Re: [OPSAWG] Minutes of L3NM/L2NM module discussions (27th-May-2020)

[Qin Wu <[e-mail]>]

And on that topic, your operational-type is used for both admin and oper status.  It seems to me that admin status would either be up or down (or maybe something like testing such as in the ietf-interfaces module).  The oper-status may be richer.

And in your grouping for service-status, you have a timestamp tied to admin that should indicate the _actual_ date and time of the service being up or down.  This won’t necessarily be the case for an admin status.

[Qin]: Agree with Joe, two points to add here:

1.       why tie timestamp with both admin and oper status, why not define additional leaf for timestamp within service-status container?

2.       since operational-type is used for both admin and oper status, I think operation-type could be extended to support additional function, such as testing.

In addition, I would two additional typedefs



typedef oper-status {

type operational-type;

description

"Defines a type representing the operational status of

a vpn service.";

}

typedef admin-status {

type operational-type;

description

"Defines a type representing the administrative status of

a vpn service.";
}

Joe