Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-manderson-routing-intent-00.txt
Pedro Torres <torres@pop-pr.rnp.br> Mon, 22 August 2011 19:52 UTC
Return-Path: <backup2.torres@gmail.com>
X-Original-To: grow@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: grow@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 5E95A21F8C9E for <grow@ietfa.amsl.com>; Mon, 22 Aug 2011 12:52:05 -0700 (PDT)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -1.347
X-Spam-Level:
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-1.347 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-2.599, FM_FORGED_GMAIL=0.622, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_LOW=-1, SARE_PROLOSTOCK_SYM3=1.63]
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([12.22.58.30]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id UJXIitrV5vqq for <grow@ietfa.amsl.com>; Mon, 22 Aug 2011 12:52:02 -0700 (PDT)
Received: from mail-ww0-f44.google.com (mail-ww0-f44.google.com [74.125.82.44]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id E244421F8C73 for <grow@ietf.org>; Mon, 22 Aug 2011 12:52:01 -0700 (PDT)
Received: by wwf5 with SMTP id 5so3620377wwf.13 for <grow@ietf.org>; Mon, 22 Aug 2011 12:53:07 -0700 (PDT)
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=gmail.com; s=gamma; h=mime-version:sender:in-reply-to:references:date :x-google-sender-auth:message-id:subject:from:to:cc:content-type :content-transfer-encoding; bh=u+fpoB4CIsIwQty0b91lwoTwg+wsPws7PNMpjs9/qkY=; b=fP/mm/ktUKbzzqSvoV9cyao0Nj0rK1hheJzKoiZ3ET5EmOQ0ZjJ8TEegKh0pr8cyIl ETmmRZ9rvEtIavr6WNzeRnqCouNKOchIhqLLfKt7on+nJkfw5KFi04C1vu5IUjkOX7/1 c395aqTx2F6DI9+c7fXorSF50Jt0ax9fkOqeM=
MIME-Version: 1.0
Received: by 10.227.11.75 with SMTP id s11mr25508wbs.10.1314042785110; Mon, 22 Aug 2011 12:53:05 -0700 (PDT)
Sender: backup2.torres@gmail.com
Received: by 10.227.69.17 with HTTP; Mon, 22 Aug 2011 12:53:05 -0700 (PDT)
In-Reply-To: <FFAFF430-C75C-45DC-BC64-AF75A3B00D3B@lacnic.net>
References: <CA783D40.19739%terry.manderson@icann.org> <FFAFF430-C75C-45DC-BC64-AF75A3B00D3B@lacnic.net>
Date: Mon, 22 Aug 2011 16:53:05 -0300
X-Google-Sender-Auth: zywLr1eCyvj-IHKu31LP9emLUp4
Message-ID: <CAPfnYRhvgDZZfnQffGSVYorQ5YpvQC-4EqHYGCi8dgE0MDi+OQ@mail.gmail.com>
From: Pedro Torres <torres@pop-pr.rnp.br>
To: "grow@ietf.org" <grow@ietf.org>
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="ISO-8859-1"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable
Subject: Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-manderson-routing-intent-00.txt
X-BeenThere: grow@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.12
Precedence: list
List-Id: Grow Working Group Mailing List <grow.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/grow>, <mailto:grow-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <http://www.ietf.org/mail-archive/web/grow>
List-Post: <mailto:grow@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:grow-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/grow>, <mailto:grow-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Mon, 22 Aug 2011 19:52:05 -0000
Dears, I don't know if GROW WG is the best place to suggest such modifications to IANA but I appreciate Terry I-D. Acctually we see these things in IANA IPv4 Address Space Registry: 192/8 Administered by ARIN 172/8 Administered by ARIN Was 192.168/16 or 172.16/12 allocated by ARIN? I really appreciate the idea to show more specific allocations in this IANA document. I am not sure if the column PRI is the best way to do this but a new way to show ALL IANA allocated prefixes with a reasonable designation could be nice. -- Pedro On Mon, Aug 22, 2011 at 3:00 PM, Arturo Servin <aservin@lacnic.net> wrote: > Terry > > Who defines that one of the other is routable or not? > > For example, 179/8. It assigned to LACNIC but we cannot claim that the whole /8 is routable. It would depend in the allocations and the organisations that are received them to decide if their assignment is or not routable. > > For the rest, I have the following comments (Version 0 looked very different to v1 / v2): > > - I see the importance of the PRI in IANA IPv4 Special Purpose Address Registry but > - I do not see any technical advantage to include that information in the IPv4 and IPv6 registries (as my comment about 179/8) > > > "The IANA address registries currently do not have a uniform and > consistent nomenclature to signal if an allocation is intended to be > publicly routed" > > Because they are mainly /8 (v4) and /12 (v6) assigned to RIRs, there is no need for any signal or it is irrelevant. > > > "Work is underway in the IETF to design and document a number of > systems or architectures to facilitate the desire to secure the > Internet routing system." > > Yes, RPKI is the place and technology to do this, not PRI IMHO. > > "Such work will require an explicit statement as to the > intended public routability of an allocation." > > May be (I think it does not), but in any case, the IANA registry is not the place. Also, IANA does not have that information. Neither RIRs. > > "This document directs IANA to extend all the IPv4 and IPv6 address > registries to record Public Routing Intent (PRI) as either "Routable" > or "Not Routable". > > IANA does not have the mechanisms to do that. > > Also I think that we are going to waters that we should not go (this is going between the technical and policies fields). > > Regards, > .as > > > > On 22 Aug 2011, at 04:07, Terry Manderson wrote: > >> >> On 18/08/11 10:35 AM, "Terry Manderson" <terry.manderson@icann.org> wrote: >> >>> >>> To help, I will come back to the list soon with a full synthesized IPv4 >>> registry based on what it looks like today. That includes PRI and and >>> entries for the more specific reserved prefixes. This can augment the >>> understanding from the example in the draft. >>> >> >> Below is a IANA IPv4 address registry synthesized to how it _might_ look >> after routing-intent-02 is implemented. I stopped at the Multicast >> allocations.. >> >> It's probable that line wrapping may occur. >> >> >> Prefix Designation Date Whois >> Status [1] PRI Note >> 000/8 IANA - Local Identification 1981-09 >> RESERVED Not Routable [2] >> 001/8 APNIC 2010-01 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 002/8 RIPE NCC 2009-09 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 003/8 General Electric Company 1994-05 >> LEGACY Routable >> 004/8 Level 3 Communications, Inc. 1992-12 >> LEGACY Routable >> 005/8 RIPE NCC 2010-11 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 006/8 Army Information Systems Center 1994-02 >> LEGACY Routable >> 007/8 Administered by ARIN 1995-04 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 008/8 Level 3 Communications, Inc. 1992-12 >> LEGACY Routable >> 009/8 IBM 1992-08 >> LEGACY Routable >> 010/8 IANA - Private Use 1995-06 >> RESERVED Not Routable [3] >> 011/8 DoD Intel Information Systems 1993-05 >> LEGACY Routable >> 012/8 AT&T Bell Laboratories 1995-06 >> LEGACY Routable >> 013/8 Xerox Corporation 1991-09 >> LEGACY Routable >> 014/8 APNIC 2010-04 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable [4] >> 015/8 Hewlett-Packard Company 1994-07 >> LEGACY Routable >> 016/8 Digital Equipment Corporation 1994-11 >> LEGACY Routable >> 017/8 Apple Computer Inc. 1992-07 >> LEGACY Routable >> 018/8 MIT 1994-01 >> LEGACY Routable >> 019/8 Ford Motor Company 1995-05 >> LEGACY Routable >> 020/8 Computer Sciences Corporation 1994-10 >> LEGACY Routable >> 021/8 DDN-RVN 1991-07 >> LEGACY Routable >> 022/8 Defense Information Systems Agency 1993-05 >> LEGACY Routable >> 023/8 ARIN 2010-11 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 024/8 ARIN 2001-05 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 025/8 UK Ministry of Defence 1995-01 >> whois.ripe.net LEGACY Routable >> 026/8 Defense Information Systems Agency 1995-05 >> LEGACY Routable >> 027/8 APNIC 2010-01 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 028/8 DSI-North 1992-07 >> LEGACY Routable >> 029/8 Defense Information Systems Agency 1991-07 >> LEGACY Routable >> 030/8 Defense Information Systems Agency 1991-07 >> LEGACY Routable >> 031/8 RIPE NCC 2010-05 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 032/8 AT&T Global Network Services 1994-06 >> LEGACY Routable >> 033/8 DLA Systems Automation Center 1991-01 >> LEGACY Routable >> 034/8 Halliburton Company 1993-03 >> LEGACY Routable >> 035/8 MERIT Computer Network 1994-04 >> LEGACY Routable >> 036/8 APNIC 2010-10 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 037/8 RIPE NCC 2010-11 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 038/8 PSINet, Inc. 1994-09 >> LEGACY Routable >> 039/8 APNIC 2011-01 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 040/8 Eli Lily & Company 1994-06 >> LEGACY Routable >> 041/8 AfriNIC 2005-04 >> whois.afrinic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 042/8 APNIC 2010-10 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 043/8 Administered by APNIC 1991-01 >> LEGACY Routable >> 044/8 Amateur Radio Digital Communications 1992-07 >> LEGACY Routable >> 045/8 Administered by ARIN 1995-01 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 046/8 RIPE NCC 2009-09 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 047/8 Bell-Northern Research 1991-01 >> LEGACY Routable >> 048/8 Prudential Securities Inc. 1995-05 >> LEGACY Routable >> 049/8 APNIC 2010-08 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 050/8 ARIN 2010-02 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 051/8 UK Government Department for Work and Pensions 1994-08 >> whois.ripe.net LEGACY Routable >> 052/8 E.I. duPont de Nemours and Co., Inc. 1991-12 >> LEGACY Routable >> 053/8 Cap Debis CCS 1993-10 >> LEGACY Routable >> 054/8 Merck and Co., Inc. 1992-03 >> LEGACY Routable >> 055/8 DoD Network Information Center 1995-04 >> LEGACY Routable >> 056/8 US Postal Service 1994-06 >> LEGACY Routable >> 057/8 SITA 1995-05 >> LEGACY Routable >> 058/8 APNIC 2004-04 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 059/8 APNIC 2004-04 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 060/8 APNIC 2003-04 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 061/8 APNIC 1997-04 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 062/8 RIPE NCC 1997-04 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 063/8 ARIN 1997-04 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 064/8 ARIN 1999-07 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 065/8 ARIN 2000-07 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 066/8 ARIN 2000-07 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 067/8 ARIN 2001-05 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 068/8 ARIN 2001-06 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 069/8 ARIN 2002-08 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 070/8 ARIN 2004-01 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 071/8 ARIN 2004-08 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 072/8 ARIN 2004-08 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 073/8 ARIN 2005-03 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 074/8 ARIN 2005-06 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 075/8 ARIN 2005-06 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 076/8 ARIN 2005-06 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 077/8 RIPE NCC 2006-08 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 078/8 RIPE NCC 2006-08 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 079/8 RIPE NCC 2006-08 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 080/8 RIPE NCC 2001-04 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 081/8 RIPE NCC 2001-04 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 082/8 RIPE NCC 2002-11 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 083/8 RIPE NCC 2003-11 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 084/8 RIPE NCC 2003-11 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 085/8 RIPE NCC 2004-04 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 086/8 RIPE NCC 2004-04 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 087/8 RIPE NCC 2004-04 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 088/8 RIPE NCC 2004-04 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 089/8 RIPE NCC 2005-06 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 090/8 RIPE NCC 2005-06 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 091/8 RIPE NCC 2005-06 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 092/8 RIPE NCC 2007-03 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 093/8 RIPE NCC 2007-03 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 094/8 RIPE NCC 2007-07 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 095/8 RIPE NCC 2007-07 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 096/8 ARIN 2006-10 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 097/8 ARIN 2006-10 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 098/8 ARIN 2006-10 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 099/8 ARIN 2006-10 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 100/8 ARIN 2010-11 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 101/8 APNIC 2010-08 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 102/8 AfriNIC 2011-02 >> whois.afrinic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 103/8 APNIC 2011-02 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 104/8 ARIN 2011-02 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 105/8 AfriNIC 2010-11 >> whois.afrinic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 106/8 APNIC 2011-01 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 107/8 ARIN 2010-02 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 108/8 ARIN 2008-12 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 109/8 RIPE NCC 2009-01 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 110/8 APNIC 2008-11 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 111/8 APNIC 2008-11 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 112/8 APNIC 2008-05 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 113/8 APNIC 2008-05 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 114/8 APNIC 2007-10 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 115/8 APNIC 2007-10 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 116/8 APNIC 2007-01 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 117/8 APNIC 2007-01 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 118/8 APNIC 2007-01 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 119/8 APNIC 2007-01 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 120/8 APNIC 2007-01 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 121/8 APNIC 2006-01 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 122/8 APNIC 2006-01 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 123/8 APNIC 2006-01 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 124/8 APNIC 2005-01 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 125/8 APNIC 2005-01 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 126/8 APNIC 2005-01 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 127/8 IANA - Loopback 1981-09 >> RESERVED Not Routable [5] >> 128/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 129/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 130/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 131/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 132/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 133/8 Administered by APNIC 1997-03 >> whois.apnic.net LEGACY Routable >> 134/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 135/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 136/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 137/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 138/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 139/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 140/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 141/8 Administered by RIPE NCC 1993-05 >> whois.ripe.net LEGACY Routable >> 142/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 143/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 144/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 145/8 Administered by RIPE NCC 1993-05 >> whois.ripe.net LEGACY Routable >> 146/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 147/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 148/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 149/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 150/8 Administered by APNIC 1993-05 >> whois.apnic.net LEGACY Routable >> 151/8 Administered by RIPE NCC 1993-05 >> whois.ripe.net LEGACY Routable >> 152/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 153/8 Administered by APNIC 1993-05 >> whois.apnic.net LEGACY Routable >> 154/8 Administered by AfriNIC 1993-05 >> whois.afrinic.net LEGACY Routable >> 155/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 156/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 157/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 158/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 159/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 160/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 161/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 162/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 163/8 Administered by APNIC 1993-05 >> whois.apnic.net LEGACY Routable >> 164/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 165/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 166/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 167/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 168/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 169.0.0.0/9 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 169.127.0.0/9 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 169.128.0.0/10 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 169.192.0.0/11 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 169.193.0.0/11 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 169.194.0.0/11 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 169.224.0.0/13 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 169.232.0.0/13 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 169.240.0.0/13 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 169.248.0.0/14 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 169.252.0.0/15 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 169.254.0.0/16 IANA - Link Local 2005-05 >> RESERVED Not Routable [6] >> 170/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 171/8 Administered by APNIC 1993-05 >> whois.apnic.net LEGACY Routable >> 172.0.0.0/12 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 172.16.0.0/12 IANA - Private Use 1996-02 >> RESERVED Not Routable [7] >> 172.32.0.0/11 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 172.64.0.0/10 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 172.128.0.0/9 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 173/8 ARIN 2008-02 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 174/8 ARIN 2008-02 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 175/8 APNIC 2009-08 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 176/8 RIPE NCC 2010-05 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 177/8 LACNIC 2010-06 >> whois.lacnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 178/8 RIPE NCC 2009-01 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 179/8 LACNIC 2011-02 >> whois.lacnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 180/8 APNIC 2009-04 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 181/8 LACNIC 2010-06 >> whois.lacnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 182/8 APNIC 2009-08 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 183/8 APNIC 2009-04 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 184/8 ARIN 2008-12 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 185/8 RIPE NCC 2011-02 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 186/8 LACNIC 2007-09 >> whois.lacnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 187/8 LACNIC 2007-09 >> whois.lacnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 188/8 Administered by RIPE NCC 1993-05 >> whois.ripe.net LEGACY Routable >> 189/8 LACNIC 1995-06 >> whois.lacnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 190/8 LACNIC 1995-06 >> whois.lacnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 191/8 Administered by LACNIC 1993-05 >> whois.lacnic.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.0.0.0/24 IPv4 Special Purpose Address Registry 2010-01 >> RESERVED [9] >> 192.0.1.0/24 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.0.2.0/24 IANA TEST-NET-1 2010-01 >> RESERVED Not Routable [8] >> 192.0.3.0/24 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.0.4.0/22 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.0.8.0/21 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.0.16.0/20 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.0.32.0/19 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.0.64.0/18 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.0.128.0/17 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.1.0.0/16 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.2.0.0/15 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.4.0.0/14 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.8.0.0/13 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.16.0.0/12 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.32.0.0/11 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.64.0.0/12 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.80.0.0/13 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.88.0.0/18 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.88.0.0/18 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.88.0.0/18 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.88.64.0/19 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.88.96.0/23 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.88.98.0/24 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.88.99.0/24 6to4 Relay Anycast 2001-06 >> RESERVED Routable [8] >> 192.88.100.0/22 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.88.104.0/21 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.88.112.0/20 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.88.128.0/17 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.89.0.0/16 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.90.0.0/15 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.92.0.0/14 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.96.0.0/11 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.128.0.0/11 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.160.0.0/13 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.168.0.0/16 IANA Private Use 2001-06 >> RESERVED Not Routable [8] >> 192.169.0.0/16 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.170.0.0/15 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.172.0.0/14 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.176.0.0/12 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 192.192.0.0/10 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 193/8 RIPE NCC 1993-05 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 194/8 RIPE NCC 1993-05 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 195/8 RIPE NCC 1993-05 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 196/8 Administered by AfriNIC 1993-05 >> whois.afrinic.net LEGACY Routable >> 197/8 AfriNIC 2008-10 >> whois.afrinic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 198/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY [10] >> 198.0/12 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 198.16/15 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 198.18/15 IANA - RFC5735 1999-03 RESERVED >> Not Routable [10] >> 198.20/14 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 198.24/13 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 198.32/12 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 198.48/15 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 198.50/16 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 198.51.0/18 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 198.51.64/19 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 198.51.96/22 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 198.51.96/22A Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 198.51.100.0/24 IANA - TEST-NET-2 2010-01 >> RESERVED Not Routable [10] >> 198.51.101/24 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 198.51.102/23 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 198.51.102/23 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 198.51.112/20 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 198.51.128/17 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 198.52/14 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 198.56/13 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 198.64/10 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 198.128/9 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable >> 199/8 ARIN 1993-05 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 200/8 LACNIC 2002-11 >> whois.lacnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 201/8 LACNIC 2003-04 >> whois.lacnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 202/8 APNIC 1993-05 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 203.0.0.0/18 APNIC 1993-05 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 203.0.64.0/19 APNIC 1993-05 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 203.0.96.0/20 APNIC 1993-05 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 203.0.112.0/24 APNIC 1993-05 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 203.0.113.0/24 IANA TEST-NET-3 2010-01 RESERVED >> Not Routable [11] >> 203.0.114.0/23 APNIC 1993-05 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 203.0.116.0/22 APNIC 1993-05 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 203.0.120.0/21 APNIC 1993-05 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 203.0.128.0/17 APNIC 1993-05 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 203.1.0.0/16 APNIC 1993-05 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 203.2.0.0/15 APNIC 1993-05 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 203.4.0.0/14 APNIC 1993-05 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 203.8.0.0/13 APNIC 1993-05 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 203.16.0.0/12 APNIC 1993-05 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 203.32.0.0/11 APNIC 1993-05 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 203.64.0.0/10 APNIC 1993-05 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 203.128.0.0/9 APNIC 1993-05 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 204/8 ARIN 1994-03 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 205/8 ARIN 1994-03 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 206/8 ARIN 1995-04 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 207/8 ARIN 1995-11 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 208/8 ARIN 1996-04 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 209/8 ARIN 1996-06 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 210/8 APNIC 1996-06 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 211/8 APNIC 1996-06 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 212/8 RIPE NCC 1997-10 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 213/8 RIPE NCC 1993-10 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 214/8 US-DOD 1998-03 >> LEGACY Routable >> 215/8 US-DOD 1998-03 >> LEGACY Routable >> 216/8 ARIN 1998-04 >> whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 217/8 RIPE NCC 2000-06 >> whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 218/8 APNIC 2000-12 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 219/8 APNIC 2001-09 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 220/8 APNIC 2001-12 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 221/8 APNIC 2002-07 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 222/8 APNIC 2003-02 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> 223/8 APNIC 2010-04 >> whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable >> >> >> Cheers >> Terry >> >> _______________________________________________ >> GROW mailing list >> GROW@ietf.org >> https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/grow > > _______________________________________________ > GROW mailing list > GROW@ietf.org > https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/grow >
- [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft-man… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Benson Schliesser
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Benson Schliesser
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Arturo Servin
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Arturo Servin
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Arturo Servin
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Geoff Huston
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Geoff Huston
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Geoff Huston
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Geoff Huston
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Arturo Servin
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Pedro Torres
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Arturo Servin
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Pedro Torres
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Arturo Servin
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Nick Hilliard
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Geoff Huston
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Joel jaeggli
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Joel jaeggli