Re: Draft L1VPN Charter

[Alex Zinin <[e-mail]>]

Makes my skin crawl after the ITU NGN workshop earlier this week, but I can
add that. Will have to talk to the future WG chairs to clearly explain that
this shouldn't become a DoS...

-- 
Alex
http://www.psg.com/~zinin

Wednesday, May 4, 2005, 10:23:32 AM, Igor Bryskin wrote:
> Good idea.
> Igor

> [e-mail] wrote:

> igor, all - now that i am thinking of it there is probably a need to
> add a sentence like "The WG will also liaise with related ITU-T SGs"
> after "... and other WGs where necessary." 

> Igor Bryskin <[e-mail]>
> Sent by: [e-mail]
> 05/04/2005 07:18 MST

> To: Alex Zinin <[e-mail]>, Adrian Farrel <[e-mail]>,
> Dimitri PAPADIMITRIOU/BE/ALCATEL@ALCATEL, [e-mail], Kireeti
> Kompella <[e-mail]>, [e-mail]
> cc: 
> bcc: 
> Subject: Re: Draft L1VPN Charter




> Alex, All



> 2. Enhanced mode: the CE-PE interface provides the signaling capabilities
> as in the Basic mode, plus permits utilization of the provider's control
> plane for distribution of user's routing information (e.g. similar to the
> MPLS/BGP model).

> I'd like to replace this with:



> 2. Enhanced mode: the CE-PE interface provides the signaling capabilities
> as in the Basic mode, plus permits utilization of the provider's control
> plane for distribution of user's arbitrary control plane information
> between the VPN sites including but not limited to routing information.



> Provider network IHMO should make no assumptions on what protocols are
> running within VPNs. Generally speaking, a L1VPN user is not necessarily
> GMPLS controlled network. Furthermore, even in case it does use GMPLS it
> needs L1VPN CE-CE connections to provide (TE) links within VPNs.
> Specifically, the User should be capable to run LMP for such links, it
> also should be possible to establish signaling (RSVP) adjacencies between
> their ends, etc. The bottom line is that distribution of routing
> information between CEs IHMO is not sufficient. I believe this is
> consistent with the requirements stated in ITU-T SG13 L1VPN documents 



> Igor   





> Alex Zinin <[e-mail]> wrote: 

> Folks-

> Before we bring it to the l1vpn mailing list, I'd like to run this draft
> by you guys for comments.