[vnfpool] 答复: comments on VNF Pool Charter

[Zongning <[e-mail]>]

Hi, Kapil,

Thanks for the review. Please see inline.

Hello All,

A couple comments, maybe questions, on the VNF Charter:

1.      The point below indicates “to collect network information”…did you consider collecting the platform information as well?  I would suggest to add that.

[Ning] I’d think “platform information” may be too general term to be focused. In our charter, we collect network information for specific purpose, e.g., place a live and backup VNF instances into distributed physical locations, or locations without shared risk in the network. Could you please elaborate more on the purpose of using any specific piece of platform information, or give some use cases? We could then think about how to make it more focused, as required by the charter.


2.      Please clarify the scope of the protocols work within the charter.  Current text says “re-chartering before adopting any work to develop new, or extend existing, protocols”.  But, it also says that group will work on 2 protocols.

[Ning] Current charter lists a set of interfaces/protocols to be standardized, but will only delivers documents such as requirements to these interfaces/protocols, and architecture highlighting the functionalities of these interfaces/protocols. The protocol development, i.e., specifying on-the-wire message format, will be after the re-chartering.

Best Regards,

Kapil.

Hope my reply helps.

Thanks.

-Ning