and presented through OpenID4VP, and in those > cases I fully agree that OpenID4VP is the right tool. > > What this draft has in mind is a narrower case. The holder is a non-human > client that controls its own key, and the credential is issued by an > authorization server or IdP the resource server already trusts, so from the > resource server's point of view it sits in the same place as an access > token. Although the resource server does not request the credential, it can > still supply its own nonce through DPoP-Nonce, and the cnf key is set and > signed by an issuer it already trusts, so my understanding is that holder > binding is established in the same way as for a DPoP-bound access token. If > you see a gap there, I would be very grateful for your guidance. Your > comments made me realize this scope did not come through clearly enough in > the draft, and I will make it explicit in the next revision. > > I also realize that within this scope the credential is very close to an > access token. Coming from the credential side, what I would still like to > do is find some first step that lets verifiable credentials flow over > existing OAuth infrastructure, and this narrow case seemed the safest place > to start. I would value your perspective on whether this is a reasonable > way to begin. > > On audience, thank you for the concrete suggestions. I will reflect both > approaches you described, multiple resource values yielding a multi-valued > aud and an agreed aud value within one trust domain, and recommend a fresh > mint with an accurate aud across unrelated resource servers, as you advised. > > Thank you again for your time and generosity. > > Best regards, > Su-hyeon > > -----Original Message----- > *From:* "Yaron ZEHAVI"<yaron.zehavi=40rbinternational.com@dmarc.ietf.org> > *To:* "Su-hyeon Forten Lee"<nine01223@naver.com>; "Warren Parad"<wparad= > 40rhosys.ch@dmarc.ietf.org>; > *Cc:* "oauth@ietf.org"<oauth@ietf.org>; > *Sent:* 2026-09-29 (화) 19:26:32 (GMT+09:00) > *Subject:* [OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signed JWT > Credentials to Resource Servers with DPoP > > Dear Su-hyeon, > > > > While a resource server can indeed be a credential verifier, the exchange > of credential presentations in OpenID4VP is different from using access > tokens: > > > - Clients send tokens to resource servers in unsolicited HTTP calls, > while OpenID4VP credential presentation is a response to a credential > request which contains a nonce to be included in the signed presentation > response as replay protection mechanism. > > - A resource server cannot safely accept a credential unless obtained > through a presentation request it created, as it can’t establish holder > binding. > > - The basic idea to use credential key binding as DPoP might be > feasible, but: > > - Credentials are not access tokens, so their structure might be > unsuitable for processing by resource servers (e.g issuer not recognized). > > - Sending the entire credential and not a presentation of selected > attributes could hinder subject’s privacy. > > - Credentials are stored in wallets, so in human OBO use-cases the > agent / client would have a presentation and not control the keys to make > presentations. > > - Non human wallet holders would control both the credentials and > their keys, but would encounter previously mentioned challenges as well as > governance frameworks would likely limit eligible wallets which can obtain > certain credential types (e.g won’t issue an EU PID credential representing > a natural person to an agent’s wallet). > > > > > That said, the audience challenge you mention could be solved in other > ways, such as: > > > - Requesting tokens with resource request parm specifying multiple > values à obtains token with multi-value aud > > - Multiple resource servers in the same trust domain could accept an > agreed aud value, making the token usable for them all > > > > > Where multiple unrelated resource servers are concerned, a fresh mint with > accurate aud value is the most secure approach. > > > > I hope this helps > > Yaron > > > > > Classification: GENERAL > > *From:* Su-hyeon Forten Lee <nine01223@naver.com> > *Sent:* Monday, September 28, 2026 3:23 PM > *To:* Warren Parad <wparad=40rhosys.ch@dmarc.ietf.org> > *Cc:* oauth@ietf.org > *Subject:* [OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signed JWT > Credentials to Resource Servers with DPoP > > > > You don't often get email from nine01223@naver.com. Learn why this is > important <https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderIdentification> > > This message is from an external sender - be cautious, particularly with > links and attachments. > > > > Hi Warren, > > > > Thank you for the feedback, I appreciate you taking the time. I think you > are right that, seen from OAuth, nothing here is new, and I should have > made that clearer up front: in a way, that is what the document is trying > to say. > > > > On aud, I should be candid that this was the part I struggled with most. > The access tokens DPoP is used with in practice require aud, and making it > optional in the draft may well have been a stretch. My thinking was that > the holder is the right party to decide the audience; that is what a > presentation is. But the only aud available is inside the issuer-signed > JWT, and the holder cannot set it without breaking the issuer's signature, > unless one adopts a holder-signed wrapper as in the VP model, which is what > I was trying to avoid. The DPoP proof's htu binds the request, but it is > not an audience. I do not have a good answer yet, and it needs more thought. > > > > I come from the credential side, where it is often assumed that a verifier > needs to run OpenID4VP. What I hoped to record is that a DPoP-capable > resource server can already serve as a presentation verifier for > SD-JWT-based credentials, with only a few small rules: matching cnf.jwk > against cnf.jkt, computing ath over the presented SD-JWT including its > disclosures so that the DPoP proof serves as the key binding, and > distinguishing such a credential from an access token by typ. > > > > I suspect I found exciting what is simply ordinary in OAuth, and the draft > shows it. I will revise several parts with this in mind. > > > > Thanks again for the comments. > > > > Best regards, > > Su-hyeon > > > > -----Original Message----- > *From:* "Warren Parad"<wparad=40rhosys.ch@dmarc.ietf.org> > *To:* "이수현"<nine01223@naver.com>; > *Cc:* <oauth@ietf.org>; > *Sent:* 2026-09-28 (월) 21:47:57 (GMT+09:00) > *Subject:* [OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signed JWT > Credentials to Resource Servers with DPoP > > What does the audience matter here? The audience claim is optional, what > are you trying to do that DPoP doesn't already support, that's the part > which isn't clear for me. I'm also not sure what agents have to do with > this, A client interacts with multiple resource servers RS, but what ends > up in the token is responsibility of the AS, if you don't want audience in > the token, your AS doesn't have to put one there, right? > > > > So I'm still not really sure what can't be done today, or what the change > is that the draft advocates for. As a bit of feedback, it feels like most > if not all of the draft is defining what already exists as a summary of > OAuth, JWTs, and DPoP, and I'm not sure why. > > > > On Mon, Sep 28, 2026 at 12:57 PM 이수현 <nine01223@naver.com> wrote: > > Hi Warren, > > > > Thank you for taking the time to read it, and fair point: the introduction > is too abstract. > > > > Some context: I come from the credential side. > > In MCP and A2A, OAuth is the first-class mechanism, and from where I sit > the goal is for credentials to fit into that as closely as possible. > > OpenID4VP is excellent where a verifier needs to negotiate with a wallet, > but that is not this use case. > > What struck me is that a DPoP proof already has essentially the same > structure as the key binding in a verifiable presentation, so an ordinary > DPoP-capable resource server is, in effect, already a presentation verifier. > > > > Concretely: a user delegates to an agent, and the agent calls several > resource servers (e.g. MCP tool servers) in the same trust domain. > > With access tokens, the agent needs a separate audience-restricted token > for each resource server. > > > > The draft lets the AS, or an IdP the resource servers already trust, issue > one holder-bound credential that the agent presents to each resource server > directly with DPoP, with revocation through a status list. > > If the issuer sets aud, it is enforced as usual, and it can list the set > of resource servers the credential is meant for. > > If aud is omitted, the credential is more flexible, at the cost of > per-resource audience restriction. > > > > Does this make the use case clearer? > > If you think an existing mechanism already covers it, I would appreciate a > pointer. > > > > Best regards, > > Su-hyeon > > > > -----Original Message----- > *From:* "Warren Parad"<wparad@rhosys.ch> > *To:* "이수현"<nine01223@naver.com>; > *Cc:* <oauth@ietf.org>; > *Sent:* 2026-09-28 (월) 19:00:47 (GMT+09:00) > *Subject:* Re: [OAUTH-WG] New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signed JWT > Credentials to Resource Servers with DPoP > > I'm pretty confused by this. I don't really understand what defines or the > specific use case that is different from the existing mechanisms. > > > > I think the most poignant question for me would be related to this > statement in the draft: > * The gap is most visible for AI agents.* > > > > What gap? > > > > On Mon, Sep 28, 2026 at 11:31 AM 이수현 <nine01223@naver.com> wrote: > > Hi all, > > > > I have posted a new individual draft: > > > https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-lee-oauth-dpop-credential-presentation/ > > > > It lets a client present an issuer-signed JWT credential directly to > a resource server using DPoP (RFC 9449), with no authorization server or > OpenID4VP flow in between. > > The wire format is that of a DPoP-bound access token; the draft adds only > three rules: the issuer is an AS or IdP the resource server already trusts, > the credential may carry no issuer-set audience, and the resource server > checks its status. > > > > The motivation is clients that can simply submit a credential, such as > AI agents calling MCP or A2A endpoints, for which OpenID4VP is more than > needed. > > It follows the pattern of draft-ietf-oauth-attestation-based-client-auth, > but for the holder's credential rather than client authentication. > > > > Comments are very welcome. > > > > Best regards, > > Su-hyeon Forten Lee > > _______________________________________________ > OAuth mailing list -- oauth@ietf.org > To unsubscribe send an email to oauth-leave@ietf.org > > > This message and any attachment ("the Message") are confidential. If you > have received the Message in error, please notify the sender immediately > and delete the Message from your system, any use of the Message is > forbidden. Correspondence via e-mail is primarily for information purposes. > RBI neither makes nor accepts legally binding statements via e-mail unless > explicitly agreed otherwise. Information pursuant to § 14 Austrian > Companies Code: Raiffeisen Bank International AG; Registered Office: Am > Stadtpark 9 > <https://www.google.com/maps/search/Am+Stadtpark+9?entry=gmail&source=g>, > 1030 Vienna, Austria; Company Register Number: FN 122119m at the Commercial > Court of Vienna (Handelsgericht Wien). > _______________________________________________ > OAuth mailing list -- oauth@ietf.org > To unsubscribe send an email to oauth-leave@ietf.org > > _______________________________________________ > OAuth mailing list -- oauth@ietf.org > To unsubscribe send an email to oauth-leave@ietf.org > -- Regards Ashwin Ambekar
- [OAUTH-WG] New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signed JW… 이수현
- [OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signe… Warren Parad
- [OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signe… 이수현
- [OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signe… Warren Parad
- [OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signe… Su-hyeon Forten Lee
- [OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signe… Yaron ZEHAVI
- [OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signe… Su-hyeon Forten Lee
- [OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signe… Warren Parad
- [OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signe… Su-hyeon Forten Lee
- [OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signe… Warren Parad
- [OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signe… Su-hyeon Forten Lee
- [OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signe… Warren Parad
- [OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signe… Su-hyeon Forten Lee
- [OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signe… Warren Parad
- [OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signe… Su-hyeon Forten Lee
- [OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signe… Ashwin Ambekar
- [OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signe… Su-hyeon Forten Lee
- [OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signe… Jijie Wei
- [OAUTH-WG] Re: New draft: Presenting Issuer-Signe… Su-hyeon Forten Lee