AW: [Softwires] Notes and Consensus from Interim Meeting in Hong Kong

["Tschofenig, Hannes" <[e-mail]>]

Hi all, 

can someone explain me why IKEv2 was not chosen. To me it seems to be the obvious candidate. 

Ciao
Hannes
 

> -----Ursprüngliche Nachricht-----
> Von: David Ward [mailto:[e-mail]] 
> Gesendet: Freitag, 3. März 2006 19:01
> An: [e-mail]; Mark Townsley; Durand, Alain; David Ward
> Betreff: [Softwires] Notes and Consensus from Interim Meeting 
> in Hong Kong
> 
> All -
> 
> Many thanks to all that participated in the interim meeting. 
> We accomplished
> a lot of work and achieved consensus on selecting our 
> solution technology
> for both hub and spokes and mesh scenarios. Also many thanks 
> to Spencer
> Dawkins who performed scribe duties (and managed to keep his 
> laptop going
> after a perilous fall from his desk) and our hosts, CUHK and 
> CERNET. David
> also provided note taking duties as well.  Dah Ming Chiu from CUHK and
> Jiaping Wu from CERNET provided us meeting rooms, internet 
> access, all local
> logistical coordination, local transportation and local 
> meals. It should be
> noted that the meeting was the first official IETF meeting in 
> China and that
> we demonstrated that it is easily possible to have a successful and
> productive meeting!
> 
> 
> Here is the location of the meeting minutes:
> 
> http://bgp.nu/~dward/softwires/2006-02SoftwiresInterimNotes.html
> 
> Please send me any corrections before I submit them to the 
> secretariat. I
> will update them as appropriate.
> 
> 
> Here is a summary of what the participants achieved consensus 
> and our set of
> deliverables and next steps:
> 
> Consensus Summary:
> 
> 1 H&S scenario: L2TPv2 chosen as the immediate solution, 
> L2TPv3 in phase 2
> 2 Mesh scenario: Conjoined effort for extensions to MPBGP 
> based on work
> presented by Chris Metz and Yong Cui
> 
> 
> Deliverables (docs to be made WG docs):
> 
> General docs:
> (The names below lists the suggested authors by the WG chairs 
> and interim
> meeting participants. All are welcome to participate)
> 
> 1 Security analysis (delivered July 2006 IETF) - Florent, Shu, Carl
> 2 Radius accting (delivered July 2006 IETF) - Laurent, Bruno
> 
> Mesh:
> 1 Framework doc using MPBGP (delivered July 2006 IETF) - Chris, Yong
> 2 Multicast draft  (delivered March 2006 IETF) - Greg, Dino, 
> Jiaping Wu,
> Xing Li
> 3 Extensions (delivered July, Nov 2006 IETF)
>     1     tunnel-safi
>     2     softwire connector
>     3     softwires attributes
> 
> Hub and Spoke:
> 1 Phase 1 Framework doc using L2TPv2 (delivered July 2006 IETF) -
> Jean-Francois, Bill, Laurent, Alice, Jordi
> 2 Phase 2 Framework doc using L2TPv3 (requirements and 
> progress discussed at
> post-July '06 interim meeting, delivered Nov 2006 IETF)
> 3 Extensions (discussed next interim meeting, delivered Nov 
> '06 IETF, March
> '07 IETF)
>     1     DHCP
> 
> Proposed Agenda for Dallas Meeting - David and Alain
> 
> 1     Report from the Interim Meeting
> 2     Hubs and Spokes: Phase One L2TPv2 as selection and 
> framework overview
> 3     Mesh: BGP-MP as selection and framework overview
> 4     General documents the working group needs to take on
> 5     Next Steps and Phase 2 work discussion
> 
> NOTE: Please send us other agenda slot requests
> 
> Given that consensus was achieved between the participants of 
> the interim
> meeting, we are calling for comments on the list so that we 
> can claim WG
> consensus.
> 
> Here is the final draft of the Problem Statement that will be 
> submitted
> immediately (we made some terminology tweaks during the 
> interim meeting):
> 
> http://bgp.nu/~dward/softwires/draft-ietf-softwire-problem-sta
tement-01.txt
> 
> 
> Again many thanks to all participants in the meeting and our 
> local hosts.
> 
> -DWard, Alain
> 
> 
> _______________________________________________
> Softwires mailing list
> [e-mail]
> https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/softwires
> 

_______________________________________________
Softwires mailing list
[e-mail]
https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/softwires