[Ietf-dkim] Re: DKIM2 / DMARC Sender Policy Proposal

Emanuel Schorsch <emschorsch@gmail.com> Fri, 23 October 2026 17:56 UTC

Received: from mail-ua1-x92d.google.com (mail-ua1-x92d.google.com [IPv6:2607:f8b0:4864:20::92d]) (using TLSv1.3 with cipher TLS_AES_256_GCM_SHA384 (256/256 bits) key-exchange x25519 server-signature ECDSA (prime256v1) server-digest SHA256) (No client certificate requested) by mx.ietf.org (Postfix) with ESMTPS id A28B046 for <Ietf-dkim@ietf.org>; Fri, 23 Oct 2026 17:56:57 +0000 (UTC)
Authentication-Results: mx.ietf.org; dkim=pass header.d=gmail.com header.s=20251104 header.b=ID8uIVVx; spf=pass (mx.ietf.org: domain of emschorsch@gmail.com designates 2607:f8b0:4864:20::92d as permitted sender) smtp.mailfrom=emschorsch@gmail.com; arc=pass ("google.com:s=arc-20260327:i=1"); dmarc=pass (policy=none) header.from=gmail.com
Received: by mail-ua1-x92d.google.com with SMTP id a1e0cc1a2514c-988bb309c2bso682585241.1 for <Ietf-dkim@ietf.org>; Fri, 23 Oct 2026 10:56:57 -0700 (PDT)
ARC-Seal: i=1; a=rsa-sha256; t=1792778211; cv=none; d=google.com; s=arc-20260327; b=R6FgMY9Fkbs+qE0rb7iBTToLKUyVUYS4JaqcUCScSsW2JjDZIsaRk8De8ZzKBeUEbj vTrVC27QY6B/mRjzgXcbE7NJJsNzKWjPh4A42X3SjnzbR3rJX586lCzLbzF3CewqqDBo y9w2tLkh+7afDRcIWNeZvIEq+gkZkC5VbDUrsrDH8Jo3QjNM8UxPBv0BRryhkJ7C6rhC V0MH5qIz+1T3xiO38tPCUHV5+KcRDMosaDme3Z0GLbTReUFGgTGrwllWHKpiKCKMMVJU uhIzCTGD3F/zoSiLnhI3Z5SPktGNv2nKfTT3S6iiGyTG93svDFPNIGeMdhjr55aZ0KzB KlkA==
ARC-Message-Signature: i=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=google.com; s=arc-20260327; h=cc:to:subject:message-id:date:from:in-reply-to:references :mime-version:dkim-signature; bh=aszf0Cey+FWeJ5jUXclpKDUJzH9bncwamhJrpKsedkY=; fh=kGy6yJs2GuClRw1uC1upAcSElwwvoBk9hNyD4evI9mI=; b=Rcz6ay0xd+CQM5jGF5YnvupLDlpstyZKwdkYGccPHPYJpe4QSbm84PkIK9HJIOgsep A2HOVcGuWZ49ri6Pqcplzjf5KLND5uwKh5iD4JnCb1BbX001JbeXKagB+ETnzTB9XPtJ QW5a+y+gPjyTwCGuwIvtihuBweTjjibY4vahsyGOWpsFPVSvrOsP6EsVp01OVuEzX0Fv G5dckQj1aPElRaf6lJn8LLt5LDfrcRxdG2D4fCc+IvVT42nK5X8G1Rtt03s+VulPcvRv K0+mBtPg8SjS5EEldEExZrWwmgfWnaYRQvBfw7YKo4Q0mJgMwl/STDyRV6mKlYuPMzEh nmxA==; darn=ietf.org
ARC-Authentication-Results: i=1; mx.google.com; arc=none
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=gmail.com; s=20251104; t=1792778211; x=1793383011; darn=ietf.org; h=content-type:cc:to:subject:message-id:date:from:in-reply-to :references:mime-version:from:to:cc:subject:date:message-id:reply-to :content-type; bh=aszf0Cey+FWeJ5jUXclpKDUJzH9bncwamhJrpKsedkY=; b=ID8uIVVxDyqtqZ8ZNOay2kgcPOZOq6/Jx7edxRxSgoeYJqgv41DESrVvREULA46PgK oxrZQe2BAUMvFf5HWs8XnI+UDZWMxg7y2jyVwBr1FdM1ey0uuylau4oa0THsTtazhT5r rzD6dbXM3EWkn5r4hfncgti0oJR1sUd8lK4g7+ie5e/6nxp8v1tT25aWWgmy+v+addZy wTGiUquynCl35MyIW1R6G28bVgbO9GyYcmS2hWvC3HRw2C+sgJ94ZMs8rjI4V1Eh3i2I lU6Wtgwx7H4YOimY0AASeebIKK02bmhwfadDL1fmOKxk/BWxQHL78mFwbRa0VlrPhxrY VKKQ==
X-Google-DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=1e100.net; s=20260707; t=1792778211; x=1793383011; h=content-type:cc:to:subject:message-id:date:from:in-reply-to :references:mime-version:x-gm-gg:x-gm-message-state:from:to:cc :subject:date:message-id:reply-to:content-type; bh=aszf0Cey+FWeJ5jUXclpKDUJzH9bncwamhJrpKsedkY=; b=eFLND2GOYSMsbmg+8fAlKKLIvt9mw7BnicOHBWJv9Xti4jN/GdaneRntvI23A6ozJp GeNCu51w5hm7r2pG9YbNx8TgMVFWTbXM9qGvCbWUuJSqveBqDpID4J4F3APS2UGsnxHp ckeK2jHy+3qYaCRdae8LnwP1l9Nrn0YypfKsx0ZYdUxdlFQHvzosDZfWt3sb4TQWlMAg bW1qLNf9D94s2nnW2rStkTSlQ4bfwH2f1YX3MTtFTDDtr1JZywk9RyK/v48zTJ3l8yko lTxXzFOwl+u9hckynLclmKWAii09qE2BlrRPd1Nd7JdK/WsNHc9R6eCuMOrXz81IvYTb rW4w==
X-Forwarded-Encrypted: i=1; AKwUvBxDSU8Zba9CJhtZbfEQeo7Qlwr5pQxVLRAomIrdFbCN4UgkavvrdzHNdjTtJD+mdI1cxzfohgXHKXA=@ietf.org
X-Gm-Message-State: AFq9FYK55E3C44h7oeFrcglNkETnNiTuTMW9AkfCplSYHiQ95ARxvzlI SV7MVjfT8fooOx8v2lzi2tZofB0Y6q5CAzWUzBXxS6P2G5P1T63zXj+Dnq8hkInohtRcA+dQ+Ry fRHMvaoG/LZP8VAigJgRHfX38cXppcnk=
X-Gm-Gg: AYBFou2PtGV9VpHhErAxImAVtCLlWtGsZFJzC3BAiKLQ3AktHtaplP+Y+P8P0PXHXMD odTqEgaixDTEaTeCT6s89ptRMW6ioHneQMTtiRy19yL6QwAs6ECFDzPCnpuAuMcTj8PbdXM+NWD soqd3j9dTJGZ2K1R2O/3a6P6jLnWWSsHt+TdMglgND4mUvn5L9uXc8Dhl2NuVMmt1xnq5E89OUv 2CywjuHzsUAF2+omxdtKvxGqEjW6bTxqI3IDPb1CbENJzvYh6Ti59LCWYDs5rGvy2sWppX1Y52g eI7My8Ff7nym0mPUCmkw7QeolSix6uf43a1mkTJ4CKxN3uL3rYSVB5RjSEUOzyZe6gW8tHJPRW5 9hUJkafjbaCX55cpPx9+Yeof06noPZMT04O70t1KjyZHc0o/3
X-Received: by 2002:a05:6102:b02:b0:7c2:7a0:ae28 with SMTP id ada2fe7eead31-7ccc33a56b4mr1399306137.30.1792778210961; Fri, 23 Oct 2026 10:56:50 -0700 (PDT)
MIME-Version: 1.0
References: <CAAFsWK1M--tCPj=Nhz8jB-9uaoeiJcdmfBZKaJsAXFaT4Z9fgQ@mail.gmail.com> <CAHEDGu8h9wyukuj+yDT+LQH-hk32iPbdrQ4sxny6KoKMYYyzxQ@mail.gmail.com> <CAAFsWK3jepdeMzQi5Whs4chDF2daAR0-5ED672WaLP73MG1VTw@mail.gmail.com> <CAAFsWK1K-1br3fOrr5=tc-GahaJwki8=cGH2g=pxfKre=auViw@mail.gmail.com> <CAMhUCqLk3+hZbqKOZ5234BJo=dhX0Gn8VV1xRNAOQenjFZvdxg@mail.gmail.com> <CAAFsWK0FLF2zb06Uc_UmhsWT3tNTkhLBYAu_qLLtjpowr5N93A@mail.gmail.com> <PR3P193MB050519ADCD0C265556254325D1BE2@PR3P193MB0505.EURP193.PROD.OUTLOOK.COM> <CAAFsWK1ucEx2uDqQq9zSAQtYdZb5gqeAizwQczNryNug6H6dhA@mail.gmail.com> <CAAFsWK3-S9krHyGBBJ6hkUROfyXGsGsNqddyjfkez8=4qw0A_g@mail.gmail.com> <CAMhUCqJxq_22UU3kGew2GoedcxpAgUMFxq7o1M5GcmdFb=_H0w@mail.gmail.com> <CAHEDGu_jzhmoY4U+OreBp3PbvS4cb-LExNrY+vjXQ8Ddx=gKYQ@mail.gmail.com> <CAAFsWK2Td43CdLa9=XnEBb2Uuy2bfCcAuO2y3=THkESw0yzh1w@mail.gmail.com> <CAHEDGu-11sgVCWoFYPVvxLdjO7GatboW7d03+DwZf0O0qqHTJg@mail.gmail.com> <CAAFsWK3t=fMTF=CfhiwtvgVER9ieyjvCwT6Um7DNYU5LFmnY7Q@mail.gmail.com> <evvENQS7G9qqFAic@highwayman.com> <CAAFsWK26ugerMCQZPwRy=ic=CKFGoaiSiLDD1KZHs4p6wCgM4g@mail.gmail.com> <EZMiwEBwp$rqFAre@highwayman.com> <CAAFsWK11ErGjV-4t1Bi5qD-VCFxcYD1Ba8=B=aO7v0JBHPzqjA@mail.gmail.com> <CAAFsWK2ArAP-cm7UJ0vb3o2N=saJM05bZ+PQSdQZ7gE-2yP+eA@mail.gmail.com> <CAAFsWK0vgCVs1jO9G11y42uYGu0TaD3FsMvcFYhBeq2g05ku=Q@mail.gmail.com>
In-Reply-To: <CAAFsWK0vgCVs1jO9G11y42uYGu0TaD3FsMvcFYhBeq2g05ku=Q@mail.gmail.com>
From: Emanuel Schorsch <emschorsch@gmail.com>
Date: Fri, 23 Oct 2026 10:56:14 -0700
X-Gm-Features: AclHuK9ARVV70OyOKmGk9bFR23B_J6pQsXst18Ha5_LLwYMWCyhGdfv4oy-DiSQ
Message-ID: <CAHEDGu_2-ySm_hm7=Rs_Upmf_oFAsWRYsEAKRwRS-1-HBSDOLw@mail.gmail.com>
To: Wei Chuang <weihaw@google.com>
Content-Type: multipart/alternative; boundary="0000000000006cee22065e85b467"
X-Spamd-Bar: --------------------------
Message-ID-Hash: HW25CVOW2QMWMVZTR64DC2BSO46MXNKG
X-Message-ID-Hash: HW25CVOW2QMWMVZTR64DC2BSO46MXNKG
X-MailFrom: emschorsch@gmail.com
X-Mailman-Rule-Misses: dmarc-mitigation; no-senders; approved; loop; banned-address; header-match-ietf-dkim.ietf.org-0; emergency; member-moderation; nonmember-moderation; administrivia; implicit-dest; max-recipients; max-size; news-moderation; no-subject; digests; suspicious-header
CC: Richard Clayton <richard@highwayman.com>, Ietf-dkim@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 3.3.10
Precedence: list
Subject: [Ietf-dkim] Re: DKIM2 / DMARC Sender Policy Proposal
List-Id: IETF DKIM List <ietf-dkim.ietf.org>
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/ietf-dkim/8NH-VJJ93f3z3f9Pvho-U9WrPU0>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/ietf-dkim>
List-Help: <mailto:ietf-dkim-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Owner: <mailto:ietf-dkim-owner@ietf.org>
List-Post: <mailto:ietf-dkim@ietf.org>
List-Subscribe: <mailto:ietf-dkim-join@ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <mailto:ietf-dkim-leave@ietf.org>

Hi Wei,

I'm still very concerned about the security and safety risks being
introduced by allowing a DMARC pass for body changes even if they don't
munge the From. I think it introduces serious phishing and spear phishing
risks for sensitive domains that should not be the default spec behavior. A
DKIM2 intermediary that legitimately received a message could replace the
body with a phishing message, record a Recipe that restores the original,
and deliver it with a DMARC pass for the author's domain. With donotmodify
removed in -07, the domain owner has no way to prevent this. I think a
DMARC pass should keep meaning what it means with DKIM today: the From
domain signed the content as delivered.

I made some specific changes below to how sections 2.1 and 2.2.2 choose the
From header field and signature used for DMARC alignment. I think any of
them would be reasonable.

Section 2.1: replace the text about the From recovered at i=1 (and the
sentence in 2.2.2 that refers back to it) with:

   The Author Domain is taken from the RFC5322 From header field of
   the message as delivered, as in [RFC9989].

Section 2.2.2: replace "the DKIM2 signature d= domain at the
Originator (i=1)" with:

   the Signing Domain of the highest numbered DKIM2-Signature header
   field, without an nd= tag, whose Signing Domain is a relaxed domain
   match for the Author Domain. Alignment holds only if the message
   has not been modified since that DKIM2-Signature header field was
   created.

What follows is three different ways to define "not modified", from loosest
to
strictest (all seem reasonable to me):

1. Body only (the From is Body-Authentic, as proposed in
   https://github.com/dkim2wg/spec/pull/13)

   the body hash recorded in the Message-Instance header field
   identified by its m= tag equals the body hash of the message as
   delivered.

2. Body and Subject:

   as in (1), and no Message-Instance header field with an m= value
   higher than that DKIM2-Signature header field's m= tag contains a
   Header Recipe for the Subject header field.

3. Body and signed header fields, as DKIM treats them:

   as in (1); every header field that was present when that
   DKIM2-Signature header field was created is still present and
   unchanged; and no From, Reply-To, Subject, Date, To or Cc header
   field has been added since.

Option (3) is how DKIM behaves today for a signer that signs the
header fields present and over-signs the core fields, as RFC 6376
sections 5.4.2 and 8.15 recommend. A header field the author signed
cannot be changed or removed. New header fields such as List-Id can be
added, but the core fields cannot. Verifiers already reconstruct the
earlier state of the message when checking the chain, so the check is
a comparison of two sets of header fields.

For mailing lists that do not rewrite From, all three options keep
the pass when the list only adds List-* header fields, and lose it
when the list adds a footer. (2) also catches Subject tags, but would
let other signed fields such as Reply-To or To be changed. (1) lets
Subject tags through as well.

Thanks,
Emanuel

On Mon, Sep 21, 2026 at 12:13 AM Wei Chuang <weihaw@google.com> wrote:

> Some more bug fixes in -03:
> https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-chuang-dkim2-sender-policy/03/
>
> -Wei
>
> On Sun, Sep 20, 2026 at 4:44 PM Wei Chuang <weihaw@google.com> wrote:
>
>> I've updated the document to -02:
>>
>> https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-chuang-dkim2-sender-policy/02/
>>
>> This strips out mention of support for policy lookup or alignment
>> requirements at i=n.  This also strips out mention of From header field
>> rewriting.  Various subsection headers have been clarified.
>> -Wei
>>
>> On Sun, Sep 20, 2026 at 1:22 PM Wei Chuang <weihaw@google.com> wrote:
>>
>>>
>>>
>>> On Sun, Sep 20, 2026 at 8:24 AM Richard Clayton <richard@highwayman.com>
>>> wrote:
>>>
>>>>
>>>> >It's possible I'm overreading the relationship
>>>> >between draft-ietf-dkim-dkim2-spec and this proposal, and if fact what
>>>> you
>>>> >are proposing is to support i=1.  If so, as Pietro points out,
>>>> evaluating
>>>> >DMARC at i=1 can simplify this proposal.
>>>>
>>>> I am in favour of the "enhanced-for-DKIM2 DMARC" and relevant MUAs using
>>>> the i=1 value of the RFC5322 header field.
>>>>
>>>> But whatever we decide, the notion that every hop rewrites the RFC5322
>>>> - From header field is nonsense. Your draft says that. If you think my
>>>> - -spec document says that then please cite the paragraph and will
>>>> ensure
>>>> that the text is modified appropriately
>>>>
>>>>
>>> My document says this, and I'm stripping that text out.
>>> -Wei
>>>
>>>
>> _______________________________________________
> Ietf-dkim mailing list -- ietf-dkim@ietf.org
> To unsubscribe send an email to ietf-dkim-leave@ietf.org
>