Re: [e2md] Doodle poll: Next Conf-Call on Requirements

Hi Bernie,  folks,
 I am slightly confused. The Dean & Rich show does that :)p

This looks rather like a Bait 'n' Switch deal.

AFAICT, there is an idea to revive the ENUM WG and to work on
*some* of the items in that. I agree++ with that -- ENUM Vivax!
In fact, on list everyone has agreed with that and our friendly
channeled demons don't seem to have raised a complaint yet :).

For ENUM (as opposed to any other WG) ...
First Step:
I'd guess that revival could work on Send-N and Unused.
[Assuming we can roll back some of the more arcane restrictions
in section 1.2 of rfc3761bis and the bit moved into the second
paragraph of the intro of section 2].
These **should** be short term work items.

Even CNAM and SPID could be done in the existing ENUM WG as well,
I suspect. Heck -- we have number portability already, so why not?

Second step:
In the past the IESG appear to have resisted URIs that do not act as
"direct" session initiators to Internet services.
I remember the protracted pain of pushing against that resistance (that
initially included use of telephone numbers, video telephony service,
and even SMS §-/

So ... ISTM that it might be useful to re-charter ENUM to extend its
remit to either unwind these alleged but unwritten rules (or write
them in stone so at last we know what the limits ARE).

-----

SO ... what is the other stuff that you are asking for requirements,
and some seem to be thinking of other RR types, use of other protocols,
indirection, ... ?

It sure isn't ENUM. I seem to have lost track. Clarification required.

all the best,
  Lawrence

On 18 May 2010, at 19:54, Bernie Hoeneisen wrote:

> Hi,
> 
> As decided at the last conf call, we will have a dedicated conf call on requirements / use cases.
> 
> Please indicate your availabilities on Doodle:
> 
>  http://www.doodle.com/3hqunikiwxzkrez5
> 
> 
> Goals:
> 
> * Get a common understanding on the set of requirements and use cases
>  we are going to address
> 
> 
> Topics:
> 
> * List of Requirements (draft version)
>  http://trac.tools.ietf.org/bof/e2md/trac/wiki/RequirementsList
> 
> * Use Cases (under construction)
>  http://trac.tools.ietf.org/bof/e2md/trac/wiki/UseCases
> 
> Note: No other topics are discussed during this call.
> 
> Looking forward to you Doodle responses!
> 
> cheers,
> Bernie
> _______________________________________________
> e2md mailing list
> e2md@ietf.org
> https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/e2md