[Openpgp-dt] 2022-05-31 design team notes

[Stephen Farrell <[e-mail]>]

OpenPGP Design Team

2022-05-31

Present:
dkg
gniibe
huigens
sftcd
justus

# Agenda

## Reportback from OpenPGP E-mail Summit
- about 20 attended, 8-10 different projects
- broad discussion, incl. PQ, discovery, deprecation, ...
- plenty of interest in moving fwd, many topics could be part of a 
rechartered WG
- there'll be a report we can send to the WG list in a bit (hopefully)
- ACTION (dkg): if no report in a week or so, will send some of his 
notes to the WG mailing list
- there wasn't any alarm about the currently chartered work though not 
clear people had devled into it yet though some had read some v5 drafts 
(v5 wasn't a major topic for that meeting)
- there was some discussion of best-before dates for algs that might fit 
with openpgp in future (or even sooner)

## Next steps for a new draft
- !187 - ACTION on dkg to do stuff (see last week)
- !195 - ACTION on gniibe to reframe this as a "MUST NOT decrypt SED 
with ECDH, since there is no legitimate archival data with this combination"
- stuff to be done (ACTION editor: do 'em:-)
- author list changes (as discussed last week)
- paul had comments on !190 - they seem ok for him to fix as needed, 
then merge
- !194 has approvals so ready to merge
- once actions above on !187 and !195 are done, they should be ready to 
merge
- once above done we'd like editor to emit new I-D (ACTION dkg: ping paul)

## Next steps to enter WG LC
- once I-D published chairs will start WGLC ending @ july 3rd (if we get 
next I-D by june 10)
- we'll ask for comments as MRs/Issues in gitlab if possible, but if we 
get 'em on mailing list design-team folks will map those to MRs/Issues
- chairs should encourage comment (clean up, whatever) that improves doc
- RFC9760 would be 4880*2 and 2440*4, we could ask

## IETF 114 plans
- discuss WGLC comments then as time permits, re-chartering
- chairs can ask list for re-chartering ideas to be sent after end of 
WGLC (so july 3-10 roughly) chairs will develop agenda for rechartering 
discussion accordingly
- chairs: let AD know these plans
- DT member(s) may prefer Monday meeting (action SF modify session req)

## Any more info on gitlab policy changes?
- dkg chatted with gitlab person, who seemed to understand issues, 
pending contact with a/c mgr-type and member of OSS team in gitlab, more 
contact planned ACTION: dkg to ask questions of their two teams, and 
report back
- still non-urgent, would become urgent if random people can't create issues