Re: [Isis-wg] FW: I-D Action: draft-white-openfabric-00.txt

["Russ White" <[e-mail]>]

>    OpenFabric implementations MUST NOT be mixed with standard IS-IS
>    implementations in operational deployments.  OpenFabric and standard
>    IS-IS implementations SHOULD be treated as two separate protocols.
> ---
> 
> any hard feelings about using MI as a way of guaranteeing that the two
> protocols are shielded from each other ?

Very good idea -- want to suggest text?

> 2) Modified Adjacency Formation
> 
> rather than doing the "only one adjacency is up" (which we did prior to
the
> graceful-restart SA bit) - suggest to use the graceful-restart 'SA'
> bit, such that a node can bring up the adjacency without generating a new
> LSP. The LSP can then be generated if the initial-sync is done (and the
new
> LSP arrival rate indicates that the dust is settling) such that the LSP
may get
> released.

This is a really good idea, actually... Again, you want to suggest text? :-)


> 3) Flooding Optimization
> it looks to me you have re-invented the OLSR MPR set.
> https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc3626#section-8.2
> perhaps you may want to add a reference.

Very close -- but there's a tiny bit more optimization because of the fixed
topology than can be wrung out of that and/or the other MANET drafts. I
should actually add ref's to all of them, thanks for pointing this out.

:-)

Russ