re: proposal for random selection process for nominations

[Frank Kastenholz <[e-mail]>]

Craig,

David Brandin's note had some good "knob tweaking" about this issue
(specifically, do not allow IESG/IAB members to be on the W.G.s). The
IAB/IESG presumably are "enfranschised" as a body by their special
representatives. Individuals on the IAB and IESG can always submit
information to the Nominating and Recall WGs via email, as anyone
else can (I hope!)  While this may or may not be a good thing, it
would solve this particular problem.


 > resulting slate will occasionally look suspicious to some parties.  For
 > example, what do you think the probability is if all the IAB and IESGers
 > volunteer to serve on the nominations committee, that the nominations
 > committee of 7 will have 3 or more IAB/IESG members on it (an effective
 > majority)?

--
Frank Kastenholz