Re: [rrg] feature comparison chart, conscripted peer review ?

sorry, someone pointed out a typo in (2) below;
i meant to suggest

  (2) i understand such a chart is likely blocked on more meat
  filled in on critiques/rebuttal/counterpoints for each
  proposal.  has the wg considered asking all proposal submitters
  to submit critiques of at least three (or some N) other
  proposals, including estimating the corresponding lines of
  a feature comparison matrix?

this suggestion is based on the imbalance in the
current draft between ideas-submitted and 
ideas-rigorously-evaluated. i suspect the IETF 
needs more of the latter, which it doesn't look 
like natural WG forces are going to produce.

k

On Fri, Feb 12, 2010 at 09:57:14PM -0800, k claffy wrote:

  robin

  thanks for these "Comparison charts of:
                     CES: LISP-ALT/NERD, APT, Ivip, TRRP, TIDR,
                          IRON-RANGER and Six/One Router.
                     CEE: GSE, GLI-Split, ILNP, Name-Based Sockets."

  two process questions:
  (1) is there any plan for the RRG recommendation to include a more
  complete version of such a matrix chart of proposals vs
  rrg-documented design goals, with a pointer to enough explanation
  of how well the proposal meets the design goal, or outstanding
  complications?  your charts are the first step i've seen in
  this direction, but a more comprehensive comparison chart
  would be incredibly useful.  

  (2) i understand such a chart is likely blocked on more meat
  filled in on critiques/rebuttal/counterpoints for each proposal.
  has the wg considered asking all proposal submitters to submit 
  critiques of at least other proposals, including estimating
  the corresponding lines of a feature comparison matrix?

  there is so much immense and impressive work going into this
  process, i'm just wondering out loud about structural assists
  that might improve clarity of the result and maybe even the
  efficiency of getting there.

  k 
  _______________________________________________
  rrg mailing list
  rrg@irtf.org
  http://www.irtf.org/mailman/listinfo/rrg