Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-manderson-routing-intent-00.txt
Arturo Servin <aservin@lacnic.net> Mon, 22 August 2011 18:00 UTC
Return-Path: <aservin@lacnic.net>
X-Original-To: grow@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: grow@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 38AA421F8B3F for <grow@ietfa.amsl.com>; Mon, 22 Aug 2011 11:00:03 -0700 (PDT)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -1.785
X-Spam-Level:
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-1.785 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[AWL=-0.815, BAYES_00=-2.599, NO_RELAYS=-0.001, SARE_PROLOSTOCK_SYM3=1.63]
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([12.22.58.30]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id O07+QcX09Lql for <grow@ietfa.amsl.com>; Mon, 22 Aug 2011 11:00:00 -0700 (PDT)
Received: from mail.lacnic.net.uy (mail.lacnic.net.uy [IPv6:2001:13c7:7001:4000::3]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id CE50121F8B38 for <grow@ietf.org>; Mon, 22 Aug 2011 10:59:57 -0700 (PDT)
Received: from [IPv6:2001:13c7:7001:5128:1c63:5443:aa79:219f] (unknown [IPv6:2001:13c7:7001:5128:1c63:5443:aa79:219f]) by mail.lacnic.net.uy (Postfix) with ESMTP id BF743308447; Mon, 22 Aug 2011 15:00:48 -0300 (UYT)
Mime-Version: 1.0 (Apple Message framework v1244.3)
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"
From: Arturo Servin <aservin@lacnic.net>
In-Reply-To: <CA783D40.19739%terry.manderson@icann.org>
Date: Mon, 22 Aug 2011 15:00:48 -0300
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable
Message-Id: <FFAFF430-C75C-45DC-BC64-AF75A3B00D3B@lacnic.net>
References: <CA783D40.19739%terry.manderson@icann.org>
To: Terry Manderson <terry.manderson@icann.org>
X-Mailer: Apple Mail (2.1244.3)
X-LACNIC.uy-MailScanner-Information: Please contact the ISP for more information
X-LACNIC.uy-MailScanner: Found to be clean
X-LACNIC.uy-MailScanner-SpamCheck:
X-LACNIC.uy-MailScanner-From: aservin@lacnic.net
Cc: "grow@ietf.org" <grow@ietf.org>
Subject: Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-manderson-routing-intent-00.txt
X-BeenThere: grow@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.12
Precedence: list
List-Id: Grow Working Group Mailing List <grow.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/grow>, <mailto:grow-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <http://www.ietf.org/mail-archive/web/grow>
List-Post: <mailto:grow@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:grow-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/grow>, <mailto:grow-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Mon, 22 Aug 2011 18:00:03 -0000
Terry Who defines that one of the other is routable or not? For example, 179/8. It assigned to LACNIC but we cannot claim that the whole /8 is routable. It would depend in the allocations and the organisations that are received them to decide if their assignment is or not routable. For the rest, I have the following comments (Version 0 looked very different to v1 / v2): - I see the importance of the PRI in IANA IPv4 Special Purpose Address Registry but - I do not see any technical advantage to include that information in the IPv4 and IPv6 registries (as my comment about 179/8) "The IANA address registries currently do not have a uniform and consistent nomenclature to signal if an allocation is intended to be publicly routed" Because they are mainly /8 (v4) and /12 (v6) assigned to RIRs, there is no need for any signal or it is irrelevant. "Work is underway in the IETF to design and document a number of systems or architectures to facilitate the desire to secure the Internet routing system." Yes, RPKI is the place and technology to do this, not PRI IMHO. "Such work will require an explicit statement as to the intended public routability of an allocation." May be (I think it does not), but in any case, the IANA registry is not the place. Also, IANA does not have that information. Neither RIRs. "This document directs IANA to extend all the IPv4 and IPv6 address registries to record Public Routing Intent (PRI) as either "Routable" or "Not Routable". IANA does not have the mechanisms to do that. Also I think that we are going to waters that we should not go (this is going between the technical and policies fields). Regards, .as On 22 Aug 2011, at 04:07, Terry Manderson wrote: > > On 18/08/11 10:35 AM, "Terry Manderson" <terry.manderson@icann.org> wrote: > >> >> To help, I will come back to the list soon with a full synthesized IPv4 >> registry based on what it looks like today. That includes PRI and and >> entries for the more specific reserved prefixes. This can augment the >> understanding from the example in the draft. >> > > Below is a IANA IPv4 address registry synthesized to how it _might_ look > after routing-intent-02 is implemented. I stopped at the Multicast > allocations.. > > It's probable that line wrapping may occur. > > > Prefix Designation Date Whois > Status [1] PRI Note > 000/8 IANA - Local Identification 1981-09 > RESERVED Not Routable [2] > 001/8 APNIC 2010-01 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 002/8 RIPE NCC 2009-09 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 003/8 General Electric Company 1994-05 > LEGACY Routable > 004/8 Level 3 Communications, Inc. 1992-12 > LEGACY Routable > 005/8 RIPE NCC 2010-11 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 006/8 Army Information Systems Center 1994-02 > LEGACY Routable > 007/8 Administered by ARIN 1995-04 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 008/8 Level 3 Communications, Inc. 1992-12 > LEGACY Routable > 009/8 IBM 1992-08 > LEGACY Routable > 010/8 IANA - Private Use 1995-06 > RESERVED Not Routable [3] > 011/8 DoD Intel Information Systems 1993-05 > LEGACY Routable > 012/8 AT&T Bell Laboratories 1995-06 > LEGACY Routable > 013/8 Xerox Corporation 1991-09 > LEGACY Routable > 014/8 APNIC 2010-04 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable [4] > 015/8 Hewlett-Packard Company 1994-07 > LEGACY Routable > 016/8 Digital Equipment Corporation 1994-11 > LEGACY Routable > 017/8 Apple Computer Inc. 1992-07 > LEGACY Routable > 018/8 MIT 1994-01 > LEGACY Routable > 019/8 Ford Motor Company 1995-05 > LEGACY Routable > 020/8 Computer Sciences Corporation 1994-10 > LEGACY Routable > 021/8 DDN-RVN 1991-07 > LEGACY Routable > 022/8 Defense Information Systems Agency 1993-05 > LEGACY Routable > 023/8 ARIN 2010-11 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 024/8 ARIN 2001-05 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 025/8 UK Ministry of Defence 1995-01 > whois.ripe.net LEGACY Routable > 026/8 Defense Information Systems Agency 1995-05 > LEGACY Routable > 027/8 APNIC 2010-01 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 028/8 DSI-North 1992-07 > LEGACY Routable > 029/8 Defense Information Systems Agency 1991-07 > LEGACY Routable > 030/8 Defense Information Systems Agency 1991-07 > LEGACY Routable > 031/8 RIPE NCC 2010-05 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 032/8 AT&T Global Network Services 1994-06 > LEGACY Routable > 033/8 DLA Systems Automation Center 1991-01 > LEGACY Routable > 034/8 Halliburton Company 1993-03 > LEGACY Routable > 035/8 MERIT Computer Network 1994-04 > LEGACY Routable > 036/8 APNIC 2010-10 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 037/8 RIPE NCC 2010-11 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 038/8 PSINet, Inc. 1994-09 > LEGACY Routable > 039/8 APNIC 2011-01 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 040/8 Eli Lily & Company 1994-06 > LEGACY Routable > 041/8 AfriNIC 2005-04 > whois.afrinic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 042/8 APNIC 2010-10 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 043/8 Administered by APNIC 1991-01 > LEGACY Routable > 044/8 Amateur Radio Digital Communications 1992-07 > LEGACY Routable > 045/8 Administered by ARIN 1995-01 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 046/8 RIPE NCC 2009-09 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 047/8 Bell-Northern Research 1991-01 > LEGACY Routable > 048/8 Prudential Securities Inc. 1995-05 > LEGACY Routable > 049/8 APNIC 2010-08 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 050/8 ARIN 2010-02 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 051/8 UK Government Department for Work and Pensions 1994-08 > whois.ripe.net LEGACY Routable > 052/8 E.I. duPont de Nemours and Co., Inc. 1991-12 > LEGACY Routable > 053/8 Cap Debis CCS 1993-10 > LEGACY Routable > 054/8 Merck and Co., Inc. 1992-03 > LEGACY Routable > 055/8 DoD Network Information Center 1995-04 > LEGACY Routable > 056/8 US Postal Service 1994-06 > LEGACY Routable > 057/8 SITA 1995-05 > LEGACY Routable > 058/8 APNIC 2004-04 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 059/8 APNIC 2004-04 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 060/8 APNIC 2003-04 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 061/8 APNIC 1997-04 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 062/8 RIPE NCC 1997-04 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 063/8 ARIN 1997-04 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 064/8 ARIN 1999-07 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 065/8 ARIN 2000-07 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 066/8 ARIN 2000-07 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 067/8 ARIN 2001-05 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 068/8 ARIN 2001-06 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 069/8 ARIN 2002-08 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 070/8 ARIN 2004-01 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 071/8 ARIN 2004-08 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 072/8 ARIN 2004-08 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 073/8 ARIN 2005-03 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 074/8 ARIN 2005-06 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 075/8 ARIN 2005-06 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 076/8 ARIN 2005-06 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 077/8 RIPE NCC 2006-08 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 078/8 RIPE NCC 2006-08 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 079/8 RIPE NCC 2006-08 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 080/8 RIPE NCC 2001-04 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 081/8 RIPE NCC 2001-04 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 082/8 RIPE NCC 2002-11 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 083/8 RIPE NCC 2003-11 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 084/8 RIPE NCC 2003-11 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 085/8 RIPE NCC 2004-04 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 086/8 RIPE NCC 2004-04 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 087/8 RIPE NCC 2004-04 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 088/8 RIPE NCC 2004-04 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 089/8 RIPE NCC 2005-06 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 090/8 RIPE NCC 2005-06 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 091/8 RIPE NCC 2005-06 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 092/8 RIPE NCC 2007-03 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 093/8 RIPE NCC 2007-03 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 094/8 RIPE NCC 2007-07 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 095/8 RIPE NCC 2007-07 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 096/8 ARIN 2006-10 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 097/8 ARIN 2006-10 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 098/8 ARIN 2006-10 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 099/8 ARIN 2006-10 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 100/8 ARIN 2010-11 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 101/8 APNIC 2010-08 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 102/8 AfriNIC 2011-02 > whois.afrinic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 103/8 APNIC 2011-02 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 104/8 ARIN 2011-02 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 105/8 AfriNIC 2010-11 > whois.afrinic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 106/8 APNIC 2011-01 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 107/8 ARIN 2010-02 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 108/8 ARIN 2008-12 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 109/8 RIPE NCC 2009-01 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 110/8 APNIC 2008-11 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 111/8 APNIC 2008-11 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 112/8 APNIC 2008-05 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 113/8 APNIC 2008-05 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 114/8 APNIC 2007-10 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 115/8 APNIC 2007-10 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 116/8 APNIC 2007-01 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 117/8 APNIC 2007-01 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 118/8 APNIC 2007-01 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 119/8 APNIC 2007-01 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 120/8 APNIC 2007-01 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 121/8 APNIC 2006-01 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 122/8 APNIC 2006-01 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 123/8 APNIC 2006-01 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 124/8 APNIC 2005-01 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 125/8 APNIC 2005-01 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 126/8 APNIC 2005-01 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 127/8 IANA - Loopback 1981-09 > RESERVED Not Routable [5] > 128/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 129/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 130/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 131/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 132/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 133/8 Administered by APNIC 1997-03 > whois.apnic.net LEGACY Routable > 134/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 135/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 136/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 137/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 138/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 139/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 140/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 141/8 Administered by RIPE NCC 1993-05 > whois.ripe.net LEGACY Routable > 142/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 143/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 144/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 145/8 Administered by RIPE NCC 1993-05 > whois.ripe.net LEGACY Routable > 146/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 147/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 148/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 149/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 150/8 Administered by APNIC 1993-05 > whois.apnic.net LEGACY Routable > 151/8 Administered by RIPE NCC 1993-05 > whois.ripe.net LEGACY Routable > 152/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 153/8 Administered by APNIC 1993-05 > whois.apnic.net LEGACY Routable > 154/8 Administered by AfriNIC 1993-05 > whois.afrinic.net LEGACY Routable > 155/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 156/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 157/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 158/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 159/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 160/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 161/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 162/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 163/8 Administered by APNIC 1993-05 > whois.apnic.net LEGACY Routable > 164/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 165/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 166/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 167/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 168/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 169.0.0.0/9 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 169.127.0.0/9 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 169.128.0.0/10 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 169.192.0.0/11 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 169.193.0.0/11 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 169.194.0.0/11 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 169.224.0.0/13 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 169.232.0.0/13 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 169.240.0.0/13 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 169.248.0.0/14 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 169.252.0.0/15 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 169.254.0.0/16 IANA - Link Local 2005-05 > RESERVED Not Routable [6] > 170/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 171/8 Administered by APNIC 1993-05 > whois.apnic.net LEGACY Routable > 172.0.0.0/12 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 172.16.0.0/12 IANA - Private Use 1996-02 > RESERVED Not Routable [7] > 172.32.0.0/11 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 172.64.0.0/10 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 172.128.0.0/9 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 173/8 ARIN 2008-02 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 174/8 ARIN 2008-02 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 175/8 APNIC 2009-08 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 176/8 RIPE NCC 2010-05 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 177/8 LACNIC 2010-06 > whois.lacnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 178/8 RIPE NCC 2009-01 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 179/8 LACNIC 2011-02 > whois.lacnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 180/8 APNIC 2009-04 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 181/8 LACNIC 2010-06 > whois.lacnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 182/8 APNIC 2009-08 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 183/8 APNIC 2009-04 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 184/8 ARIN 2008-12 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 185/8 RIPE NCC 2011-02 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 186/8 LACNIC 2007-09 > whois.lacnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 187/8 LACNIC 2007-09 > whois.lacnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 188/8 Administered by RIPE NCC 1993-05 > whois.ripe.net LEGACY Routable > 189/8 LACNIC 1995-06 > whois.lacnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 190/8 LACNIC 1995-06 > whois.lacnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 191/8 Administered by LACNIC 1993-05 > whois.lacnic.net LEGACY Routable > 192.0.0.0/24 IPv4 Special Purpose Address Registry 2010-01 > RESERVED [9] > 192.0.1.0/24 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.0.2.0/24 IANA TEST-NET-1 2010-01 > RESERVED Not Routable [8] > 192.0.3.0/24 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.0.4.0/22 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.0.8.0/21 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.0.16.0/20 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.0.32.0/19 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.0.64.0/18 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.0.128.0/17 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.1.0.0/16 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.2.0.0/15 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.4.0.0/14 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.8.0.0/13 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.16.0.0/12 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.32.0.0/11 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.64.0.0/12 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.80.0.0/13 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.88.0.0/18 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.88.0.0/18 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.88.0.0/18 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.88.64.0/19 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.88.96.0/23 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.88.98.0/24 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.88.99.0/24 6to4 Relay Anycast 2001-06 > RESERVED Routable [8] > 192.88.100.0/22 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.88.104.0/21 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.88.112.0/20 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.88.128.0/17 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.89.0.0/16 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.90.0.0/15 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.92.0.0/14 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.96.0.0/11 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.128.0.0/11 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.160.0.0/13 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.168.0.0/16 IANA Private Use 2001-06 > RESERVED Not Routable [8] > 192.169.0.0/16 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.170.0.0/15 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.172.0.0/14 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.176.0.0/12 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 192.192.0.0/10 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 193/8 RIPE NCC 1993-05 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 194/8 RIPE NCC 1993-05 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 195/8 RIPE NCC 1993-05 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 196/8 Administered by AfriNIC 1993-05 > whois.afrinic.net LEGACY Routable > 197/8 AfriNIC 2008-10 > whois.afrinic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 198/8 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY [10] > 198.0/12 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 198.16/15 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 198.18/15 IANA - RFC5735 1999-03 RESERVED > Not Routable [10] > 198.20/14 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 198.24/13 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 198.32/12 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 198.48/15 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 198.50/16 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 198.51.0/18 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 198.51.64/19 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 198.51.96/22 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 198.51.96/22A Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 198.51.100.0/24 IANA - TEST-NET-2 2010-01 > RESERVED Not Routable [10] > 198.51.101/24 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 198.51.102/23 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 198.51.102/23 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 198.51.112/20 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 198.51.128/17 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 198.52/14 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 198.56/13 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 198.64/10 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 198.128/9 Administered by ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net LEGACY Routable > 199/8 ARIN 1993-05 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 200/8 LACNIC 2002-11 > whois.lacnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 201/8 LACNIC 2003-04 > whois.lacnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 202/8 APNIC 1993-05 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 203.0.0.0/18 APNIC 1993-05 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 203.0.64.0/19 APNIC 1993-05 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 203.0.96.0/20 APNIC 1993-05 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 203.0.112.0/24 APNIC 1993-05 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 203.0.113.0/24 IANA TEST-NET-3 2010-01 RESERVED > Not Routable [11] > 203.0.114.0/23 APNIC 1993-05 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 203.0.116.0/22 APNIC 1993-05 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 203.0.120.0/21 APNIC 1993-05 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 203.0.128.0/17 APNIC 1993-05 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 203.1.0.0/16 APNIC 1993-05 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 203.2.0.0/15 APNIC 1993-05 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 203.4.0.0/14 APNIC 1993-05 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 203.8.0.0/13 APNIC 1993-05 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 203.16.0.0/12 APNIC 1993-05 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 203.32.0.0/11 APNIC 1993-05 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 203.64.0.0/10 APNIC 1993-05 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 203.128.0.0/9 APNIC 1993-05 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 204/8 ARIN 1994-03 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 205/8 ARIN 1994-03 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 206/8 ARIN 1995-04 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 207/8 ARIN 1995-11 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 208/8 ARIN 1996-04 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 209/8 ARIN 1996-06 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 210/8 APNIC 1996-06 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 211/8 APNIC 1996-06 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 212/8 RIPE NCC 1997-10 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 213/8 RIPE NCC 1993-10 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 214/8 US-DOD 1998-03 > LEGACY Routable > 215/8 US-DOD 1998-03 > LEGACY Routable > 216/8 ARIN 1998-04 > whois.arin.net ALLOCATED Routable > 217/8 RIPE NCC 2000-06 > whois.ripe.net ALLOCATED Routable > 218/8 APNIC 2000-12 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 219/8 APNIC 2001-09 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 220/8 APNIC 2001-12 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 221/8 APNIC 2002-07 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 222/8 APNIC 2003-02 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > 223/8 APNIC 2010-04 > whois.apnic.net ALLOCATED Routable > > > Cheers > Terry > > _______________________________________________ > GROW mailing list > GROW@ietf.org > https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/grow
- [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft-man… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Benson Schliesser
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Benson Schliesser
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Arturo Servin
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Arturo Servin
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Arturo Servin
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Geoff Huston
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] FW: New Version Notification for draft… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Geoff Huston
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Geoff Huston
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Geoff Huston
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Arturo Servin
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Pedro Torres
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Arturo Servin
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Pedro Torres
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Arturo Servin
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Nick Hilliard
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Terry Manderson
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Geoff Huston
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Joel jaeggli
- Re: [GROW] New Version Notification for draft-man… Joel jaeggli